Some of you may be wondering who Martin Peters is – he was a great footballer and member of the 1966 World Cup winning team. Sir Martin Peters, to give him his full title, was so good that he was frequently described as being 10 years ahead of his time.
To call myself the Martin Peters of financial blogging is a bold and arrogant claim. But, even if I say so myself, it’s justifiable. In late 2002, I set up a website with various muckers under the pseudonym of Mr Angry. This was a pre-blog blog, and for that reason alone I claim to have been ahead of my time. The site’s purpose was to provide a forum on which people could rant about financial topics on a regular basis. One of our most popular tactics was to send an email to a company’s chief executive or chairman and ask awkward questions. As the site said: “The way these captains of industry respond says much about the companies they run.”
We scored some notable successes and along the way we discovered that those chief executives who felt able to respond without the aid of their lawyers were normally at the helm of companies that were either about to turn around or were already doing well – notable examples were Ben Verwaayen at BT and Stuart Rose at Marks & Spencer. A few bosses took spectacular umbrage and suffered from major sense of humour failures, while many more opted for silence. Among the latter were Tom Glocer, chief executive of Reuters, and Sharon Rowlands, the president and chief executive officer for Thomson Financial.
Funnily enough, Glocer now has his own blog (tomglocer.com) to post his own comments. Here is a recent one: “I hope you will all excuse my silence over the past few weeks as I was busy reaching our historic agreement with Thomson Corp and, at least in my little world, nothing else seemed as important to comment upon.”
As Mr Angry, I wrote about a possible Thomson and Reuters tie up as long ago as February 7 2003. I even sent Glocer an email. “I might be talking out of my arse, but Reuters has recently come into focus for many analysts. Their views on the whole are extremely negative. This is fully understandable given the company’s many deep-rooted problems. What will hold up the shares and perhaps trigger a rally is the fact that Reuters is starting to look as cheap as chips. Thomson could probably buy it out of petty cash, while there are other smaller, more nimble vendors out there with wealthy backers.” At the time, Reuters’ shares were languishing around 150p.
You have to admit, that was a bit of a Martin Peters moment. Switch forward a few years and Thomson has finally pulled the trigger, paying around 700p a share for Reuters. While Glocer hasn’t managed to get the shares back to the dizzy levels they were trading at when Reuters was a dot.com darling, he will be rightly applauded by the company’s shareholders for the value he has managed to add.
I’m not sure what Thomson’s shareholders think, given they could have got it from the bargain basement just a few years ago. However, I suppose all the slashing and burning at Reuters has now been done, which may justify the price. Who knows what the future will bring for the newly merged media behemoth, but looking into my crystal ball, I don’t anticipate it causing Mike Bloomberg too many sleepless nights. Many of my FX sources now swear by Bloomberg and have ditched their Reuters terminals.
Anyway, Glocer explains on his blog why he decided to publish his musings: “We are all subject to a lot of official communications these days from companies, governments, celebrities and others. All too often these are ghost-written passages concocted by overeager PR machines and do little to tell you anything new about the author, or his or her true interests,” he says.
I couldn’t agree more, so I decided to email Glocer some questions about FXMarketSpace (FXMS), the platform Reuters formed as a joint venture with the CME. I did this, because it seems that if I ask anyone at FXMS any questions, they ignore me. I can only assume that this is because I want to write more than what’s contained in its official communications.
Glocer was swift to respond:
Lee,
From your questions it looks like you have formed some weird views of both the FXMS business and its relationship with the two parents. Your note is unusually hostile for a working journalist.
I don’t want to go into the details of each of your propositions, but I found myself in disagreement with almost all. What I can tell you is that I and Reuters are pleased with the joint venture, its progress and its prospects to be a very important (but not the only) player in the FX market. FXMS itself releases monthly volume figures so you can follow the progress there.
I thought the questions I sent Glocer were fair, and so did my esteemed editor. Naturally, I sent a response.
Thanks for the reply Tom.
I wouldn’t say that my note is particularly hostile, but if it comes across like that, I’m more than happy to apologise. My views tend to be coloured very much by the dealings I have with companies. My relationship with Reuters and the CME is excellent and even when I question some of the obvious puff put out by both companies, it is, I hope, regarded as an attempt to cut through the spiel.
So what can we conclude from all of this? Companies still don’t like being asked tough questions, especially when they question the viability or the logic of one of their businesses. As for being hostile, I plead not guilty. I took my Mr Angry hat off a long while ago and I’m more like Mr Serene these days. But if it does take a kick to open a door, I’ll still stick the boot in. I’ve asked some questions, they haven’t been answered. I think to simply dismiss them is patronising to me and the wider FX market.
Clearly, it’s still too early to say whether FXMS will be a success or not. My own view is not particularly relevant, but I think that even if it does succeed – which given the lack of enthusiasm for the venture from the market’s true liquidity providers ¬is a big ‘if’ – it will struggle for longer than both the CME and Reuters have perhaps anticipated. I’ll also wager that in five years time, this column will prove a better source for what actually went on than all the corporate PR puff that has been put out and then regurgitated by those who do not have the luxury of independence. One of my contacts reminded me only today that the first cut is the cheapest – or put another way, there’s no point throwing good money after bad.