Where investment bankers rule

UBOMIR MINCHEV, EXECUTIVE director of mobile telephone software company Telelink, is one of the new breed of Bulgarian entrepreneurs. Like many of the country's leading politicians and businessmen, Minchev is a former investment banker. He set up Telelink only two years ago and has seen it grow to a point where it employs more than 100 people. Most of them are young and all but a handful have university degrees.

UBOMIR MINCHEV, EXECUTIVE director of mobile telephone software company Telelink, is one of the new breed of Bulgarian entrepreneurs. Like many of the country’s leading politicians and businessmen, Minchev is a former investment banker. He set up Telelink only two years ago and has seen it grow to a point where it employs more than 100 people. Most of them are young and all but a handful have university degrees.

Telelink’s offices are in one of the modern industrial parks outside the capital, Sofia, that are home to the growing number of western information technology and industrial firms that have invested in Bulgaria in the 13 years since the collapse of communism. Already Bulgaria has attracted blue-chip firms ranging from US information technology company Hewlett-Packard to Belgian metal refiner Umicore.

The management and staff in these companies are mostly under 35 years old, well qualified and confident that Bulgaria’s future lies in a western market economy that is a full member of the EU and Nato. “Bulgaria is moving ever closer to having a similar structure to a western economy,” says Minchev.

Business remains one of the strongest backers of the technocratic government of Simeon Saxe-Coburg Gotha, which was swept to power in June 2001, promising a wave of pro-market reforms. In most cases, the government has delivered. Saxe-Coburg Gotha, the former King Simeon, who was driven out by the communists in 1946, has brought robust economic growth, low inflation, booming exports and a solid, conservative fiscal policy. Taxes are among the lowest in Europe and privatization – despite a few recent setbacks – is well advanced. Almost all the banking sector is now in private foreign hands.

Bulgaria, with its low wage costs and highly qualified workforce, has attracted western companies. They have been given extra comfort by the performance of the currency board, which has kept the lev’s value fixed, first against the Deutschmark and then the euro. The country is on course for Nato membership in 2004 and hopes to join the EU in 2007.

A bonfire has been made of many bureaucratic controls, with parliament approving the removal of 74 licensing, permit and registration regimes and simplifying a further 120. A one-stop shop for investors will make life easier for international and local companies.

However, this only tells part of the story. Throughout Sofia there are reminders of both the state’s communist past and the difficult transition from communism to a market economy.

The infrastructure needs massive investment. The roads, even in central Sofia, are poor. The telephone network covers only 30% of the country and most services are still analogue. Although the banking system has made major progress in the past five years, Bulgaria is still predominantly a cash economy and, while many jobs have been created, the headline unemployment figure of more than 14% is still uncomfortably high.

As a result the government gets more appreciation in London’s banking halls than in Sofia’s bars. The financiers who hold many of the senior positions in Saxe-Coburg Gotha’s’s government – this is surely the only administration in the world where analysts can point to different nuances of approach between ministers with an investment and commercial banking background – have a glowing international reputation.

The global financial community, the IMF, the ratings agencies and the EU, which last year said that Bulgaria had a “fully functioning market economy”, believe that the country has adopted the correct economic policies.

Voters prove hard to convince But voters, disillusioned by high unemployment, sharp though necessary increases in the cost of necessities such as electricity and the belief that the election promise to raise living standards in 800 days has not been fulfilled, have been much harder to convince. Within months of last June’s national elections, voters elected as president Georgi Parvanon, a socialist who campaigned for a relaxed fiscal policy and more social spending.

“There is a contrast between the global fixed-income investors, who see the country as a success story, and the local population, which believes it has not seen much benefit. The reason is that although there is 5% growth, this has not been strong enough to bring unemployment down by a significant enough amount,” says Andrew Roberts, emerging-market economy analyst at Citibank.

Local elections this October will show just how unpopular the government has become and what it needs to do if it is to win a second mandate in two years’ time. Western bankers worry that a poor showing could threaten the government’s coalition with its junior partner, the ethnic Turkish party, or that the pace of reform could slacken in the two years before the next national election.

Senior ministers insist that talk of a humiliatingly low vote is overdone. Nikolay Vassilev, deputy prime minister and economy minister, says: “We have not given up on the elections. Remember we are starting from a zero base. We plan to participate very strongly and are focusing on major cities, headed by Sofia and Varna.”

Vassilev, a former emerging-markets’ analyst with Lazard Capital Markets in London, “does not expect any major changes in policy to follow the elections. I am sure that every party will find something in these election results to enable them to claim success.”

Political analysts say that one explanation for the government’s unpopularity is its lack of political experience, which has meant that it has paid too little attention to getting its message across. This naivety has left it ill equipped to counter criticism from the press and the more experienced opposition politicians.

One government adviser accepts that the bout of unpopularity has given ministers a sharp warning that they need to pay as much attention to convincing voters as they do to persuading investors.

Unemployment in Bulgaria
Source: Bulgarian Ministry of economy

Vassilev believes that the government’s fortunes will improve when people become more aware that, “the strong macroeconomic reforms are benefiting them as well. In the past two years, the minimum wage has risen by 30%, the average salary is up 17% and pensions have increased by 20%. This has happened at a time when there is almost no inflation.”

He says he is confident that, “people are starting to realize that we have set the country on the path to joining Nato and the EU and that we have taken steps against corruption and crime. We are a pragmatic government that concentrates on problem-solving.”

Even if the government performs badly in the local elections, a change in strategy is unlikely. Bulgaria’s bankers and business executives remain confident that the government will hold its nerve and continue with reforms for the second half of its term. Significantly the government defeated a recent no-confidence motion in the National Assembly with the support of all its 129 MPs. That level of unity suggests the coalition will hold and resist pressure from the opposition for early national polls.

“The government is unpopular now because it appears too technocratic and has not been political enough. But I think they will hold their nerve and given a bit more time the people will realize that the economy is improving and there is no alternative,” says Rumen Beremski, chairman and chief executive of one of the country’s leading commercial banks, Biochim.

A decisive factor could be the public perception of how high unemployment is at the time of the next election. Many businessmen believe that the government is being unfairly blamed because the statistics are misleading.

Even these official statistics, which have shown a drop from 18% to 14.3% in the past two years, are moving in the right direction. Ministers see this as a vindication of their strategy of labour market reforms, including a form of “workfare” to take people out of the social security net.

But the statistics only tell part of the story. The government and businessmen also believe that the official figures exaggerate the real position. They say there is a substantial grey economy, which accounts for more than a quarter of business activity – as a result real unemployment could be as much as 5% lower than official figures. “You can see the greater prosperity from the traffic congestion, the way people dress and the fact that there are restaurants full of people,” says Beremski. “Besides, it is rather common for companies to under-report revenues for tax purposes. This can easily be seen if one works at a bank.”

Even if this evidence fails to convince the voters, there is little likelihood that even a socialist government could turn back the clock

All parties endorse Nato and EU membership and are committed to maintaining the currency board system. “The changes have gone so far that they are irreversible – there is no way we can return to an unpredictable environment. We have been through transition and need to build on this,” says Sasha Bezuhanova, general manager of Hewlett-Packard Bulgaria.

However, the government’s ability to direct events has been hampered by its late arrival on the political scene – the governing party was formed only months before the 2001 elections. This means that it has had very little influence in other parts of the government process such as the politicized judicial system.

Evidence of this has been apparent in recent controversial decisions by the courts. These will at best delay the sales of the tobacco and telecommunications industries, which the government is under pressure from the IMF to sell as rapidly as possible.

These decisions will not only hold up much needed management modernization and investment but may also make foreign investors feel nervous about the government’s ability to control the process.

Ministers, though, are trying to take more control of institutions and install their supporters in important positions that have until now been held by members of different parties.

A key trial of strength will be over the governorship of the central bank. The government wants to appoint its own candidate even though the current governor, Svetoslav Gavriiski, a finance minister in the Union of Democratic Forces government that preceded the present administration, has said he wishes to stand for a further term. Ministers, while careful to express their respect for his professional expertise, believe he is too close to the previous governing party.

The government has nominated Ivan Iskrov, currently the chairman of the budget and finance permanent committee at the National Assembly. Iskrov, who has worked as a senior executive at the central bank as well as in the commercial banking sector, is also careful to praise Gavriiski’s governorship. But he says that the central bank “needs to be governed in a more transparent way”.

Resolving this issue will call for sensitivity. According to Marco Annunziata, emerging-markets analyst at Deutsche Bank: “There is a risk that the nomination process could be seen as driven by political motivations. While the central bank has very limited policy autonomy in the context of the currency board, upholding its reputation is important in the perspective of accession to the EU and eventually the eurozone.”