D and QFC: deluded and quixotic financial centres

Can Gulf financial centres’ high ambitions be fulfilled in a post-credit crunch world with falling oil prices?

There were doubts earlier on but now the Gulf’s rulers might be feeling positively foolhardy for basing the future of their economies so heavily on such a capricious industry as financial services. What now of the Gulf’s dreams to host some of the world’s capitals of capital?

In coming years, Gulf cities probably will become slightly less insignificant as global financial centres, rather than just Gulf regional ones – provided the oil price holds up. If it does, the credit crisis, paired with cash surpluses, will give Gulf cities slightly more of a competitive advantage in financial services. The Gulf will become a more essential stopping point in global investment-banking roadshows. Mergers between two companies in the US, for example, will more often require a final injection of debt or equity from the Gulf. More joint venture partnerships between global private equity groups and Gulf entities might also increase the statuses of Gulf cities as global financial centres.

On the other hand, extravagant and often useless state-sponsored real estate projects continue to proliferate in the Gulf and rulers are already setting aside more of their money to prop-up their the home country’s banks and capital markets. If oil prices fall further, the Gulf as a whole will have even less money to invest abroad, and the ambitions of Dubai and other Gulf financial centres will have to downsize even more. A real estate crash in Dubai would only exacerbate this.

Gulf banks suffering from talent shortages before the crisis will certainly find it easier to recruit more experienced bankers now. In fact, the presence in the Gulf of more bankers, and more senior bankers, is already causing occasional inter-regional deals between non-Gulf entities to be negotiated and arranged in the Gulf. But the point is that these deals are usually small, rare, and often, for example, the product of coincidental personal relationships.

Even in Dubai, which is the only viable regional financial centre, the most important thing often seems to be for bankers just to be seen to be based there, and appear committed to the city and the region – even if the real targets are the sovereign wealth funds. The basic reality now, as before, is that apart from the region’s cash surpluses, Gulf cities have few particular attractions as centres for deals between entities based outside the Middle East. The global investment banking infrastructure still centres firmly on New York, London, and Hong Kong. The Gulf’s capital markets are shallow and immature by comparison. Legal and regulatory infrastructure is lacking, and industry-specific bankers are still based for the most part in the traditional metropolises.

As ever, the oil price determines the future of the Gulf, and recently that has been falling at the same time as the value of the Gulf’s foreign investments. Ironically, this might damage most of all the least oil-rich economies – Dubai, Qatar, Bahrain – because these are also the least cash-rich economies. They are also the places that have staked most on the financial services industry.