Renminbi: Small steps on a long journey

China's currency revaluation is more evolution than revolution but will have a number of knock-on effects

Zhou Xiao Chuan: good timing

China’s long-awaited revaluation of its currency, the renminbi, has had a modest impact on the international financial markets. However, the move, which saw the renminbi revauled upwards by 2.1% in June, looks well timed. The new system, which sees the renminbi managed against a basket of currencies as opposed to being held at a fixed rate against the dollar, is suitably flexible for China’s immediate purposes. At the same time, it panders somewhat to the China-bashers in the US Congress, the more vociferous of whom had been barking for a revaluation of more than 25%. Basket

Of course that was never going to happen, but China’s move is more than just a sop to US politicians looking for scapegoats for the structural weaknesses in their own economy. In a later statement, China’s central bank governor, Zhou Xiao Chuan, added a little more meat to the bones of the country’s new currency framework when he disclosed the constituent currencies, although critically not the weightings, within the basket against which the renminbi will be “referenced”. It is no surprise that the basket includes the US dollar, yen, Euro and Korean won, China’s four largest trading partners. Less obvious constituents are the Australian, Canadian and Singapore dollars, sterling, the Thai baht, Malaysian ringgit and Russian rouble.

To add to China’s case for credibility in exchange rate reform, the government also announced a relaxation of restrictions on the trading of foreign currency, permitting non-banking institutions to trade in the renminbi spot market. They have also agreed to permit more foreign banks to play in the forward market.

The effects of all this on the global economy will take a while to play out, although most market commentary was positive. The most immediate effect came not in China but in Malaysia. Fearful of suffering inflows of speculative capital into the country’s financial system as a result of the renminbi adjustment, the Malaysian government announced that it too would abandon a peg to the US dollar in favour of a basket of currencies.

Modest

Modest though the immediate Chinese revaluation is, there will be a number of knock-on effects. At home, a stronger renminbi coupled with reduced pressure on US dollar sterilization should help tame the liquidity that has driven the more speculative sectors, including property. China’s halo effect in Asia will also likely dampen inflationary pressures as currencies appreciate against the dollar. Although that could give some cause for concern among exporters, most Asian currencies continue to look like a one-way bet, particularly the Singapore dollar, Japanese yen and Korean won.

One market that is unlikely to benefit from the renminbi revaluation, at least immediately, is the US. An adjustment of 2.1% will not solve the US budget and trade deficits singlehandedly; that will need concerted efforts from Americans themselves who need to stop blaming others for their own excesses and start saving more.  Further appreciation of the yuan is likely, but not the radical one-off adjustments called for by unenlightened US politicians that could actually precipitate the financial crisis they want to avoid. Rather, there will be gradual appreciation at the expense of the dollar, leading to higher US inflation and yields on treasuries.

Journey

No doubt many China analysts will have spent part of their summer vacation guessing when the next revaluation will be and crunching endless permutations of currency weightings within the basket. There is one thing on which all will agree: no-one considers China’s latest exchange rate adjustments, significant though they are, to be anything more than small steps on the journey to a freely convertible currency and an open capital account.

Nirvana

The more euphoric analysts have hailed the latest moves as evidence that this capitalist nirvana for the global economy is on its way soon. That is likely to be wide of the mark.

“The upshot is that this still looks to us that the Chinese are mainly managing the yuan against the US dollar,” writes Adrian Foster, head of foreign exchange strategy at Dresdner Kleinwort Wasserstein. “The reform to date is much more evolutionary than revolutionary.”

China may be lightening its touch on the regulatory tiller but the government remains firmly on course and completely in control.