Talking of liquidity: what goes around comes around. Consider a company called GFX Corporation. According to a Futures Industry Magazine from 10 years ago, “futures exchanges are continually searching for ways to enhance the liquidity of their markets, especially when launching new products”.
And, a decade ago, it seemed like my friends in Chicago had found the answer. “Paid and unpaid market makers, rebates for trades, privileges to trade in other markets if a certain number of trades are made in a target market – all these have been tried. New ground was broken on January 23 [1997] of this year, when the CME launched the first exchange subsidiary whose purpose is to enhance the liquidity of its products,” the old article continued.
“Actual transactions are offset in the interbank market and trades are cleared through a CME member firm. The objective is to create liquidity not to make a profit, so the exchange expects to foot the bill for overhead,” the magazine added.
Now this report covers events that are almost a decade old. Back then, the CME hadn’t even demutualized. What puzzles me is that GFX is still active. The CME makes no secret about its activities. According to its 2006 annual report: “GFX engages primarily in the purchase and sale of our foreign exchange futures contracts on the CME Globex platform to provide additional liquidity in these products.” I simply don’t see what need the CME now has for GFX and I know of no other exchange that has its own prop shop pumping in liquidity.
GFX has consistently made money and made net trading gains of $7 million and $7.6 million for 2006 and 2005 respectively; these profits were made with very little open risk. This suggests that it is still as active as ever. GFX gained access to Reuters years before prime brokerage offerings and there is talk that at one time it managed to get on to EBS. Quite why Reuters allowed this baffles me.
Anyway, I tried to track down GFX and the CME to ask a series of questions. I couldn’t understand why the CME had originally proposed that Derek Samman, its head of FX, replied, when GFX was supposedly a subsidiary. It acknowledged this was a fair point and put me on instead to Phupinder Gill (PG), CME’s president & chief operating officer, who also served as managing director and president of GFX. He came came back with the following replies:
The FiX: Does the CME still need GFX’s liquidity injection?
PG: GFX itself had not been a liquidity provider to CME Globex in major currencies for a number of years. This market has long been self sustaining. GFX continues in a market-making role for a few of our secondary currency products, such as the Mexican peso and New Zealand dollar, to the benefit of other market participants.
The FiX: How much volume does GFX provide?
PG: GFX’s market-making contributes less than 1% of the volume in our $80 billion-a-day FX market.
The FiX: What percentage of the CME’s turnover stems from GFX now, in 2004, 2001 and 1998?
PG: While GFX had an electronic futures market-making role in 1998, this would have been waning by 2001, particularly in the four large major currencies. By 2004, they [sic] had ceased all market-making activity in these four major currencies and have been reducing others ever since. More recently, GFX cut out their market-making in Canadian dollar futures during North American then European hours over the last year or so. This trend will continue.
The FiX: How does GFX’s existence affect your neutrality?
PG: Not at all. What’s important is that GFX’s methodology has always been about linking liquidity pools to help enhance CME’s FX market for the benefit of futures participants. GFX started with all manual market-makers in 1996 when the notional volume of CME FX on Globex was about $120 million a day. Today, although they still have some legacy trading activity in minor currencies, most of their business has migrated to electronic execution by helping link a diverse set of third-party financial participants into the CME Globex FX market. Every cash trade they do, no matter what the venue, has one side in the futures market. They carry no risk and everything is hedged.
The FiX: At what point do you become a bank rather than an exchange?
No response
The FiX: As GFX was on Reuters before PB, how did it secure credit lines, especially as at that time the CME had not grown into the big powerhouse it is now?
PG: A number of GFX’s bank counterparts interceded on their behalf with Reuters and convinced Reuters that there would be sufficient credit/liquidity for GFX to access their matching system as a professional counterparty.
The FiX: Does GFX pay exchange fees? In other words are the reported profits, which are impressive given the level of risk it assumes, net of costs?
PG: We obviously cannot elaborate on any financial issues outside of what we have formally disclosed to shareholders. I can tell you that GFX has a number of private co-development electronic trading partnerships with financial institutions, every one of which has the fees passed through to them.
The FiX: How many traders does GFX now have?
PG: GFX has 13 traders.
The FiX: Does it use algos or programs?
PG: “Algos” and “programs” are pretty loosely used terms these days. GFX is very technologically savvy with regard to connectivity and processing capabilities. Although they are well known for helping introduce/mentor many in the electronic FX community, they have never used anything like an algo or smart trading program themselves. They have never used price arbitrage, latency or system arbitrage programs, nor VWAP and TWAP, etc, in the past and unlikely that they would do so in future.
The FiX: Does GFX co-locate any servers?
PG: GFX does not utilize CME’s co-location offering, CME L-Net, and connects through third-party bandwidth vendors.
The CME has been always completely transparent about GFX. However, its existence, which puts it into competition with many of the CME’s clients, looks increasingly like an anomaly.