Just over three years ago, Bank of England chief dealer Martin Mallet described a phenomenon he termed the “liquidity mirage” in a speech he made to delegates at an Association Cambiste International congress held in London. Since then, the issue of liquidity management has remained a hot topic in the FX market, particularly to the leading banks that stream prices to various trading venues.
Mallett’s comments specifically referred to the way multiple platforms showed the same price. Aggregating these created an impression that the market’s liquidity was far deeper than it was, as ultimately all the different prices stemmed from a single source. To the chagrin of the market’s big liquidity providers, some aggressive participants started to take advantage of this. Their ability to profit further accelerated when they were allowed access to EBS and Reuters, the market’s effective liquidity hubs. In addition, some technologically advanced market participants started to take advantage of the latency between the various trading outlets. Not surprisingly, the liquidity providers took umbrage and started to reconsider not only where they were putting their liquidity but how to price it. The situation now is that banks are rethinking where they stream their prices to, ending the period where all flow was considered good.
Efficiency
The recent decisions by Barclays Capital and Deutsche Bank to allow their clients to post bids and offers to their own platforms (see The weeklyFiX for more details) could well prove highly significant; other banks are almost certain to follow suit. As the 2007 Euromoney FX poll showed in May, the top five banks in the FX market, which account for about 61% of the volume traded, are highly efficient at internalizing their order flows.
Barclays’ and Deutsche’s moves are designed to improve their own liquidity and, in what appears a win/win situation, there are also obvious benefits for their clients. Having the ability to show an interest means they will be able to trade on their own price, potentially reducing the implicit cost of trading. As important for many, they will be able to do this without paying commission.
The question is why then anyone would wish to pay to trade on a multi-bank platform? Liquidity is unlikely to prove an issue on any of the major bank’s platforms and ultimately competition will ensure that spreads remain ultra-thin. Furthermore, those who wish to can aggregate the bank platforms into a single virtual trading platform.
Independence
Mark Warms, general manager of FXall in Europe, plays down any concerns. “The trend in the FX market, as with other asset classes, has been towards independent platforms that offer a level playing field to market participants, who are becoming ever more sophisticated and as a result increasingly discriminating,” he says. “They are looking to take part in a market with natural interest distributed across a diverse group of participants.”
He adds: “They want guaranteed price/time priority. They want to be sure that everyone is playing by the same rules. The market for FX ECNs continues to evolve and we are confident that in the long run it will be the platform with the most diverse sources of liquidity combined with independence and transparency that will see the most adoption.”
Justyn Trenner, chief executive of ClientKnowledge, who recently wrote a report on liquidity management and the challenges facing the sell side, feels that it might be an exaggeration to say that the multi-bank platforms are facing a challenge. “I’m not too sure it will affect the multi-bank platforms to a great extent. The banks might well attract some liquidity away from them but FX is a rapidly growing market and more participants are becoming familiar with the concept of dealing on their own price. If the likes of Deutsche educate them how to do this further, they [the clients] may well then add liquidity to platforms such as Hotspot,” he says.
And yet, even though they will not say it publicly, there is no doubt that the sell side is seeking to retake charge of its liquidity. And despite all the talk about how great the impact has been from a new breed of market makers, ultimately it is still the liquidity from the market’s traditional big players that supports it.
Wisdom
Barclays’ decision when it started to make its successful push into e-commerce not to provide liquidity to every platform but to limit it to its proprietary Barx offering is increasingly being recognized as wise. As a senior trader at a top-five FX bank says, the days when banks streamed liquidity on to every start-up platform have now gone. As it stands, liquidity management appears to involve yet another information technology spend. However, looking ahead, is there really any logic in spending huge amounts of money to combat an issue that arises from supporting too many venues, when a simpler solution exists? Once, the migration of the market to an exchange would have been the obvious solution, but that is no longer the case. The leading banks have become technology providers and as long as their platforms have the prices and functionality their clients want, they clearly pose a threat for all of the multi-bank portals, EBS, Reuters and the CME included.
![]() |
“The possibility of creating a peer-to-peer market by linking platforms is becoming a reality” |
Although the big FX banks are efficient in internalizing their flow, they will still need external outlets for the business they cannot match up. If they do pull back their liquidity, it would be easy to surmise that perhaps the most obvious expectation is that the positions of EBS, Reuters and perhaps the CME will be further strengthened. Links
However, another idea is being revived and this is that the banks link their platforms together. Just over 18 months ago (see Euromoney December 2005, “Do the big FX banks need a new platform?“), this idea was dismissed as ridiculous. But now it is regarded as having merit. “The possibility of creating a peer-to-peer market by linking platforms is becoming a reality,” says Axel Pierron, an analyst at Celent Communications. “The banks clearly want to have greater control of their liquidity and in FX they are very efficient in internalizing it. However, they still need external sources and dealing with each other is a solution. The Yellow Submarine initiative in fixed income shows that this is being considered as a way forward. Also, although spot FX is not covered by Mifid, its impact should not be underestimated and it will drive changes.”
He adds: “Due to Mifid, European banks are upgrading elements of their trading system infrastructure and can now seize new business opportunities because they will have the technology to support it.”
