Antitrust enforcement: Price-fixing costly for chipmakers

Brokerage firm Refco steals the headlines but Samsung faces major fine. South Korean electronics conglomerate Samsung has pleaded guilty to price-fixing in a far-reaching probe by the US Department of Justice and has been handed down the second-largest criminal fine ever

 Barnett: hunting down price-fixing

South Korean electronics conglomerate Samsung has pleaded guilty to price-fixing in a far-reaching probe by the US Department of Justice and has been handed down the second-largest criminal fine ever, after the $500 million Hoffman La Roche paid for vitamin-related price-fixing in 1999. Samsung will pay $300 million to settle the case, in which it was charged with conspiring to fix prices on DRAM chips. The fine will hit Samsung hard. It claims to have set aside just $100 million in 2004 “in provision against possible loss resulting from the ongoing antitrust investigation into the company”. In the third quarter, the group’s semiconductor operating profits were W1.35 trillion ($1.3 billion), down 11.7% on the third quarter of 2004. Samsung cited DRAM chip price weakness for the results.

Furthermore, DoJ representatives have said that several Samsung employees are not protected by the guilty plea, which suggests that further charges might be laid against them. In a similar case against German chipmaker Infineon Technologies, four executives pleaded guilty to the conspiracy and received jail sentence ranging from four to six months for their involvement.

Samsung is the latest chipmaker to be caught up in the probe. In April its largest competitor – Korean group Hynix Semiconductor – was fined $185 million for fixing the prices of its memory chips and last autumn Infineon pleaded guilty to similar charges, incurring a $160 million fine.

According to the DoJ the price-fixing was perpetrated against computer makers Dell, Compaq, Hewlett-Packard, Apple, IBM and

Gateway between April 1999 and June 2002, involving cartel-like activity and conspiring through telephone calls, e-mails, and face-to-face meetings to fix prices.

Thomas Barnett, acting assistant attorney general in charge of the US Department of Justice’s antitrust division, stated in a release: “This case demonstrates the need for vigorous antitrust enforcement in high-technology markets, which is one of the most important sectors of the American economy.”

Overall, Samsung’s third-quarter financial results showed semiconductor sales equivalent to $4.4 billion, up 10% on the previous quarter, but down 3% from a year earlier.