Brazil: Investors confident despite political scandals

Lula remains favourite for second term

 Lula: under pressure

Most Brazilians are transfixed by their country’s political crises but international investors are rather more sanguine. The majority remain bullish about Brazil’s prospects, despite scandals that have engulfed senior members of the governing Workers Party (PT). Four of president Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva’s closest aides, including Jose Genoino, one of the PT’s founders, have resigned after allegations that they bribed members of congress in return for votes. One party worker was even found with $100,000 in dollar bills stuffed down his underpants. The president has responded by reshuffling his cabinet and appointing three members from the centrist Democratic Movement party, so weakening the PT party’s influence within the governing coalition.

Although none of these scandals directly implicates Lula (at least for the time being), they have emerged at exactly the wrong time for him. Next year there is a presidential election and although Lula remains the favourite to win a second term in office, he might find his mandate is restricted if the allegations continue. That, in turn, could limit his reform agenda.

However, international fund managers, perhaps immune to corruption stories in Latin America, remain unconcerned. Ed Gutierrez, emerging-markets portfolio manager at Deutsche Asset Management in London, says that while the “political noise has lasted longer than expected”, Brazil’s fundamentals are strong.

Ingrid Iversen, portfolio manager at Insight Investment, the asset manager of UK bank group HBOS, says that the scandals have had a limited impact on her strategy. “I haven’t felt the need to sell because of them,” she says, adding that her fund has an overweight position on Brazil’s debt.

Although Brazil’s risk premium widened to 422 basis points over US treasuries on June 9 (from 402bp over at the beginning of June), by early July it was between 385bp and 390bp over.

One dissenting voice is Christian Stracke, analyst at CreditSights. He reckons that Brazil’s external debt “still has plenty of room to weaken”. He says investors might still be caught short, especially if Lula were to become directly implicated in the scandals and if moves were made to impeach him.

“Outright impeachment and conviction of president Lula is still unlikely, but we believe the market consensus may be overconfident about the degree to which these scandals will implicate Lula,” says Stracke.

“Even if no impeachment proceedings are started, Lula will emerge from the scandals a weakened president, and prospects for the structural reform agenda will be eroded.”

Investors hope that Lula, assuming he wins the election scheduled for October 2006, will not make the mistake of his predecessor, Fernando Henrique Cardoso, and waste his second term.

Fiscal reform is seen as being the key challenge. “Overall debt levels and the tax burden are still too high,” says Gutierrez. In addition, he says, further reform of the social security system is needed.