Don’t look back in anger

A lot has been made of the banks’ rights to ‘last look’ on their own and some other multi-bank platforms. This allows them to reject trades. The inference is that they do this whenever a deal is done that doesn’t suit them.

I received an email this week from someone commenting on the relative lack of liquidity on FXMarketSpace. “The volume has started decreasing, yes, but I hope it will pick up again. Probably the banks like to keep things the old way, where they have no obligation to fill when it doesn’t suit them,” my contact writes.

Smarter people than me have termed FX a casino rather than a market; after all, the house always wins. But do banks really bust trades on such a frequent basis? Competition suggests that they can’t. I’m told that the rejection rate varies somewhere between less than 1% to as much as 20%, depending on the client. Active clients, I’m also told, benchmark the banks against rejections and will swiftly move on if they don’t like the fill-ratio they are getting. Furthermore, the rules are automated and trades are turned down for various reasons, such as static rates or latency, but not because a 12 offer was lifted and it’s now a 14 bid. “It’s not about looking back and simply saying, ‘I don’t fancy that trade,’” says the chief dealer at one bank in London.

I spoke to a very active retail aggregator and a second-tier bank – admittedly a small sample size – and neither had any complaints. In fact, the bank trader was unaware that his counterparty even had the right to turn a trade down. I’m told that so-called sharks are given zero tolerance by the banks. “Even the sharks don’t complain. If they get rejected 20% of the time, they’re still happy to have got the other 80% through,” one source said.

I can’t help but think the whole issue of last look is a massive red herring, used as a rather ineffectual marketing gimmick. If you think differently, feel free to contact me.

Look back in anger