Reforms are crucial to recovery

Russia: Fairy tale ending or start of a nightmare?

Russia: Fairy tale ending or start of a nightmare?

Real estate: Rebuilding a house of cards

Russia urgently needs to reform its economy if it is to stage a sustainable recovery from the twin ills of the global credit crunch and associated economic slowdown.

That’s the clear message from market participants, many of whom view the recent recovery in Russia’s capital markets as a temporary respite. “The reality on the ground is that growth, industrial output and investment are still declining fast,” says Bernie Sucher, head of Merrill Lynch Securities in Russia. The latest available data show that GDP growth has plummeted from 8% in the first half of 2008 to minus 8%, industrial output growth has gone from 10% to minus 12% and investment growth from 7.5% to minus 7.5%.

“The entire political, social and economic system is being tested by the crisis,” says Sucher. “People are fighting fires all over the place, but new fires are still breaking out.” A recent report by investment bank Renaissance Capital points out: “When oil prices were well above $100 a barrel, with economic growth approaching 10% and real personal income growth exceeding 10%, calls for reform were muted, to say the least. Suddenly this need has become painfully obvious to most, both within and outside the government.”

Evgeny Fetisov, managing director at hedge fund group Da Vinci Capital Management, says that high oil prices in particular served to mask inefficiencies within the Russian economy. “The worst thing for Russia right now would be for oil to go back over $100 a barrel – nothing would get changed. He adds: “Many things needs to happen before we have an efficient economy – we need to see more private sector involvement in the economy, we need to develop small and medium-sized enterprises and cut corruption and red tape.” With about 70% of the economy still in state hands, Russia is far from being a market economy, and small and medium-sized enterprises account for only 5% of GDP, compared with 50% in western Europe and almost 90% in Japan.

Sucher at Merrill Lynch says that although increased government spending has so far at least helped to avert an economic meltdown, it’s not a cure-all for the problems of an unreformed, inefficient system. He says that efforts by the Kremlin to combat corruption and implement capital markets reform will be crucial to winning back international investor confidence in Russia. He says: “I don’t think that it’s an accident that among all the things he could have focused on recently president Medvedev has focused on two things – the fight against corruption and establishing Moscow as a global financial centre. You cannot have a truly competitive financial centre without the rule of law.”