Have your bath and leak it

"FX is like a cracked bath, where the taps are running but the water is leaking out."

We all like to use metaphors and analogies, although I’m led to believe they have no real place in journalism. Still, as I wrote only the other day, FX is a big enough pie for most people to get a decent meal.

I heard a new one at lunch on Monday: FX is like a cracked bath, where the taps are running but the water is leaking out. That, so my mucker claimed, should worry the major liquidity providers, because the leakage is going off to alternative platforms. My view is slightly different. Provided the taps keep running, the major liquidity providers will probably not be too concerned. The problem will only become apparent if the taps slow and liquidity starts to dry up at the market’s hubs and, depending on how far below the water line the leak is, at alternative venues. I’m not sure where that crack is, and so who is the most vulnerable, the established hubs or the new upstarts who thrive on the repackaging of liquidity.

Ultimately, whether or not FX is comparable to a cracked bath (You should know all about taking baths in FX – Ed.) is not that relevant. The main point here is that it takes opinions to make markets. My mucker expressed the view that the market will still move, eventually, to a centralized location, if only because it is easier to maintain liquidity in a closed system. My view, at least for this month, is that it won’t and the reason is that the major sell-side liquidity providers won’t allow this to happen.

It is astonishing how important the explicit cost of trading is to many genuine buy-side counterparties. Now that they are able to trade electronically on state-of-the-art bank platforms, which provide good liquidity and tight spreads, it is likely that there will be consolidation of platforms – especially as some banks are now allowing their clients to post their own prices. Clearly, some portals have established real footholds, whether in retail or institutional; these will survive, but the platform space is starting to look over-crowded, even for the huge FX market.

Banks and certain retail platforms are incredibly efficient at internalizing flow; what they can’t match, spills out into the market. Who knows, perhaps at some stage, direct dealing will re-emerge in spot, but at the moment, what spills out is more than adequate for the likes of EBS, Reuters, CME and perhaps a few others. With banks re-evaluating the true cost of liquidity, the days of posting prices on every platform in existence have gone. My prediction is that once the plug is pulled on one platform, it will be pulled on others.