RBS clinches top spot on China’s new FX trading system

Doubts, though, emerge over portal's sustainability

Li: CFETS will help China
integrate

Royal Bank of Scotland ranks number one on the new China foreign exchange trading system (CFETS) since it went live in May. It can now boast a market share of just below 35% by the number of deals and 40% by volume up to June 17 2005. This is good news for the 10 market-making banks participating in the project, which includes other top FX players such as HSBC, Deutsche Bank, Citibank and ABN Amro. It’s also a sign China’s banking community is gaining much-needed experience in trading currencies other than the renminbi.

CFETS is a subsidiary of Bank of China and is the only organization licensed to trade foreign exchange in China. Membership now exceeds 360 members, of which more than 30 are trading on the system. Historically, domestic banks have been allowed to trade only a handful of renminbi currency pairs but the new portal enables the inter-bank market to trade US dollar against the euro, yen, Hong Kong dollar, sterling, Swiss franc, Australian dollar and Canadian dollar, plus euro against yen. Many in the market have regarded this new portal as a significant turning point in the country’s resolve to reform its tightly controlled currency regime and it fits with the decision late in July to revalue the renminbi.

It’s an entirely new experience for many Chinese banks, and one that has so far received a warm welcome given the strong trading volumes on the platform. In addition to the increase in the number of tickets each day, the transaction sizes have increased from about $100,000 to $500,000 to $1 million. Given that the liquidity of the whole market at a certain rate is limited, a ceiling of $10 million has been imposed on the amount of trading. Trading exceeding this limit can only be made on an RFQ (request for quotation) basis. Nevertheless, the market-making banks have seen tickets in excess of $10 million already.

The liquidity-providing banks offer competitive executable prices on a best bid and best offer basis, with CFETS acting as the counterparty. This is an important feature as it eradicates the need for prime brokers. Instead, CFETS acts as the intermediary by offering full trading, settlement and clearing facilities to FX market participants. This is a good incentive for second- and third-tier banks that might not have had the credit to participate in international currency markets.

Reuters won the deal to develop the system, which was concluded within seven months of the contract being signed. Although the portal isn’t as sophisticated as others in the industry, Charles Li, head of corporate banking and financial markets for China at the Royal Bank of Scotland, is confident that the infrastructure is a sound starting point and will allow for greater flexibility in the future. “This is the first time that CFETS has invited the international banks to work together in developing a specific market infrastructure in China,” he says. “This will help China become a more integrated member of the global foreign exchange community. The fact that Reuters has developed the system will also ensure that the portal will run on international standards.”

Despite the obvious benefits this system might bring to China’s financial institutions and the global banks eager to make inroads into this important emerging market, some analysts are sceptical about its long-term sustainability. “It’s still early days at the moment and no-one can be 100% sure that participants will keep earning a profit,” says a currency analyst at a top US investment bank.

But Kenneth Poon, head of trading, global markets China, at ABN Amro, is still bullish. “The system will work as long as more people participate. I am positive that this will happen,” he says. “The liquidity from this portal should bring greater levels of transparency and efficiency in China, thereby enticing more people into the currency markets. It will also enable FX participants in China to understand how to manage their foreign exchange risk, and therefore how to manage the renminbi, if and when it’s allowed to float.”

CFETS has announced that it plans to explore the possibility of adding other FX-related products to the system, such as forwards and options as well as other Asian currencies.