Achtung! Icap rumoured to be in play

Consequences of consolidation.

As readers know, I am a small shareholder in Icap, so I was pleased to see the company’s shares catch a bit of a bid last week  – it played for some of my other losses, which I won’t go into. Various reasons were touted for the minor rally. One suggested the rise was because of the approach made to Reuters; another hinted that Michael Spencer was poised to sell up and concentrate on politics. The consequence of the latter, it was suggested, would be that Icap would get taken over by Deutsche Börse.

Deutsche Börse has really struggled to play a role in the consolidation dance that the exchanges are doing, even though it was probably the first to start the process. It created the first cross-border merger with the Swiss Exchange when it formed derivatives exchange Eurex almost a decade ago. Since then, it has been rebuffed several times by the London Stock Exchange, got stiffed by the Chicago Board of Trade and saw Euronext form into what looked initially to be an anti-German alliance by the French, Dutch, Belgian and then Portuguese. Euronext then looked to boost its alliance by merging with the New York Stock Exchange.

But the Börse remains a real powerhouse, despite its inability to find a partner to help safeguard its dynasty. So is it really about to buy Icap? Would Spencer really sell out to a regulated exchange, a move that would not please many of his clients, who like operating in the over-the-counter markets? History has taught the Germans before about the dangers of opening up on too many fronts at the same time, and its Eurex subsidiary is currently poised to pay top dollar for the International Securities Exchange.

This won’t fully satisfy the exchange’s desire to do deals, but with Eurex coughing up $2.8 billion for ISE – or 38 times prospective 2007 earnings – does the Deutsche Börse have the ready cash for another big deal? Spencer will be fully aware of the multiples exchanges are being valued at. Why should Icap be sold for a lower one? I am, of course, talking my book, but Icap is a truly diversified, global business.