Well, I seem to have upset one reader last week, when I described how I was off skiing for the weekend and some of the efforts Euromoney Poll head honcho Andrew Newby has to go to protect its sanctity. The reader, who calls himself Robin Prinz, added a comment to the site. “Break a leg!” he exhorted. “In fact, break both of them.”
Bit harsh, I thought, but everyone’s entitled to an opinion. After all, it’s opinions which make markets. So ‘Robin’, who commented behind a Yahoo e-mail address, will no doubt be disappointed that we all returned safely after a fantastic trip. Le mot du jour, so to speak, for the entire jaunt was “Combien?”
Most of you will have seen the supposed picture of the response of Soc Gen’s chief executive when he heard that Jerome Kerviel, had blown a near €5 billion hole in the bank’s balance sheet. I was very impressed by Simon Meadows, global head of FX sales at Credit Suisse, who spotted straight away that the picture is of the late French actor and singer Fernandel. “Shows I have a bit of culture, non?” he asked me. I guess it does, but I’m not sure how culture helps in the world of investment banking.
In fact, there are times when I think luck plays the biggest role in trading. Naturally, there’s been a lot written about the sorry saga at Soc Gen. One could argue that Soc Gen was simply unlucky to have employed someone who could expose its frailities to such an extent. One could argue that, but one would be completely wrong. Stupidity often plays the biggest role and it’s stupidity which causes bosses to turn a blind eye to some of the activities which can occur in a dealing room. Stupidity makes weak men believe the P&L they see is accurate, even when it is patently obvious it’s not.
I read one article on the Soc Gen debacle this week which raised a very valid point. It was written by Carl Mortishead in The Times. He alluded to the fact that rogue traders are seldom women. “The future of investment banking is likely to be mainly female. Where else will banks look for reliable and co-operative employees? Would a bank rather have a team that looks after its members and openly discusses problems or a group of dysfunctional individuals working on their own? It’s not a difficult choice. Of course, a team of empathetic females might not catch the really big halibut, but the banks can probably live with that if the girls net a steady and predictable catch of lesser fry. It’s a small price to pay to save €5 billion,” he wrote.
I mentioned it to my wife, who we used to call Annie Dotal on the basis that Annie Dotal’s evidence was always right. Annie used to be a very good FX options trader. The hardest job she says she ever had was managing the egos of her male subordinates, some of whom would trade the wings to ‘smooth’ their P&L when they had bad days. Annie, by contrast, booked her losses when they occurred and took what some would call a Steady Eddie approach, but which would be more appropriately called a Steady Edwina. Most years, Steady Edwina was up more than the so-called star performers, who were men and whose P&L was far more volatile. “How many women are in the list of the top rogue traders?” she asked me. You can send your answers to me at fx@euromoney.com, or if you prefer to hide your identity, like Robin Prinz, add a comment to this site.