After pressure from a number of top multinationals around the regulations for listing and de-listing in the US, William Donaldson, chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), has said he would like to see the SEC consider providing relief for foreign private issuers. In a speech given Jan. 25 2005 at the London School of Economics and Political Science in London, UK, Donaldson made three recommendations. The three primary recommendations he made are for SEC to:
consider new approach to allow more flexibility in deregistration process for foreign private issuers.
-
consider adopting a proposal [note: previously issued proposal available here] to allow first time users of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) to reconcile their financial statement to U.S. GAAP for only two years (as opposed to existing 3 year requirement)
consider whether to further delay compliance date of internal control reporting requirements for non-U.S. companies (i.e., SEC requirement for management report on internal control over financial reporting as set forth under Sarbanes-Oxley Section 404)
Excerpts of his speech, provided by the Financial Executives International (FEI) in these three areas are provided below. “First, I expect the SEC to consider whether there should be a new approach to the deregistration process for foreign private issuers if they do not feel prepared to meet the U.S.requirements. … We recognize that issuer circumstances change, and that foreign private issuers should have the flexibility to respond to these changes.”
“Second, the Commission also recognizes the seismic change that conversion to IFRS represents for many European countries. We appreciate the European Union’s efforts in this area because we value the EU’s willingness to require the use of a single set of high quality accounting standards. This approach enhances investor understanding. We also understand that conversion to IFRS, while undoubtedly beneficial in the long run, could be difficult and expensive for some to implement in the immediate term. Consequently, the Commission has proposed amendments to our reporting requirements that would facilitate foreign private issuers’ conversion to IFRS. For those foreign issuers also listed on U.S. exchanges, the SEC has long allowed these companies to use IFRS, provided the financial figures were reconciled to U.S. Generally Accepted Accounting Principles over a three-year period. Within the next few months, I fully expect the Commission will consider adopting a proposal [note: previously issued proposal available here] to allow first-time users of IFRS to reconcile their financial statements to U.S. GAAP for only two years, and I am of the firm view that this would be a step in the right direction. “
“Third, the SEC recently extended the deadline for smaller accelerated filers – issuers in the United Stateswith market capitalization between 75 and $700 million – to come into compliance with SEC rules implementing Section 404 of Sarbanes-Oxley. We pursued this course of action because we understand there are limited resources available to comply with these internal control requirements, which may be disproportionately expensive for companies with fewer resources to devote to compliance and their internal controls.
“Though the Sarbanes-Oxley Act does not provide an exemption for foreign private issuers, we will continue to be sensitive to the need to accommodate unique foreign structures and requirements. Many non-U.S. companies and their auditors are well on their way to completing the processes necessary to report on internal controls. Of all the reforms contained in the Act, getting these processes right is likely to have the greatest long-term impact on enhancing the reliability of financial reporting. However, many companies outside the U.S., especially in Europe, face additional challenges in the near term that go above and beyond those faced by U.S.companies as European companies adopt international financial reporting standards for the first time in 2005.
“To address these burdens, I have asked the staff of the Commission to consider whether to recommend that we delay the effective date of the internal control on financial reporting requirements for non-U.S. companies. We will continue to monitor progress in these areas and we are prepared to reach out and engage in an open dialogue to address concerns regarding reporting on internal controls.?