Market sources say that Reuters is about to try to penetrate the FX options market again by launching a revamped matching service for currency derivatives at the start of October. Players seem split in their view of how likely it is that the beefed-up Reuters Matching for FX Options will succeed. The company has already had unsuccessful forays into the market, notably with its ICor venture, launched initially as a joint venture back in 2001.
The FX options market has proved reluctant to embrace electronic trading fully and the voice brokers still play a very active and crucial role in both price discovery and the provision of access to liquidity, especially in emerging markets. However, the hybrid Volbroker system, owned by TFS-ICAP, is said to be playing an increasingly important role.
Whether Reuters can replicate the success of Volbroker is debatable. Volbroker is backed up by TFS-ICAP’s voice brokers, and users say it combines the benefits of an electronic platform, such as transparency and straight-through processing, with the ability of the brokers to find liquidity.
However, many banks are dissatisfied – as they always have been – with the levels of commission they are charged. These vary from bank to bank and from currency to currency but sources say they can be as high as $100 per million dollars in some emerging markets. In contrast, Reuters is believed to be proposing a flat rate of $10 per million dollars, regardless of currency pair.
One senior options player said that the banks’ hands are effectively tied, with the brokers being able to charge whatever they like in return for access to liquidity. Although it is in the nature of banks to grumble about their brokerage bills, many view this as an acceptable trade-off.
In the past, the attempts of Reuters and others to take the option market electronic have proved unsuccessful, primarily because they have only been able to build any kind of liquidity in at-the-money options in major currencies. Whether this is about to change remains to be seen but it is believed that Reuters has managed to secure some initial support from a very big market player.
One market cynic dismisses the Reuters initiative as “another solution looking for a problem. It did not work five years ago and there is no reason to assume that it will work now,” he says. He adds: “Reuters still cannot attract a decent pool of liquidity in spot euro/US dollar after trying for 13 years. It is not going to be able to draw away FX options liquidity from its current locations. It might be able to scratch a living, but that is all.”
He continues: “If Reuters has a signed and sealed Service Level Agreement from a major bank that commits that bank to make a running price in a reasonable amount and a tight spread, then perhaps some people will look at it as a guide to where the market is and maybe it can develop further. On the other hand, if Reuters has met some dealer down the pub and that dealer has agreed through a drunken haze to quote them some support prices, then forget it. Remember, nothing ever happens on the support prices, so promising to support it could turn out to be providing something for nothing.”
Another angle is that even if the relaunch is unsuccessful, there is a chance that it will result, if only for the short term, in lower brokerage rates. Eurex’s failed foray in US treasury futures provides an easy analogy. Few gave the venture any chance but it created enough of a competitive threat to force the Chicago Board of Trade to slash its fees. The FX options market, the brokers will argue, is already so competitive that it has already seen considerable consolidation.
It remains to be seen whether the Reuters initiative will force brokerage levels lower. “Voice brokers will not see Reuters as a threat, so they are very unlikely to cut brokerage. If I was broking and a bank said to me. ‘I can deal through Reuters at $10 per million’, I would simply say. ‘Off you go then’. They’ll soon be back when they can’t get the liquidity they need,” says the cynic.
What is clear is that few in the market believe it can sustain another options broker and the pressure will increase if an electronic one able to undercut the four incumbents proves successful. As the voice brokers argue they have already cut their costs to the bone, they might do well to hide their ostentatious bling the next time they host a corporate golf day. Turning up in their partner’s school-run car might prove a better strategic choice than rolling out the Ferrari.