Terry Smith’s ambition appears to have been completely thwarted following the decision by Cantor Fitzgerald, eSpeed’s effective parent, to merge the trading technology vendor with its other, mainly voice broking subsidiary BGC.
“Dat showed dat Terry Smith, the f&*kin’ clown,” you could almost hear the management of Cantors/BGC/eSpeed saying.
What made the news surprising to many was that BGC had filed for an IPO. So, at face value, it seems that Howard Lutnick, who is basically the boss of all three companies, has been forced into making the move merely to see off Tulletts.
In a press release full of the normal good noises – note that there was no swearing in it either – Lutnick said: “We are extremely proud of each of these two companies and their strong positions in the marketplace. By combining these considerable strengths, we will achieve improved operating efficiencies and strengthen our market position, serving the best long-term interests of eSpeed’s stockholders, both companies’ customers and BGC’s employee-owners.”
“The strategic rationale for combining BGC and eSpeed is compelling,” chipped in Lee Amaitis, chairman and chief executive officer of BGC and vice chairman of eSpeed.
I have to say that I never quite understood the logic in splitting Cantor into three and it’s hard to think of them as separate entities. This view is shared by Octavio Marenzi, chief executive of consultancy company Celent Communications.
“It was always hard to really discern the separation between BGC and eSpeed and this transaction takes away some of the uncertainty surrounding the firms. BGC was planning on an IPO, but market reaction was lukewarm. Since BGC and eSpeed already work closely together, this merger will do little to allow the firms to better compete with market leaders Icap or Tullett,” he says.
News reaches me that far from being a move designed just to knock back Terry Smith, the merger was something BGC always wanted. In fact, I hear that BGC’s IPO was effectively a ploy to get eSpeed’s management to agree to the deal – apparently something some of them were reluctant to do, despite the common management in the two companies.