Mitchells & Butlers crashes out of opco/propco deal
Leading UK pub and restaurant group Mitchells & Butlers has been forced to shelve a £4.5 billion real estate joint venture and has been plunged into turmoil following a disastrous series of hedges that cost £274 million. As Liquid Real Estate went to press, the instability had prompted a bidding war for the company.
The joint venture was planned to be with R20, an investment company owned by property tycoon Robert Tchenguiz who, not coincidentally, owns 22.05% of Mitchells & Butlers. It would have reorganized Mitchells & Butlers to release value in the company’s property portfolio using the opco/propco structure.
Although the hedges were clearly the immediate cause for the scrapping of the property joint venture, market observers believe that the decision reflects a broader trend. In December, brewer and pub company Greene King also pulled a planned opco/propco split as a result of the credit crunch and in January, French supermarket group Carrefour scrapped plans to list its €20 billion property assets.
"Being a property company is certainly less fashionable than it was 12 to 18 months ago and it would be little surprise if we saw a decline in the number of non-real estate companies that chose to separate into operating and property companies in the short term," says John Perry, head of pan-European real estate research at Deutsche Bank in London.
According to Mitchells & Butlers, the interest rate and inflation hedges were a requirement from banks underwriting the junior debt and also necessary to achieve the required ratings on the senior debt that was to fund the joint venture with R20.