Proposed NFA rules seen as catalyst for consolidation in US retail

The US National Futures Association (NFA) has sent out a proposal to its 43 Forex Dealer Members (FDMs) which if passed will almost inevitably lead to a huge consolidation in the US retail market. The proposal will be presented to the NFA’s board in August; if it is ratified, it will then be sent to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), which effectively acts as the NFA’s gatekeeper. If accepted by this body, the NFA will then set a date by which FDMs would have to meet the new capital requirements.

The US National Futures Association (NFA) has sent out a proposal to its 43 Forex Dealer Members (FDMs) which if passed will almost inevitably lead to a huge consolidation in the US retail market. The proposal will be presented to the NFA’s board in August; if it is ratified, it will then be sent to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), which effectively acts as the NFA’s gatekeeper. If accepted by this body, the NFA will then set a date by which FDMs would have to meet the new capital requirements.

The reasons for the proposal are obvious. “In the past 20 years, there have been nine FCM (Full Commission Merchants) insolvencies. Since 1990, there have been only two insolvencies by traditional FCMs trading on US exchanges, and no funds in segregated customer accounts were lost in either of those two instances. This is from a population that averages around 250 (over the last 20 years),” says the NFA.

“The FCM insolvency rate becomes more troubling when FDMs are added to the mix. Of the three bankruptcy or receivership proceedings for insolvency occurring in the last four years, two have involved FDMs (Refco was the third), and they are drawn from the smaller FDM population (averaging around 40). Specifically, in late 2003, an FDM misappropriated almost $2 million of customer funds, which depleted the amount of assets necessary to meet the amounts owed to customers” it adds.

The NFA continues: “NFA’s concern that one day an FDM might be unable to meet its financial obligations to its customers has heightened as the amount of retail customer funds held by FDMs has increased to over $1 billion. The above described FDM insolvencies have done nothing to abate this concern, particularly with the most recent occurring just months after the $1 million capital requirement became effective.”

There is a stark contrast between the US retail market and those in other jurisdictions, such as the UK and Japan. One well placed source described how easy it is to set up an operation in the US compared with the UK, where the Financial Services Authority’s rules are far stricter. To combat what it sees as the problem, the NFA is proposing to raise FDMs’ net capital requirements from $1 million to $5 million. Two other proposed changes to the NFA’s concentration charges and its accounting requirements are likely to result in FDMs having to have a minimum of $10 million in adjusted net capital to stay in business. 

At the moment, the vast majority of FDMs don’t have this much free capital available; unless they receive fresh funding, they will almost certainly go out of business if the proposal is passed. If nothing else alters, it is likely that only a handful of FDMs, including FXCM, GFT, Oanda, FX Solutions and Gain Capital will remain in business in the US if the rule changes are implemented. Retail FX, as the report below highlights, is a booming area. Tighter regulation where it is needed will ultimately increase the confidence investors have in it. The NFA’s proposal will, if passed, result in a far better retail market than currently exists.

“We support the NFA’s proposal,” says Gain’s chairman, Mark Galant. “Making sure all FDMs are well capitalized is a positive for the industry. The management at many of the smaller FDMs have no real FX market experience and have never managed a 24×5 trading operation. Besides being able to cover your financial obligations to your customers, you also need sufficient capital to post collateral with bank liquidity providers. An FDM that does not have good credit lines can get in trouble pretty quickly if they are unable to lay off their risk as needed.”