Hybrids still on the menu

Hybrid capital may no longer be welcome in the US and Europe but it is playing a valuable role in the emerging markets.

So decoupling is not a myth. While regulators in the US and Europe are pressing banks to operate under a stricter capital regime – essentially raising more equity funding – in the emerging markets hybrid debt is still proving to have an important role.

In Russia, for example, where banks are struggling under the growing weight of bad debt, the government’s recapitalization plan includes the provision of subordinated loans. Last month Alfa Bank became the first local privately owned bank to benefit when it received approval for a subordinated loan of Rb29.9 billion ($960 million).

The 11-year loan increases Alfa’s holding company’s tier 2 level and follows legislation that allows for the state to give capital support of up to three times the amount already provided by a bank’s shareholders. Alfa’s holding company, which received a $320 million capital injection from shareholders in June, consequently granted a 16-year subordinated loan to the bank.

Also last month the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development supported three subsidiaries of Raiffeisen International in eastern Europe through a €150 million financing package. The loans, which went to Raiffeisen’s banks in Ukraine, Romania and Russia, can be classed as tier 2 capital. Nor is this form of debt capital finding use merely as part of official-sector support packages. In late September Bradesco, one of Brazil’s biggest private banks, raised $750 million through the issue of tier 2 notes in the first Latin American subordinated debt offering in the international capital markets since the onset of the global financial crisis.

The debate around the value of tier 1 and tier 2 securities to a bank’s capital structure is one of the most prominent now taking place in the financial community. The EU, the Basle Committee and other bodies have all made pronouncements on the issue. It is clear that in Europe, for example, where banks have been big issuers of hybrid capital over the past decade, regulators now have little time for subordinated debt, which they believe was found wanting during the credit crunch.

But by relegating the importance of debt capital – and by extension placing greater emphasis on equity, which is more expensive and risky – the authorities might be tying banks’ hands at a time when they are being asked to lend more.

Governments in emerging markets appear to have taken a different tack. They are clearly willing for banks to strengthen their balance sheets through lower-quality capital if it means that the real economy benefits. Alfa Bank, for example, will use the proceeds from its subordinated loan to provide credit to manufacturing companies. Ditto Raiffeisen’s subsidiaries.

In the UAE the government has gone even further in trying to stimulate its economy. In August it issued a circular that might mean that banks do not need to have as high capital adequacy ratios as before. Most commentators interpreted the circular as an attempt to accelerate lending in the federation.

Stricter capital rules will be an important part of the post-recovery financial landscape. But the governments in eastern Europe and the UAE are right to allow their banks greater flexibility over their capital structure to get them lending again. The health of their economies depends on this.