A brief thank you to the three guest columnists who allowed me to at least try to take a holiday in August. But before any of them get ideas about settling into my seat on a more permanent basis, I’d just like to remind them, in the style of the late great James Brown, “I’m back, I’m back. Jonathan Butterfield? I’m the man. Andy Durrant? I’m the man. David Woo. David Who? I’m the man.”
Clearly, the FX market did not go on holiday in August. Cable suffered a 10% fall against the dollar, while the dollar index rose 5.46% in the month, its biggest increase since the 8.10% rise in October 1992. Talking around, although there now seems widespread agreement that sterling is doomed, there is not such a consensus that the dollar has turned. That is maybe why the moves accelerated, because not too many people were on them from the beginning.
Anyway, the dollar’s resurgence got me thinking, which as my editor will tell you, can be dangerous. Many years ago, I had to listen to a cable trader whinge about how much more money he had to make each year as a result of sterling strength. At the time, I was working at Midland, which accounted in sterling. The cable trader obviously made dollars – sometimes – in his trading. The move from near parity back up eventually towards 2.0000 meant, he moaned, that he effectively had to make twice as much money to stand still.
What impact might sterling’s fall (see Currency pairs) have had on the sub-prime losses incurred by UK banks? Assuming that the write-downs have been done at realistic valuations leads to a further assumption that at some point in time there will be some write-backs as the loans mature. These are both big assumptions.
RBS has so far written down $14.6 billion, Barclays $10.1 million, HBOS $7 billion and Lloyds TSB $4.9 billion. These all went on to the banks’ balance sheets when cable was trading close to $2.0000. With sterling taking a severe beating, it would appear that the UK banks might sitting on a significant currency gain once they do some write-backs.
However, this view, although it does have merits, is possibly too simplistic. “The problem is that, for the moment, there is still a chance of further write-downs,” says Huw van Steenis, head of EMEA banks and diversified financials research at Morgan Stanley.
He adds; “There are unlikely to be any write-backs in the second half of the year and probably not for at least a couple of years. The other factor to consider is that some banks have tried to ‘de-risk’ their business and have sold off some of these assets, so it is not by all means clear just how much could potentially be written back.”
If they do benefit, though, it reminds me of that old saying, why be good if you can be lucky?