Research by investment management consultancy firm Investit indicates that the new regulation requiring the unbundling and reporting of commission spent by the buy side on execution and research is putting pressure on fund managers to justify the sell-side research they are using.
As of January this year (following the publication of PS05/9 by UK regulator the Financial Services Authority), fund managers in the UK have to make known to clients what is being spent out of those clients’ commission on research and execution. In the US, the SEC is known to be considering a similar approach. “If managers have been reliant on broker research bought with client commission, they will need to be able to demonstrate the value of that research,” says Richard Phillipson, principal at Investit. “And if fund managers need to quantify the value of research, it is likely that there will be rating systems springing up that can help judge research objectively. At the moment, managers tend to divide commission among brokers by a voting system that they will find hard to explain.”
Pressure on brokers
Phillipson believes that now research costs are to be displayed separately there will be pricing pressure on the brokers providing research, and fund managers will be more selective. “There is an estimated billion pounds spent by managers on research for clients covered by the new rules in London alone,” he says. “If people buy 20% less research, you can imagine the effect it will have on the banks.” The pressure on brokers is already clear, with the number of sell-side analysts in Europe steadily declining while in the US commissions have been falling at 6% a year for the past 30 years.
An emerging trend could be the growth in popularity of independent research. At present, research is purchased through commission generated by the buying and selling of clients’ shares. The new regulations do away with the distinction between bundled and soft commission, so by using commission-sharing agreements the execution and research can be paid for separately. This means that research companies without execution can be paid with commission more easily than in the past.
Independents on the rise
Half of the fund managers surveyed by Investit said that they believed use of research from banks and brokers would decrease and the other half felt it would remain the same. However, about 70% of them believed the use of independent research would increase and about a quarter that it would at least stay the same.