It’s well documented that Icap had a free run at EBS. Tullett Prebon was involved to an extent, but my view is that it was never serious; it’s only intention was to get Michael Spencer to pay more. I understand that Nasdaq took a peek, but the board was wary of selling to an exchange, and that the only other potential suitor was Thomson. I reckon the market should breathe a sigh of relief that nothing happened there. With private equity barred from bidding, the only buyer was Icap. Apparently, the shareholder banks wanted an owner they thought they could trust and perhaps even control. I can’t see how Michael Spencer fits this profile, but the talk is that various guarantees were given, which was enough to placate most of EBS’ board. I say most, because I hear two did categorically not want to sell and one other was very much of the view that the company was being given away too cheaply.
A couple of weeks back I wrote that both EBS and Reuters were considering handing out keyboards.
In response to the article, one global head of e-commerce commented: “I could never understand this. I would rather them (the buy side) have a keyboard and let them trip over their fingers like I did as a trader. Surely API connections are faster and easier to manipulate the market with than keyboards?”
This week, one of EBS’ board members told me something similar. “Personally I don’t think it makes much difference. The API was a lot worse.” He added that restricting buy-side access and not letting them have keyboards was like trying to get toothpaste back in the tube. However, while this seems to be the majority view, there is a suggestion that Icap had indicated it would not go down this route when it did the deal to buy EBS.
With Icap FX Spot now poised to extend its Prime offering and allow the buy side to use keyboards for a trial period from June 4, there are some who feel that promises have been broken. One global head told me that this is a slippery slope – the big difference now is that there will be little to stop anyone from the buy side trading on EBS. Using an API was arguably not easy because it did require some IT sophistication. But a spokesman for Icap says promises have not been broken: “We have always said we will maintain a close watch on the evolution of trading technology, the trading strategies of our varied customers and the growth of the FX market as a whole, then respond with the appropriate customer tools to reflect the dynamic nature of our business, our clients and our competitors. As a result we are piloting an extension to EBS Prime to enable manual keyboard access to the EBS platform for non-bank professional trading organisations.”
He adds: “This is in response to requests by the prime banks to provide this service for their non-bank customers. Our role is to facilitate a growing FX market and to ensure it remains orderly. A key part of this is to work with our prime customers to manage the integration of this non-bank segment into the FX professional trading community.”