FXall set for partial sale to private equity buyer

The sale of Hotspot has prompted a torrent of speculation about the future of other ECNs. But it seems the rumours about a sale of FXall are true.

FXall, the leading electronic platform in the foreign exchange market, is set for a new ownership structure. Euromoney has learnt that the ECN’s owners, a consortium of leading foreign exchange banks, are locked in discussions about a potential sale of up to 30% of the company to a private equity buyer.

Euromoney understands that Goldman Sachs has been appointed to run the books on the sale. Two counterparties – both private equity firms – are bidding for the stake.

Bankers involved in discussions about the deal say its completion is some way off. A debate surrounds the amount of stock the bank owners are prepared to unload. Most are in favour of a sale of between 25% and 30% on a pro rata basis, although Euromoney understands that a small number of banks would like to see a complete sale of FXall.

Discussions have apparently been slowed by the recent sale of Hotspot. That deal failed to realize its previous owners the valuation that most in the market had anticipated, leading the bank-owners of FXall to revise their expectations.

FXall Goldman Sachs and banks involved in FXall all declined to comment. But the proposed sale is the most concrete of a host of rumours sweeping the eFX market – a space that even in the quietest month is full of gossip is about matters such as who is supposedly buying who, who is shutting down, whose technology is good and whose is bad.

This month, the gossip has not just been prolific; it has also been highly scurrilous. The announcement in January of Hotspot’s sale to Knight Capital appears to have really cranked up the rumour mill.

In addition to the partial sale of FXall, Icap admitted at the end of January that it was in preliminary discussions with a view to a potential purchase of EBS. The latest noise surrounds Currenex. Both companies have denied this is true. Currenex chief executive Cliff Lewis, who has repeatedly said over the past few months that he would like to be a consolidator, rather than be consolidated, states bluntly: “We’re not for sale and don’t need money.”

Apparently though, the sale of Hotspot has set a benchmark for valuing FX ECNs. Hotspot was apparently almost sold for $125 million last year, but eventually it went for around $77.5 million. Consequently, FXall is not now able to attract as much as it thought, even though its volumes are continuing to expand. According to the company, 2005 volumes came in at 40% higher than the previous year and it is proud of the fact that it has a sufficiently diversified client base to have seen growth in every quarter of its existence.

But the award for this month’s most scurrilous rumour is that one ECN is arbitraging its own platform. The buzz is that it had been using a broker as its ‘points bank’ and capitalizing by cashing in on inverse prices resulting from system latency.

So the rumour, it has then been using the cash the activity generates as a secret fund to cross subsidise its business and charge a low commission. The company that was the subject of these rumours denies them in the strongest terms. Most market participants are flabbergasted by the claim. There are few secrets which remain uncovered in FX market, so it seems unlikely that substance to this rumour is true.

If nothing else, the bad mouthing makes it clear is that the ECN space is extremely competitive; most of the big liquidity providers make no secret of the fact that they would prefer to have business coming onto their proprietary platforms than getting it from an ECN. The fact that most of the rumours tend to originate from within the ECN sector itself is proof that the inverse of the old English saying, “where’s there’s muck, there’s brass”, is also very true.

MORE on this topic:

Hotspot sale spurs talk of eFX consolidation

FX round-up: EBS up for sale… apparently

FX round-up: Does Hotspot takeover signal consolidation?