FX turnover surges, as investors recognize market’s importance!

Wow – What a hyperbolical headline and opening sentence! Complete with what journalists call screamers – or exclamation marks for those who don’t know. Normally, screamers are only seen in low-brow publications; they have no place in august journals such as Euromoney.

But this is my column and, within reason, I set its tone. As I pointed out only this week when I apologized to someone over something I supposedly did that caused offence, you can take the boy out of southeast London, but you can’t take southeast London out of the boy. Anyway, as you can see, I’m in a positive mood this week, which will disappoint those who feel I only focus on negative aspects in this wonderful, great and, as the authoritative BIS Triennial Central Bank Survey reported on Tuesday, absolutely huge FX market.

The BIS Survey was interesting, even if its headline results shouldn’t have come as a surprise. Allow me the indulgence of giving myself a pat on the back. In April, I said turnover in the spot market was now around $1 trillion; only last Friday, I made a price of $3.25 trillion for total daily traditional turnover. Pretty much bang on, as it turns out. Once again that the old adage “once a dealer, always a dealer” still runs true.

In reality, neither prediction required rocket science. Possibly to the chagrin of various independent research boutiques, which in the past have been able to garner cheap publicity by predicting the size of the market, various central banks now publish semi-annual data on turnover. Simple extrapolation makes it easy to make accurate estimates about the market’s size. What I must confess, though, is that in my April piece, I seriously over-estimated the market share of both EBS and the CME. This was because I used their turnover data from March, which was actually a very busy month, while April was quite slow. This suggests that BIS’s findings might well have erred on the conservative side.

The survey prompted me to take another look at the CME’s and EBS’s market share, this time incorporating figures for outrights. These show that, up to April at least, the CME continued to expand at a far greater rate than both EBS and the overall market, as it has done consistently since 2001 (see tables). However, the two saw their overall market share decline, possibly because so many banks now provide superb platforms, with tight spreads and good liquidity and no commissions. It’s a simple equation: Liquidity + tight spreads + low (no) commission = increased turnover. 

Daily Average ($ billions)

1995

1998

2001

2004

2007

Spot

494

568

387

621

1,005

Change

+25%

+14%

-31%

+60%

+62%

Outrights

97

128

130

208

362

Change

+67%

+32%

+2%

+60%

+74%

CME (notional)

6

7

6

17

50

Change

-25%

+17%

-14%

+183%

+194%

EBS

25

90

75

115

144

Change

n/a

+260%

-17%

+53%

+25%

CME Market Share

1%

1%

1.1%

2%

3.5%

EBS Market Share

4.1%

12.9%

14.3%

13.6%

10.1%

CME & EBS Combined

5.1%

13.9%

15.4%

15.6%

14.6%

Tables are compiled from BIS Triennial Central Bank Survey; CME data from CME, EBS data from ICAP FX Spot

Because the loss in the two platforms’ combined market share is a result of banks attracting more flow, the headline decline is not as worrying as it might appear – the banks will always need a liquidity outlet, and although there has been talking about linking up their own platforms, this has yet to materialize. If it does, all platforms, including the CME and EBS, will have to start to worry.

Another factor to consider is how the market reacted when the longer-term, low-volatility environment suffered a jolt in August. Most platforms reported record days and months. EBS’s average daily turnover in August was $240 billion, a 66% increase on April. The CME’s was $78 billion, which was a rise of 56%. Both figures are impressive but EBS can possibly take heart that, at times of stress, it remains the market’s main spot outlet. It also possibly illustrates that there is a certain amount of liquidity repackaging on the CME, although nowhere near as much as on other platforms. What I’d like to be able to do is quantify how EBS’s market share is holding up against other cash platforms, including Reuters, but this is virtually impossible.

Interestingly, Derek Sammann, managing director and head of FX products at the CME, plays down the notion that the exchange is capturing market share at the expense of EBS. “It’s not a zero-sum game between the CME and EBS. We’ve not drawn dealing away from the cash market but grown our market more organically by bringing in new participants. The growth in futures has probably indirectly benefited EBS as well. We’re a multi-asset platform and we had clients trading other products electronically who took a look at FX, liked what they saw and then migrated across. Our growth has been to the benefit of the wider marketplace,” he says. In other words, the CME has thrived for the same reason the retail platforms are thriving – it has catered for an audience that was previously either neglected or not interested in FX. The same cannot be said for many other platforms, which makes me consider the rationale behind their existence. Expect some expensive and supposedly independent research on market structure to be published in due course.