Banking: StanChart shows King is wrong

The bank’s results reveal the benefits, and not the drawbacks, of mixing retail and wholesale banking.

When Bank of England Governor Mervyn King made his criticism of casino banking in a speech earlier this year he clearly didn’t have Standard Chartered in mind.

King was referring to the risky proprietary-driven activities of investment banks, which he wanted separated from safer, deposit-gathering-and-lending retail banking to lessen the threat of financial institutions that get too big to fail.

But as with other proposals put forward by officials and regulators to redraw the post-crisis banking landscape, King’s argument was too general, misguided and simplistic. Standard Chartered shows why.

The emerging markets specialist has had a better crisis than most other banks. Last year it delivered record pre-tax operating profits of $4.57 billion. For the first half of this year its profits hit $2.84 billion, up 10% year on year. An interim management statement released at the end of October said that the bank had continued to build on its record income and profits during the third quarter.

What’s most interesting about its results is that it’s the wholesale banking division – the casino bank, to use King’s terminology – that’s driving them. Last year, the wholesale bank – corporate lending, transaction banking, financial markets, asset and liability management, corporate finance and principal finance – accounted for 65% of the bank’s profits. In the first half of this year its contribution to the bottom line was a staggering 79%.

In contrast, the consumer banking division’s performance has fallen off a cliff. In 2008 its operating profit dropped by 33% on the previous year while in the first half of this year it collapsed 57% year on year. The unit’s profit for the first six months of the year was a paltry $348 million.

It’s not all bad news for the consumer bank. It continues to attract deposits. Last year was a record one in deposit growth and the business now creates $46 billion of surplus liquidity for the group. However, with falling interest rates globally, the increased volume has not been sufficient to offset compressed liability margins.

With global economic activity still weak, moreover, worries about bad debt continue to hang over the business. Loan impairment increased by $151 million, or 37%, to $563 million in the first half of the year.

Clearly the consumer business has been badly damaged by the financial crisis. If the wholesale division had struggled too Standard Chartered might have required some measure of state support. It didn’t. Instead it’s emerging with its reputation enhanced. That’s attributable to its achievements in investment and corporate banking and good, disciplined management.

That reputation could disappear quickly, of course, if that discipline slips because Standard Chartered’s performance is a salutary reminder that risks are inherent across all aspects of banking. Indeed, the bank’s average total value at risk increased in the first half of this year compared with 2008 because of the growth in the banking book’s VaR, reflecting the sharp rise in credit spread volatility. Average trading book VaR actually declined slightly, on account of reductions in interest rate and foreign exchange VaR.

Managing those risks, both in investment and consumer banking, will determine whether Standard Chartered continues to deliver record profits.