Banks put their heads on the block

Block trades help to make ECM bankers look busy in quiet times. But their success rests on a knife edge. • Peter Koh reports

THIS YEAR DOZENS of bought deals have hit the equity markets as cash-hungry vendors rush to take advantage of short, sharp, news-driven rallies to offload non-core holdings. Banks that bid for these blocks do so with mixed feelings. Uncertainty, volatility and rabid competition have made them exceptionally risky. And vendors are forcing banks to take on more market and stock-specific risk than ever, pushing for fully bought deals or aggressive backstop agreements to guarantee price certainty.

A bought deal in a volatile market is not the most appetizing business for an investment bank. But there is nothing else on the menu to satisfy the hunger for league table position. There were just 98 IPOs globally in the first quarter of the year, raising only $2.6 billion, down 85% from the first quarter of 2001. Global equity capital market volume in the first quarter was down 56% from last year and 30% of this now comprises bought deals. Most banks have been competing fiercely for the dubious pleasure of doing these lumpy trades, ensuring competitive bids. It’s a great situation for vendors, but for ECM bankers with eyes bigger than their stomachs it’s a possible recipe for painful – if not terminal – indigestion.

In other times, executing a block trade for Spanish utility Endesa’s sale of its non-core holding in compatriot oil firm Repsol would have been like a walk in the park for Morgan Stanley and BBVA. The 36.8 million shares, accounting for 3.01% of Repsol’s share capital and worth about e500 million, was equivalent to only three days’ trading volume in the blue-chip stock. At the end of March as many as 10 banks are thought to have bid for Endesa’s block of Repsol shares. Losers say the joint bid from Morgan Stanley and BBVA, which they estimate was probably e13.50, was the most aggressive and about 25c a share more than the others’. Repsol’s shares closed at e14.20 on Thursday March 27 and reopened at e13.50 the next day as the market believed that Morgan Stanley had not been able to finish the deal and had simply passed the block to its trading book.

A source close to the deal at Morgan Stanley says that the block, which was launched just after the US close, was sold out five minutes before the reopening of markets in Europe on Friday March 28 at e13.75, a tight 3.5% discount to the closing price. But rivals say that fund managers received approaches from Morgan Stanley as late as nine or 10 in the morning offering shares at e13.50, which suggested to them that Morgan Stanley was still trying to offload the block. Repsol closed at e13.55 on the Friday and then down again on Monday March 31 at e13.22 as the perception that the block was still out there weighed on the stock. Repsol’s price has yet to recover to the e14.20 it was trading at before the block trade.

Disposing of a well-flagged stake in an oil stock while the US was waging war in the Middle East was always going to be tricky. But even if Morgan Stanley managed to sell the block as it claims, that the market didn’t believe it still effectively makes this a botched job.

Risk now the order of the day

Repsol

 
  Source: Reuters

The number of official block trades has fallen since last year. But increasingly aggressive backstop agreements in recent accelerated bookbuild transactions of secondary issues guaranteeing tightly negotiated minimum prices imply that there is no longer a meaningful distinction. These effectively are bought deals. “Taking on risk has become part of the business,” says the European head of equities syndicate at one investment bank. “The majority of deals involve risk, whether explicit contractual risk or in terms of a promised price. Risk taking is here to stay.”

This is a revolution for many so-called equity underwriters. In the boom times they bookbuilt equity offerings, persuading issuers that extensive marketing would maximize price and proceeds but being careful to avoid any firm commitment to deliver this themselves. Today, they have to put their money where their mouth is.

Despite the potentially lethal vagaries of the markets, investment banks’ appetite for taking on these deals appears strong. “The equity underwriting business is how we define ourselves,” says Christian Meissner, co-head of European ECM at Goldman Sachs. “If you are going to be in this business you have to be aggressive. If not, you may as well get out all together.”

Goldman Sachs has had its share of troubles with block trades. The Siemens Pension Fund approached it at 9am on Tuesday, March 18 for a bid on 36 million shares of semiconductor maker Infineon worth e236 million that it wished to dispose of. The vendor had hoped to take advantage of a one-week rally in the stock. Unfortunately for Goldman, by 2.30pm when it began selling the block – equivalent to about five days’ trading volume – the ship had already sailed. Infineon was trading at e7.33 at the time of launch but by the time Goldman had wrapped up the trade at 4.30pm the price had fallen rapidly, ending the day down 10% at e6.60. According to Dealogic the shares were placed at e6.55. Goldman declines to confirm the clearing price but admits it did not go well and says it did not make much money on it. Infineon is a tough name to sell. Its share price has fallen by about two-thirds over the past 12 months and one investment bank’s most recent equity research on the firm is entitled “Earnings, earnings, when will you be back?”

The ghost of Vivendi Universal lingers

These deals can work. On the same day the Infineon deal went sour, Goldman co-managed a rather more uneventful accelerated bookbuild for French internet media company Wanadoo.

Nevertheless, given that the memory of the legendary Vivendi Universal block trade disaster is still fresh, Goldman’s self-appellation “king of block trades” sounds a little over the top. It is estimated to have lost between $121 million and $144 million on its handling of 40% of the e3.35 billion block of 55 million shares for the company in January 2002, practically wiping out its equity trading revenues for that quarter. Deutsche Bank, which underwrote the other 60% of the deal, had to announce that it had taken an investment stake in the company as the share price went into free fall, collapsing from e61 before the block to e40 by March.

Deutsche appears to have taken the lessons of its Vivendi experience closer to heart. So far this year it has been absent from block deals despite bidding for some including the Repsol, Reckitt Benckiser and Suez trades. Perhaps Deutsche is bidding to lose. It is certainly taking a more cautious approach, unwilling to go for market share at any price.

Considering the bank’s announcement of a first-quarter net loss, a focus on profitability rather than league table credit could be a good thing. But if such risk-taking defines equity capital markets now it raises the question what a non risk-taking ECM desk is for.

While none of the block trades/accelerated bookbuilds of secondary issues this year has exploded in the hands of the banks quite like Vivendi Universal, that doesn’t mean that there will not be casualties. The competitive pressure on bids, the volatility of the market and the intense time pressure from vendors desperate to take advantage of very narrow windows of opportunity make that certain. The minutes that a central risk committee might have available to contemplate the merits of a deal before committing capital might not be enough for a rigorous assessment.

The number of fumbled attempts shows that the equity market needs to be approached with considerable thought and that timing is more critical than ever. There is plenty of cash out there for improving stories, as witnessed by France Telecom’s successful e16 billion rights issue (see page 29), or for companies in sectors that are flavour of the month, such as Allianz, which got away with an upsized e4.4 billion rights issue this April. Lehman’s disposal of e39 million-worth of Renault shares for Lagardère in February and CSFB’s disposal of $200 million-worth of Russian mobile phone operator MTS were also reasonably smooth operations, but it is evident that much care needs to be taken to ensure that deals go down well.

Morgan Stanley’s lax handling of the disposal of Reckitt Benckiser shares, for JAB Investments, the holding vehicle for the Benckiser family, was simply ill timed.

Derided as “Crappit Benckiser” or “Wrecked the Benckisers” by rivals, the attempt to sell 60 million shares for the founding family in the household cleaning products manufacturer after disappointing annual results on February 19 did not go down at all well with investors. The fact that they had been led to expect the announcement of a share buy-back scheme made things even worse. The deal had to be slashed to just 25 million shares, worth £235 million ($379 million), as investors rejected the offer – priced at £9.40 – as the share price collapsed 10% from £10.45 to £9.47 during the day.

The timing of the deal, as opposed to the difficulty of placing an unwanted stock, was clearly the problem in this case as Reckitt Benckiser is a decent name in a well-performing defensive sector. Its share price has since recovered and is now at £11.38.

Morgan Stanley partly redeemed itself by skilfully placing a further 35 million Reckitt shares worth £354 million at £10.10 on April 2 for JAB. Execution this time was successful, as JAB told the market it would not make any more share disposals in Reckitt for the next six months. Escape clauses allowed the holding firm to dispose of shares once the price had stabilized. The sale came as a surprise and was gobbled up in minutes. The shares ended the day at £10.98.

Suez’s simultaneous disposal of holdings in French blue chips Vinci, Axa, and TotalFina Elf, handled by UBS, Morgan Stanley, and Citigroup on February 27, was smooth. Moreover its simultaneous e1.2 billion mandatory convertible into shares of Belgian-Dutch bancassurer Fortis, and a massive e750 million block trade of Fortis shares, fully underwritten by UBS, shows that big and risky deals can succeed when timed well (see page 28). Troubled Allianz is no investor favourite but its rights issue succeeded on the back of crafty timing. The deal closed on April 29 on the back of a substantial rally in the insurance sector this April and one day before the stock’s e1.50 dividend pay-out. This helped frustrate hedge funds as institutions were unwilling to lend the stock, and helped Allianz achieve a 99.7% take-up.

ECM bankers expect more block trades to hit the market this year, as corporates and financial institutions with damaged balance sheets seeking equity capital will have little choice but to sell their non-core holdings despite weak valuations. Equity bankers believe these sales will have to be done as bought deals because low volumes mean conventionally marketed deals are getting hammered by hedge funds as well as by traders at rival banks smelling competitors’ blood in the water.