Risk management: Saving face: Brazil’s derivatives boom

The small teams of professionals who work for the three clearing houses (foreign exchange, securities, derivatives) at Brazil’s Bolsa de Mercadorias & Futuros (BM&F) have a claustrophobia-inducing office, locked as they are inside a glass cube that sits in the centre of a larger room inside the exchange’s headquarters. Despite working in this intimidating setting, the clearing houses’ directors are welcoming and their efforts are for now focused on increasing foreigners’ access to and participation in Brazil’s growing derivatives market.

The small teams of professionals who work for the three clearing houses (foreign exchange, securities, derivatives) at Brazil’s Bolsa de Mercadorias & Futuros (BM&F) have a claustrophobia-inducing office, locked as they are inside a glass cube that sits in the centre of a larger room inside the exchange’s headquarters. Despite working in this intimidating setting, the clearing houses’ directors are welcoming and their efforts are for now focused on increasing foreigners’ access to and participation in Brazil’s growing derivatives market.

“We are launching new products, such as a dollar option contract with daily variation margin, that will facilitate structured volatility transactions and make them cheaper,” says Cicero Vieira, director of the derivatives clearing house. He says that foreign participants are involved in about 15% of the exchange’s daily trades by volume, up from 5% just three years ago. Brazil’s notoriously complex regulatory and tax regime is, however, still a major barrier to foreign investment. One key measure that could encourage more hedging in Brazil would be if the BM&F could accept collateral abroad: at the moment the law says that it can collect from a defaulting institution only the collateral that it holds in Brazil.

More than 1 million contracts are traded daily on the BM&F, compared with half that figure in 2004, yet there is still much progress to be made. “The percentage of companies in Brazil that use the BM&F is relatively small,” says Vieira, “with most of them going to the over-the-counter market.” For the moment, many CFOs, such as airline Gol’s Richard Lark, prefer to do their hedging abroad on exchanges such as New York’s where they can secure longer-term contracts and benefit from dealing with specialists with greater sector understanding. The BM&F hopes this will change.

Marcelo Salgado, senior director of the securities clearing house, is keen to emphasize the BM&F’s internationalizing agenda. “We are investing in auto-routing,” he says, “so that hopefully by late September investors in London, for example, will be able to see the whole book. There are certain barriers to foreign investment in Brazil, such as bonds being quoted under different conventions and a lack of transparency on the over-the-counter market, but we are working hard to overcome such obstacles.”

Isney Rodrigues, director of the foreign exchange clearing house, echoes the views of his colleagues in saying that the BM&F has been instrumental in reducing systemic risk in Brazil’s burgeoning markets. Nonetheless, derivatives are inherently dangerous if improperly used. Vieira says that the BM&F takes the obligation to educate and inform very seriously and has established an educational department.