The dollar’s strength in 2005 came as a surprise to many in the foreign exchange market. Far from falling out of bed, as most analysts predicted, the dollar posted significant gains against most other major currencies. Over the past 12 months, it has risen by more than 11% versus the euro, 7% against the pound, and by an even more impressive 15% versus the yen.
As Lehman Brothers wrote recently in the bank’s outlook for 2006: “2005 was not particularly good for forecasters or macro traders. And nowhere did forecasters get it more wrong than in currency markets. Remember, 2005 was supposed to be a year of further US dollar weakness.”
Lehman adds: “The year 2005 had its share of big events – referendum defeats in France and Holland leading to talk of a breakdown in the euro; the long-awaited revaluation in China; and huge political shifts in Germany and Japan. In the end, none of these events had any lasting effect on currencies. Indeed, as we near the end of another eventful year, the only rule that really mattered was to buy the high-yielding currencies and sell the low-yielding ones.”
Trading in hindsight is always easy and the reasons why the dollar strengthened are now obvious. But with many of the driving factors that fuelled the dollar rally now eroded, the dollar looks set to weaken in 2006. Deutsche Bank succinctly summarized this in recent research, saying: “Strong support from higher yields, higher oil prices and Homeland Investment Act (HIA)-related inflows have led to a significant cyclical component of the dollar (6%) relative to the longer-run fundamentals as indicated by the basic balance. With the US yield advantage peaking by mid-2006, oil prices forecast to decline during the course of next year and HIA flows to dry up with the current fiscal year, we expect the structural forces to dominate during H2 2006. From a longer-run perspective, we still see a structural downtrend in the dollar over the medium term, though our recent estimates imply a smaller downtrend than in the past.”
Rebecca Patterson, global currency strategist at JPMorgan, says that the impact of petro-dollar recycling has possibly had the greatest effect on the currency’s value over the past 12 months. “At the beginning of 2005, we, along with most analysts, thought the dollar would weaken further, even though the Fed was raising rates. HIA wasn’t a surprise to us – we expected cross-border flows of around $90 to $100 billion in 2005. What we under-estimated was the amount of petro-dollar recycling into the US.”
She says there has been considerable discussion about the HIA, perhaps because the repatriation did accelerate in the second half and even more so in the final quarter of 2005. This has prompted talk that the act will be extended. “We don’t believe it [HIA] will be extended for most US firms,” she says. US companies were given a fiscal year to repatriate foreign profits, and for the vast majority that ends December 2005. “There will be a small portion of flow coming back in 2006, but the bulk has already been done,” she adds.
Mansoor Mohi-uddin, head of FX strategy at UBS, is not convinced that the HIA was a significant reason for the dollar’s strength. “I would say that HIA has had a marginal impact on dollar sentiment this quarter. Players have focused on it and there has been a flurry of activity but the flows have been less than anticipated. One reason why is that many of the corporates held dollars overseas, so they didn’t need to do any FX.”
Mohi-uddin believes that interest rate differentials, political uncertainty in Europe and corporate activity wielded greater influence on the dollar’s value, especially in the final quarter. “Corporates are now focused on year-end hedges and window-dressing. A lot of corporates were looking for higher (euro/dollar) levels to hedge. As the euro has fallen, it’s triggered hedging and we’ve seen capitulation by some people who were dollar negative. Also, many of the central banks that were diversifying [their reserves] have been quiet.”
So it seems that the consensus is that the dollar will weaken at some stage in 2006. Quite when is obviously not certain and, as ABN Amro has highlighted, the latest CFTC Commitment of Traders report shows non-commercial or speculative IMM (CME) long dollar positions are still at historically large levels.
Data from the options market suggests that short dollar positioning is occurring, but this could be just hedging rather than speculative plays. What is clear is that the one-month risk reversal, which is an indication of how much calls trades at over or under puts, has recently moved from 0.45% in favour of euro puts to 0.2% in favour of euro calls. Ultimately, FX players will not be particularly bothered which way the dollar moves, just as long as it trends more clearly than it did in 2005.