![]() |
|
Home Credit has more than 11 million customers in China and leads the market in point-of-sale loans |
The prospect of financing China’s legions of eager shoppers has bankers around the world salivating. Yet so far foreign firms have struggled to get a foothold in the country’s still-young consumer-finance market.
A notable exception is Home Credit, a Czech group better known in the west for its operations in Russia. In 2010, when China’s banking regulator issued the first four pilot licences for private-sector consumer finance operators, Home Credit was the only foreign company to make the cut.
Today, the group has more than 11 million customers in China and is the market leader in point-of-sale (PoS) loans. Both its client base and loan portfolio have more than doubled in each of the last two years, with net lending topping €5.3 billion at the end of 2016.
How did a relatively obscure firm from central Europe manage to steal a march on global banks with far larger balance sheets and longer track records in consumer finance?
Chief executive Jiri Smejc highlights several factors that have given Home Credit an edge over its rivals in China. Top of his list, unsurprisingly, are the group’s risk systems, which Smejc insists are “probably the best in the world for personal finance”.
By his own account, however, being privately held seems to have played at least an equally important role in Home Credit’s success. The group is majority owned by PPF, the investment group of Czech billionaire Petr Kellner, with a remaining 11.4% stake held by Smejc.
“As a private company, we have the advantage of being able both to react very quickly and to be patient,” says Smejc. “I’m sure a normal listed corporation would have closed China three times over in the early years, because the losses were so big.”
We realized early on that the 2008 crisis would be serious and we started taking measures to mitigate it in September of that year – Jiri Smejc, Home Credit
Home Credit first entered the Chinese market in 2005. As Smejc notes, things did not go smoothly to start with: “We spent three years just working out how to issue credit in a way that was compliant with the regulations. Then in early 2009, we were talking about closing China because the fraud issues seemed unmanageable. But we said: ‘Let’s make one final effort’, and it was the right decision.”
The following year, the group was granted a licence to issue loans in the eastern port city of Tianjin as part of a consumer finance pilot scheme devised by the Chinese authorities. This was subsequently expanded to cover the whole country – yet even then, as Smejc explains, Home Credit’s activities were hampered by stringent regulatory requirements.
“We had to operate using a ‘guarantee company’, which would guarantee the loans that we produced; then we had to book the loans via a special trust,” he says. Restrictions on foreign firms using their own balance sheets for consumer finance were only lifted in 2014.
This may partly account for the low profile of global players in today’s China consumer-finance market. Another explanation, suggests Smejc, is that firms from larger developed markets tend to be less flexible than their smaller rivals.
“If you have a big enough home market, you can be lazy when it comes to adapting your model for other markets and new cultures,” he says. “It is easier for us not to be arrogant when we go into a new market because we are from a small country. Coming from a small market means you have to be adaptive.”
It has also meant that, to achieve scale, Home Credit has had to look beyond its Czech base from the very start. Set up in 1997, the firm expanded into neighbouring Slovakia two years later. The first real indication of the extent of Kellner’s global ambitions came in 2002, however, with the purchase of small Russian lender Innovation Bank Technopolis.
Expansion
From these relatively modest beginnings Home Credit rapidly became one of Russia’s leading consumer finance players. The group also set up shop in Belarus, Ukraine and Kazakhstan before the financial crisis, as well as making forays into China and Vietnam. A second wave of Asian expansion in 2013 added India, Indonesia and Philippines to Home Credit’s growing portfolio.
Throughout this period, however, Russia remained the group’s largest operation and profit engine. Even the global financial crisis, which slashed nearly 8% off Russia’s GDP, failed to put a big dent in the bottom line of Moscow-based Home Credit and Finance Bank (HCFB).
“We realized early on that the 2008 crisis would be serious and we started taking measures to mitigate it in September of that year,” says Smejc. “We shortened the duration of our loans and cut our cost base by 30%, as a result of which we remained strong and profitable throughout the crisis.”
The group was less fortunate in 2014, when the ending of Russia’s long consumer-finance boom coincided with the imposition of western sanctions and the collapse of oil prices. “The recent crisis was much worse than in 2008 because it combined a macro crisis with a classic credit bubble, which started before the macro crisis and exacerbated its impact,” says Smejc.
Russia’s consumer finance houses bore the brunt of the adjustment. HCFB lost €117 million in 2014, pushing the parent group to a €60.5 million loss that slid even further into the red the following year.
Stemming the losses took two years and drastic cuts to HCFB’s cost base. By 2016, the firm’s monthly operating expenses had been more than halved from pre-crisis levels, thanks to the closure of most of its bricks-and-mortar network.
HCFB now has just 250 banking offices in Russia, down from a peak of more than 1,200. The firm is focusing on new distribution channels. “A lot of the cross-selling that used to be done through our branches is now being done online,” says Smejc. “That is healthy, given that we also have 90,000 PoS that we can use for cross-selling.”
The need to minimize fixed costs was not the only take away from the recent Russia crisis, he adds. “We also learned that we need to be more conservative in our underwriting model. We were always trying to ensure that our systems were working at the economical optimum.
“This failed to allow for that fact that in a credit bubble, we could find our own underwriting standards undermined by the readiness of other players to overload our clients with debt.”
|
|
|
Jiri Smejc, |
In response, Home Credit introduced a concept that Smejc calls “sustainability room” across all its markets. “This means that our profit must be in line with our risk costs, which should ensure we have a sufficient cushion to remain profitable even in the worst crisis. We were reasonably conservative before this but we are trying to be even more so.”
This new strategy proved its worth during Kazakhstan’s recent economic crisis. Despite a massive currency devaluation in late 2015, which saw the tenge lose more than half of its value against the dollar, Home Credit’s Kazakh operation posted a net profit of €45.8 million last year.
“We had learned lessons from Russia, so we were already shrinking our fixed cost base in Kazakhstan before the crisis hit,” says Smejc. “This also showed how well our underwriting systems work when we don’t have other players overloading our customers with debt.”
The restructuring in Russia also included deleveraging. HCFB’s loan book shrank from €5.8 billion at the end of 2013 to just €2 billion two years later as the firm refocused on PoS lending and away from cash loans, which had proved particularly vulnerable during the crisis.
The efforts paid off last year with HCFB’s return to lending growth and profitability. Combined with surging returns from China and Vietnam, this helped the parent group to a net result of €210 million. Net income from Vietnam increased by 79% to €46.3 million, while profits from Home Credit’s Chinese operations were up 53% to €196 million.
By contrast, the group’s newer Asian markets have proved an increasing drain on its resources in the last three years. India, Indonesia and the Philippines between them shaved €96.2 million off Home Credit’s bottom line in 2016, with India accounting for nearly two-thirds of the total.
Smejc says such losses are the inevitable price of establishing consumer finance operations in large markets. “You need scale to be profitable, particularly in India where margins are thin, and rapid growth means big increases in opex,” he says. “In China, we already have a big base, so we could be highly profitable, but only if we stopped growing.”
Home Credit’s new strategy of offering zero interest rate PoS loans, introduced in Asia two years ago and now being rolled out across the rest of its network, has also proved costly. It has, however, been a huge success with shoppers in the region.
Smejc notes that 60% of all mobile phones sold in Vietnam in the first quarter of 2016 were financed with zero rate loans; Home Credit accounts for 86% of those sales. “This allowed us to achieve market domination, which gave us very strong leverage to negotiate subsidies from manufacturers and retailers,” he says.
Home Credit is now the market leader in PoS lending in Vietnam and expects to take the top slot in the Philippines this year. In India, local rival Bajaj Finance still has the edge in terms of lending volume, although the Czech group leads by number of loans issued.
The introduction of zero interest loans has also given Home Credit access to a massively expanded client base, which Smejc says was the main objective of the strategy. “We have to bear the cost of generating large initial portfolios, but it offers excellent opportunities for profitability during the cross-sales phase,” he adds.
At present, cross-selling in Asia means cash loans – however, Home Credit is gearing up to introduce credit cards in Vietnam this year. Launches in the Philippines and Indonesia are due to follow.
The group also has scope to expand the range of products covered by its PoS loans. In Asia, the vast majority of its lending currently relates to mobile phone purchases, whereas in more mature markets, such as Russia, it covers a wide range of products, from computers and furniture to home appliances.
E-commerce
Another big potential growth area for consumer-finance providers in Asia, and particularly China, is clearly e-commerce. Home Credit has invested heavily in digitalization over the past few years. Whether or not the group can compete with China’s home-grown internet giants and army of fintechs remains to be seen.
“That is the question everyone is asking in China,” admits Smejc. “Why shouldn’t Alibaba or Tencent be able to provide credit limits for their customers when they have their data and know their shopping habits better than us?”
His answer is that even the biggest online players will struggle to match Home Credit’s consumer finance expertise, particularly in areas such as fraud detection and collection. He also challenges the assumption that e-commerce firms have an advantage in terms of data, noting that Home Credit uses 25 sources of data in China, including aggregators, credit bureaux, telecoms firms and social networks.
“The online retailers have a lot of data and are able to do some things with it, but they still have plenty to learn about using data specifically for credit provision,” he says. “This is clearly shown by the fact that they are currently only providing credit to their best customers.”
We are hoping this will be a public service, because if we succeed, the traditional payday lenders should be killed off – Jiri Smejc, Home Credit
Home Credit is already taking advantage of this weakness on the part of China’s e-commerce players. The group has signed an agreement with JD.com, the country’s second-largest online retailer, to provide financing for customers who do not qualify for loans issued by the seller itself.
Smejc says further tie-ups are likely with both retailers and other online players. “We believe we will be able first to integrate with the e-shops, because we’re a natural fit for them, and then later with more specialized players such as local social networks,” he says.
On the other side of the balance sheet, Home Credit is also hoping to start deposit-gathering in Asia in the near future. At present, the group’s operations in the region are almost entirely wholesale-funded. By contrast, lending in its original markets in emerging Europe – Russia, Kazakhstan, Slovakia and Czech Republic – is entirely funded by deposits.
“We would love to be fully deposit-funded everywhere because we believe it increases the stability of our operations,” says Smejc. “It will be hard because there are strict limits for foreign investors in some of our markets, but we are working on different models, and we hope in the long run to achieve this.”
Home Credit is in talks with India’s banking regulator about obtaining a local licence for its new online lender, Air Bank. Launched in Czech Republic in 2011, the brand is aimed at affluent customers, in contrast to Home Credit’s traditional lower mass-client base. “This means we can target the market from two angles,” says Smejc.
Other new products in the group’s home market include Zonky, one of the Czech Republic’s first peer-to-peer lending platforms, and Kamali, a payday lender. Smejc is particularly enthusiastic about Kamali, which he hopes will revolutionize the industry by making payday lending more affordable for clients.
“The logic of payday lenders is that they charge crazy percentages for small loans because they give them to anyone,” he says. “This means good customers are paying through the nose for losses on the bad ones. We believe our credit systems are so advanced that we can separate the good customers from this group and offer them something much better.”
According to Smejc, Kamali’s loans are typically a 10th of the price of those offered by competitors. “We are hoping this will be a public service, because if we succeed, the traditional payday lenders should be killed off,” he says.
If the product proves successful, Smejc hints that Home Credit could look to roll it out in western Europe. That would mark a departure for the group, which so far has focused almost exclusively on emerging markets.
The only exception is the US, where Home Credit began financing smartphone sales for telecoms giant Sprint in 2015 – an opportunity Smejc says was “too good to resist”. He adds that the success of the joint venture has been a vindication of the group’s risk systems.
“We have been able to tune our scorecards to a level that allowed us to dramatically decrease the down payments required from sub-prime customers without any increase in risk costs,” he says. “As a result, we were able to significantly increase take-up and acceptance rates.”
Smejc insists, however, that this was a one-off and that Home Credit has no immediate plans for further geographical expansion – although he notes that Bangladesh is “an interesting market.
“At the moment, we believe it’s more efficient to maximize the value of the markets we are already in,” he says. As he notes, the group has plenty of room for growth in its existing network. “We are already covering 3.5 billion people, so there’s no shortage of population.”

