By Zach Fuchs
Local-currency sovereign issues generally give a boost to creditworthiness because they reduce a country’s exposure to FX movements. But even though Colombia has been aggressive in reducing its hard-currency bonds as a proportion of government debt – from 50% to 30% in two years – it is now just one notch away from slipping out of investment-grade territory in its local currency rating.
Moody’s Investors Service pushed Colombia’s domestic currency bond rating down to Baa3 from Baa2 at the end of June, although the country’s other ratings held firm. According to Steven Hess, a senior credit officer at Moody’s, the downgrade has nothing to do with Colombia’s fundamentals. “We’re fixing some ratings that were based on an older methodology,” he says.
As emerging market funds pack their portfolios with local-currency bonds, the agencies are aligning the credit risk of domestic-denominated debt with that of hard-currency debt. Increased foreign involvement in the local-currency markets makes this change necessary. “After all, it’s the same issuer,” says Hess.
Many countries used to inflate their way out of local-currency debt, explaining the previously higher notching. That’s less of an option now that emerging economies are more cautious about their macroeconomic fundamentals.
Julio Torres, Colombia’s director-general of public credit, is pleased that his country’s local debt remains at investment grade. “We were Ba2 in our external debt and Baa2 in our internal debt but Moody’s only downgraded us by one notch. This is because the fundamentals are so strong. They could have even done a three-notch downgrade if they wanted.”
“With three notches of difference [between its foreign and local currency ratings], Colombia was a clear outlier,” says Alexei Remizov, Dresdner Kleinwort’s director responsible for Latin America sovereign origination. “The fact that Moody’s decided to maintain the local currency debt in investment grade reflects the agency’s confidence in the depth of local markets.”
Nevertheless, mounting fiscal imbalances are causing concern. Although regional governments and key state-owned enterprises are running surpluses, the central government’s pension obligations are expected to cause the ratio of public debt to GDP to deteriorate from 50% to 60% in coming years.