Trading rooms: Hormonally yours, or mine

A piece of academic research from Cambridge University, which examined the hormone levels of a group of male traders, garnered a lot of media coverage this week.

The report’s lead author, John Coates, apparently used to work as a trader at Deutsche, although I haven’t been able to find out in which area.

Following his return to academia, Coates decided to examine whether there was a hormonal influence on the way traders behaved. Explaining why, Coates wrote in the Financial Times: “This was a question I asked while working on Wall Street during the dotcom bubble. Many traders at this time displayed manic behaviour and a sense of infallibility. Equally telling was that women appeared relatively unaffected. Both facts implicated a chemical such as testosterone.”

Coates and his colleagues did find that traders’ daily testosterone levels were higher when they made above-average profits. “We found that a trader’s morning testosterone level predicts his day’s profitability. We also found that a trader’s cortisol (a stress hormone) rises with both the variance of his trading results and the volatility of the market. Our results suggest that higher testosterone may contribute to economic return, whereas cortisol is increased by risk,” they say in the report.

The report is quite interesting for several reasons. Coates and his team sampled 17 male traders from a mid-sized trading floor of 260 dealers, of whom just four were female. Its salary range was from £12,000 to more than £5,000,000, which staggered me. I thought these days that only publishing houses could get away with paying so little and that most bank jubs were on at least 40 grand.

Inevitably, it has also led to suggestions that more women should be employed in trading rooms, which I wholeheartedly agree with. Regular readers know that my wife is often called Annie Dotal, or the basis that Annie Dotal’s evidence is nearly always correct. When she started out on her career, back in the mid-1980s, she was fortunate to have a boss who positively discriminated. He got her to write a report on why women were an under-used asset by most banks, and she subsequently went on to have a far more successful trading career than I did. But suggestions that the dealing room of the future should be all female are wide of the mark. I would imagine that having a room with just women would be as bad as one with just men. For more on the report, click https://www.admin.cam.ac.uk/news/dp/2008041501.