Press coverage is often seen as an independent endorsement of a particular company’s services. The effects of winning prestigious awards, such as those in Euromoney’s annual FX poll, can be even greater. So it is no surprise to see both used by many firms as part of their advertising and marketing strategies. It’s all part of the game and this column has written several times about embellished or exaggerated marketing.
At Euromoney, we frequently receive emails asking about the veracity of some of the claims, particularly awards. You might think this is a simple, black and white issue: after all, a company either wins an award or it doesn’t. However, the market’s structure, particularly at the retail level, introduces a layer of opacity. To an extent, this is a legacy from the way the market has developed over the past decade. As retail platforms emerged, they sought to distribute their offering as far and as wide as possible. A major way to do so is by forming white-label partnerships (WLPs). For instance, Saxo Bank is believed now to have around 100 WLPs in place.
In the past the major banks shied away from getting directly involved with retail because of reputational risk. This catch-all term covers the negative fallout that they could face from when some granny loses her pension by punting currencies to doing a deal with a bucket shop. Now, with FX regarded as an asset class and the retail segment viewed as being a valuable source of flow, the aggregators too have to consider the damage that their WLPs can do to their own reputational risk.
Recently, the weeklyFiX received the following email. “I am trying to find the legitimacy of a company’s claim to your awards. The company is called Titan Financial Group. And its trading platform is called TitanPro V2 Trader. On their website they claim that they received many awards from you but I have not been able to verify their claims.”
Titan Financial, which is registered in the Commonwealth of Dominica, is an old WLP of Saxo; all the awards it mentioned on its amateurish-looking website have been won by the Danish bank.
I got in touch with the company. “I notice on your website that you have posted the awards won by Saxo, the provider I believe of your trading platform. I don’t think you have made it entirely clear these are not your awards but Saxo’s and appear to be exaggerated if not misleading marketing. You also say that you pass trades straight through to your (but presumably Saxo’s) liquidity providers. I’m not sure this is actually Saxo’s model,” I wrote.
The company responded. “Dear Sir, There seems allot (sic) of things you are not sure about. May I suggest that before you send such emails, please contact Saxobank and verify these facts. All their partners showcase their awards since we are all legal WLP of Saxobank. We clearly state that the software belongs to Saxobank on our site https://www.titanfingroup.com/awards.htm.”
I replied: “Thank you for your response. I have an excellent relationship with Saxo and will of course talk to Lars (Christensen, its chief executive). Looking at your website I see the following: ‘TitanPro Trader V2 again received top honors in three categories in 2006! Best in multi-bank platform, single-bank platform and the aggregated awards. Seven first place finishes! The best ever!’”
I continued: “I’m sorry if I’m being dyslexic, but in these claims, you say in every case that TitanPro V2 won the award and I think it was Saxo Trader.” My esteemed editor then waded in, read them the Riot Act and the company backed down, removing all the claims from its website. Of course, it may all have been a simple misunderstanding about what it and what Saxo have actually won.
Of far more concern are the claims made by a company called Modern Program. Again, we were alerted by a reader, who asked: “Please help me to verify whether the news [on its webpage] is valid or not.”
On its website, Modern Program claimed it was a multiple winner in the Euromoney FX poll: “In the 29th annual Euromoney FX poll, Modern Program turned in another strong performance, placing among the top 25 foreign exchange banks worldwide for the first time in its history. Modern Program also took home four first-place finishes in the single-bank platform category, for speed of execution, quality of pricing, post-trade services and options services,” it said.
Funnily enough, the design of Modern Program’s website was remarkably similar to Saxo’s: its logo shared the same basic design and colours – oh, and once again, the awards are really Saxo’s. Modern Program also made some spectacular claims about what clients can expect and said it was a European regulated bank, even though the address it gave out was in New Jersey. When I called the contact telephone number to have a chat, I discovered the number didn’t exist and the company has not responded to any emails.
Imitation may be the sincerest form of flattery, but Saxo does not see it like this. Lars Christensen is not happy that his company’s reputation could be tarnished and he has made it clear that Modern Program has never been one of Saxo’s WLPs. “When you have success, unfortunately, also the con artists notice. It is not the first time, and probably will not be the last time some crook is trying to conduct a scam abusing us or other reputable firms by confusing internet users. We always take immediate and decisive action against such abuses of our good reputation and we are already in the process of doing so in this case. Our legal and compliance team is on to it but we always appreciate it when people bring such cases to our attention and thank Euromoney for doing so in this case,” he says.
He adds: “I am relatively comfortable that in the few cases we have had where someone has tried to copy our webpage, it has not led to any loss of money for prospective clients. It seems always to get detected before people try to fund an account with the con artists.”
Modern Program’s site is so ridiculous that it is inconceivable someone would ever deposit money with it. But like the Nigerian spammers who dream up scheme after scheme to dupe the gullible, it only takes one mug to fall for it to have made it worthwhile.
Retail FX is maturing and it is changing fast. The regulators are starting to clamp down in jurisdictions whose regimes have perhaps been overly lenient; the entrance of the big boys into the sector will help to reshape it. Companies such as Saxo will start to look up the food chain to do WLPs rather than down. FX has done a remarkable job of policing itself over the years. The community of participants is growing and the shelf life of fraudulent companies is dwindling fast.
* Note: the Modern Program website has been closed down since the FiX contacted Saxo.