Donohue comes out fighting

These are interesting times for the CME. I have followed the performance of the company’s shares ever since they were listed at what now looks like the unbelievable bargain price of $35 back in December 2002. The shares recently peaked at just over $700, but they have fallen back and are trading around $535. One of the factors behind the recent fall is the news that the US Department of Justice has called for the break up of the CME’s vertical silo. The exchange also owns its clearing house, which the Department of Justice feels stifles competition.

These are interesting times for the CME. I have followed the performance of the company’s shares ever since they were listed at what now looks like the unbelievable bargain price of $35 back in December 2002. The shares recently peaked at just over $700, but they have fallen back and are trading around $535. One of the factors behind the recent fall is the news that the US Department of Justice has called for the break up of the CME’s vertical silo. The exchange also owns its clearing house, which the Department of Justice feels stifles competition.

Over the past six years, every drop in the CME’s stock price has proved a buying opportunity. It will be interesting to see if the latest pullback proves the same. But it is clear that the exchange’s cage has been rattled and its chief executive, Craig Donohue, is not ready to roll over and break up an important cash cow. This week, Donohue took the opportunity to attack critics of the CME’s vertical model in a speech to the US Managed Funds Association in Florida: “I would like to share my thoughts with you on what many regard as an arcane or philosophical topic: market structure. More particularly, given recent events, I would like to talk about the growing importance of centralized clearing and the risk management systems that are the hallmark of well-run clearing houses. As many of you are aware, there is an on-going tug of war between futures exchanges and investment banks over ownership and control of central counterparty clearing houses. This seemingly perennial issue resurfaced again with an ill-timed and ill-considered suggestion that the Department of the Treasury consider whether futures exchanges should give up their clearing houses and transfer them to a monopoly, government-regulated utility.”

Donohue went on to ask: “Why would anyone question the efficacy of these exchange-owned clearing systems when we witness losses like the more than $7 billion incurred by Société Générale?”

That’s funny, I thought, because only last week I argued that the SocGen debacle would not have happened in the OTC, bilateral market. Donohue is not someone who spouts off without careful consideration – so I had to get on to the CME and ask if he had lost the plot.

The exchange responded swiftly. “Our understanding is that the losses occurred because the transparent futures positions were allowed to accumulate as hedges against the trader’s opaque (and in this case phantom) OTC trades. Everyone knew the futures trades existed. They assumed the OTC trades also existed. Had the OTC trades in fact existed, the losses in futures would have been offset against the gains on the OTC side, and the portfolio in aggregate would not have been naked long. Had the OTC half also been a cleared product, the back office would have immediately seen that they did not exist,” a spokesman argued.

That may be so, but to make any kind of claim that SG’s loss would not have occurred if all the trades had been cleared through a CCP looks a little disingenuous. The OTC market does not have a monopoly on rogue trading.