In the past, growth patterns in the data have been relatively consistent across the globe, which has allowed an easy extrapolation of the BIS numbers. This time, though, quite significant differences have emerged. For instance, the Bank of England’s Joint Standing Committee reports that turnover in London rose by an impressive 54% from a year earlier. Although the figure was slightly distorted because three more banks, Bank of Scotland, NAB and CBA, contributed data, the increase is staggering. In contrast, growth in Singapore was a measly 3% across all products.
Also, as perhaps should be expected because of the impact of the liquidity crunch, growth was not consistent across all products. Spot turnover in London increased by 67% from a year earlier to a daily average of $560 billion. However, while the option market appears to have recovered to a large extent from the previous data sample collected in October 2007, turnover, at $112 billion, was still below the level it was a year earlier ($118 billion) in April 2008.
This drop-off in options activity was even more pronounced in New York. According to the New York Fed’s FX Committee (FXC), average daily volume across all products rose 15.7% to $715 billion. This was largely driven by a 43.5% increase in spot volumes to $393 billion. Swaps and outrights remained static but option volumes plunged by 36% to $34 billion. The FXC says this is the lowest figure it has recorded since it stated collecting the data in October 2004.
In Tokyo it looks as if spot rose by about 13%, while swaps increased by 37.7% and outrights increased by 29%. I have not had sufficient time to analyse the Tokyo figures fully and it appears, at first glance, as if the figures have been double counted, so the figures reported here should be treated with caution.
So why are there such profound differences in the growth rates reported? Both New York and London have recorded much higher growth in spot (which might be a result of where banks book their trades) than Tokyo or Singapore. Swap volumes rose in London by 15.7% but in Tokyo apparently by 37.7%, while outrights increased by 59% in London but just 29% in Tokyo.
The fall in option volumes in New York is most likely, so I’m told, because in April 2007 there was a lot of model trading going on. And at that time, apparently, these wonderfully clever programs had decided that volatility, which was already on the carpet, was going to keep on falling. As we all know, that situation changed, the models blew up and a lot of funds, staffed by people who apparently knew the price of everything but ultimately the value of nothing, have done their cods.
Finally, using the JSC’s data as a benchmark for what is occurring globally, it appears that there is greater activity in more currency pairs than previously. EUR/USD accounts for 29% of turnover – in October 2007 the JSC reported it accounted for 32%. Cable’s share has slipped two percentage points to 12%, while USD/JPY has remained steady at 11%. But there has been an increase in USD/NOK, USD/SEK, NZD/USD and USD/ZAR and several others. While the big boys in the market will no doubt also be active in these, if these currency pairs do continue to grow, it should provide some real opportunities for more niche players.