Iceland Bulletin

THE ISK - A YEAR OF TWO HALVES [by bridport & cie, January 5th 2006]

THE ISK – A YEAR OF TWO HALVES [by bridport & cie, January 5th 2006]

Bridport has long stated that we believe the ISK to be an overvalued currency. The currency remains high (ISK Trade Weighted Index currently at 106.05) and we expect it to remain strong at least until end Q2 06. We see the following factors as supporting the ISK:

 

  • The domestic economy remains overheated and is yet to peak
  • The Central Bank raised interest rates by 225bps in 2005 and this trend will continue through 2006. The interest rate differential will continue to increase until the Central Bank stops the current tightening regime (we see this being end Q2 06)
  • Continued ISK Eurobond issuance

However our overall assessment of the ISK for 2006 is bearish with a house view that the currency (as measured by the TWI Index) will depreciate by at least 12-15% a trend that is likely to start as we enter the second half of the year. The ISK will weaken on:

 

  • The economy adjusting to a new equilibrium following the completion of the aluminum smelters
  • A wide current account deficit – currently at record levels. The trade deficit reached ISK 11.2bn in November 2005 compared with only ISK 2bn in 2004. Imports have increased YOY by 33% with the import of autos up by 80% YOY
  • The topping out of the hiking cycle
  • ISK Eurobond issuance drying up

We give the following caution to our clients who hold ISK paper. When the depreciation of the ISK starts (we are looking at end Q2 06) it will happen rapidly. Based on the historical relationship between the real exchange rate and the current account deficit we see at least a 17% depreciation of the ISK being needed by the end of 2007 to return the economy to a state of equilibrium following imbalances caused chiefly by the spate of aluminum smelters constructed. A 17% depreciation would see the ISK TWI Index rise to 127, a weakness not seen for three years. No analysis however would be complete without a caveat. The chief uncertainty in this forecast remains decisions surrounding the number of aluminum smelters that will be constructed in the forecast period. Any plans to construct more smelters will delay the ISK’s depreciation.

 

It warrants mention how the ISK market has developed in 2005. The average daily turnover in the currency market was ISK 12bn in December 2005 compared to ISK 5 bn in the same period in 2004. This increased turnover that we attribute to a surge in interest from foreign investors (and hold ourselves partially responsible) has increased both the depth and the width of the market as more participants contribute to price formation and is especially evident in the swaps market.

 

 

CENTRAL BANK POLICY – THE END OF A CYCLE

 

The Central Bank has raised rates by 5.2% since the start of the cycle in May 2004. We see the Central Bank adding another 75-100bps in the first half of 2006 before starting an easing process in the beginning of 2007 when the peak of the aluminum smelter led development has passed and demand growth slows.

 

The first formal interest rate decision meeting takes place on the 26th January (there are three formal rate meetings in 2006 and three meetings to coincide with the publication of the monetary bulletin), and we expect 25-50bps. However the Central Bank’s Policy is difficult to call. Inflation still remains outside its upper tolerance level at 4.1% and we have found the Central Bank to be inconsistent in its messages and its actions, having previously talked the talk of peaking through 12% a target that we now see as unlikely. Iceland’s transparency remains a long way from a Trichet ideal.

 

 

EUROBOND ISSUANCE – TO BE CONTINUED

 

Since August 2005 there has been over ISK 150 bn in ISK Eurobond issuance (equivalent to 15% of Iceland’s GDP). Will we continue to see further issuance and if so what will its effect on the currency be? Going back to Microeconomics 101 we know more often than not that supply meets demand. A quick call to the market leaders in ISK issuance told us that yesterday their London desk wrote 165 tickets in ISK ALL of them sales. Undoubtedly therefore the demand is still there – and with demand comes supply. New Issues will continue to be brought to market to join those ever expanding issues that seem to be tapped on a weekly basis. We are happy to believe that demand and therefore supply will remain constant until the interest rate differential begins to narrow in Q3 06.

 

What effect will this have on the currency? Locals suggest that each billion of ISK issuance results in a 0.1% appreciation on the currency. While we agree that ISK issuance has of course supported the currency, we consider this approach slightly naïve. Not only do the maths not add up but Iceland does not act in a vacuum and news coming out of Euroland and the US is going to make a difference. This was made evident in November 2005 with issuance continuing unabated, a month that saw a weakening in the ISK versus all major currencies.

 

 

Peregrine Hood

+41 22 817 7021