Andrew Garner

Chairman and founder, Garner International

Andrew Garner: rates Horby’s
move as his most satisfying job
.

Meet Andrew Garner, founder of blue-chip executive search firm Garner International and secret weapon of HBOS.

When Bank of Scotland lost out to Royal Bank of Scotland for NatWest three years ago, few foresaw that a later merger with Halifax to form HBOS would create one of the most successful UK bank groups.

Commentators focused on a management triumvirate of chief executive James Crosby plus Andy Hornby and Phil Hodkinson, who respectively run HBOS’s retail and insurance and investment businesses. Few people asked how the team came together. That’s where Garner comes in.

In 1994 he recruited Crosby for mortgage bank Halifax. Five years later he brought in Hornby from Asda. Hornby was running the UK supermarket chain’s clothing business at the time. In 2001 Garner recruited Hodkinson into the merged HBOS. Garner has also recruited several key HBOS executives just below board level.

After 20 years in executive search, Garner rates Hornby’s move as his most satisfying job. “To recruit a 31-year-old onto the board of a FTSE plc was fascinating,” he says. “I don’t know whether or not other people missed it, but I saw the need for succession planning within HBOS. Andy had been very well groomed by the likes of [former Asda chairman] Archie Norman and [former chief executive] Allan Leighton. And I saw the consumer financial services side of what was then Halifax as a retail business, so I recruited a retailer.”

It sounds logical in retrospect but those who know the search business say this knack of spotting trans-sector transferable talent sets apart Garner and a few others.

“Andy Hornby has redrawn the behaviour and attitude towards the Halifax brand and the techniques used to promote it,” says Garner. “And he has energized and led a substantial number of people. He has over 50,000 reporting to him now.”

Going it alone Garner pitched to Halifax in 1993 when he was chairman and CEO of Boyden World Corporation, a 40-country, 63-office executive search firm. At the time, many predicted that the sector would consolidate into a few global conglomerates.

Garner thought Boyden could start this by buying rivals. When his colleagues didn’t share his acquisitive ambitions, he set up his own business. In 1997 Garner International was born.

The downturn has denied Garner the chance to grow through acquisition – so far. “The priority of the past three years has been to generate revenue, profits, and cashflow,” he says. “There’ll be a time and a place to contemplate consolidation.”

Significantly, HBOS is Garner’s only retail financial services client. Larger search firms are strongly discouraged from seeking candidates employed by one of their clients for another one. If he only works for HBOS, Garner has no conflict of interest.

“The big search firms have progressively undermined their own competitiveness as a result of their conflicts of interest,” says Garner. “That’s beginning to show itself more clearly.”

The lack of conflicts also gives him a different perspective on what talented executives are available in retail financial services. If you can’t search out of your own client base, you are more likely to complain of a shortage.

“I can look at the entire competitive landscape,” says Garner. “If I was denied the opportunity to look at Barclays or ANZ, I’d be saying there’s a dearth of talent.”

Garner International has a core of five consultants in London searching across several sectors. Aim-listed, it was profitable in the second half of 2002 and the first half of 2003. And now it has launched an investment banking practice.

The high-octane, male-dominated, multi-decibel world of motorsport may or may not resemble investment banking. But if Garner can do for any banks what it did for one motor-racing outfit, you’ll be hearing more about the firm. Its first invoice was to former world champion driver Jackie Stewart.

Garner knew Stewart through car racing, his hobby (he races a Formula One Cooper-Climax and a Lister Jaguar, both from 1959). Stewart was looking for sponsors for his Stewart Grand Prix team, which he later sold to Ford. Garner persuaded ACC Telecom to become the team’s headline sponsor.

“The track where I’ve had most success is Imola,” Garner says. “When I first went there I drove like an idiot. Since then I’ve found the rhythm.”