Navigating uncleared margin rules in FX

Foreign exchange forwards do not fall within the scope of uncleared margin rules, but that does not mean those rules have no effect on the FX business. Firms are having to consider the pros and cons of switching to cleared trades to avoid being impacted.

The fifth and penultimate phase of uncleared margin rules (UMR) went live in September 2021 for firms with aggregate average notional amount (AANA) of in-scope derivatives greater than 50 billion in dollars or euros. In addition to the notional thresholds, initial margin is required to be posted between counterparties where there is a consolidated threshold of $/€50 million.

According to Phil Hermon, executive director FX products at CME Group, this is likely to impact a large number of real-money accounts, such as asset managers and pension funds, who typically run large, directional books.

James Pearson, ForexClear.jpg
James Pearson, ForexClear

Asset managers and pension funds subject to UMR have to post initial margin for their uncleared derivatives. This initial margin is also required to be segregated in bankruptcy-remote arrangements, such as tri-party or third-party models.

James Pearson, head of ForexClear, says that although foreign exchange forwards are not in-scope for UMR, they do still count towards AANA calculations.

“This means firms trading OTC FX forwards are not required to post initial margin on FX forwards trades with their counterparties, but the FX forwards notional counts towards the determination of UMR phases,” he says.

One of the options for firms seeking to avoid coming under the scope of UMR is the clearing of existing OTC derivatives, which enables participants to maintain the customized nature of an OTC trade while gaining the risk, margin and operational efficiency of a central counterparty (CCP).

The decision on whether to continue using tailor-made OTC products or standardized listed products will come down to each firm’s trading needs.

Catalyst

Hermon describes uncleared margin rules as a catalyst for many firms to review their FX trading behaviour, and says the potential benefits of using listed FX futures as a complement to the OTC market go beyond margin efficiencies.

“The listed FX marketplace provides firm liquidity on a no-last-look basis in a central order book that is all-to-all, credit-agnostic and totally transparent,” he says. “This enables clients to see and access a hugely diversified pool of liquidity and also to trade passively or to utilize algos if they wish.”

Although a number of large asset managers have been onboarded by BNY Mellon’s margin services business, Malik Dussaud, the bank’s head of first-line optimization for FX, says he has not seen a big impact on liquidity in non-cleared FX derivatives as a result of this phase of the regulatory reforms.

“Next year’s adoption of SACCR, the new counterparty credit risk capital rules, might be a further catalyst for central clearing, but it is not expected to be widely adopted by the asset manager community,” he says.

For the market to see any further development, FX clearing needs to be made more widely available and commercially beneficial to all participants

John Estrada, Credit Suisse
John Estrada, Credit Suisse.jpg

The impact of UMR on FX trading by asset managers and pension funds remains unclear despite assurances from these clients that they are working on UMR-related projects, notes John Estrada, global co-head of spot FX at Credit Suisse.

As regards the benefits of switching from uncleared forwards to listed futures to avoid coming into scope for UMR on notional grounds, he says the bank generally considers balance-sheet usage as a primary consideration.

Cleared OTC FX products would have an advantage in this space and it is the direction the market wants to move towards, says Estrada.

“However, the initial margin costs for smaller organizations currently outweigh any material benefit, so for the market to see any further development, FX clearing needs to be made more widely available and commercially beneficial to all participants,” he adds. “We are looking to clear where appropriate but there is an obvious advantage when multiple counterparties clear.”

Challenge

Firms could see strong margin and capital efficiencies through the netting of all FX futures positions against a highly regulated CCP, but the rules still present something of a challenge for any firm doing large volumes of non-cleared OTC trades, explains Neil Murphy, business manager at TriOptima, a post-trade infrastructure and risk management services provider.

“In the run-up to phase six [of UMR in September 2022] there will be thousands of asset managers and pension funds needing to carry out huge amounts of operational work at the same time,” he says.

Neil Murphy, TriOptima.jpg
Neil Murphy, TriOptima

“Switching to listed trades may help a firm avoid UMR, but would require them to trade a relatively vanilla portfolio. While firms continue to maintain bilateral trades on their books they may struggle to avoid being caught by UMR and, as such, hundreds of buy-side firms may need to carry out UMR preparations at the same time.”

KC Lam, head of FX and rates at the Singapore Exchange, says firms switching from uncleared forwards to listed futures will save on human capital costs and reduced daily processes as well as optimizing the cost of initial margin.

“In addition, central clearing effectively removes the need for complex Isda [International Swaps and Derivatives Association] agreements involving multiple bilateral counterparties,” says Lam. “But given the greater regulatory scrutiny of trading practices and conduct, there would be a greater impetus to move towards listed FX options trading. This market is still at a nascent stage of development but is improving.”

If a firm clears OTC FX options at a CCP or uses listed options at an exchange, it might benefit from reduced margin costs, reduced counterparty and systemic risk, as well as operational and legal efficiencies, concludes Pearson.

However, central clearing can require a substantial infrastructure and technology investment and some asset managers may feel this cost could outweigh the benefits.