Renovation of a pariah

Five years after Russia defaulted on its sovereign debt, burning foreign investors, the government is poised to return to international capital markets next year with $2.76 billion of Eurobond issues. Thanks to the country's revival, investors are salivating at the prospect of fresh Russian paper.

Five years after Russia defaulted on its sovereign debt, burning foreign investors, the government is poised to return to international capital markets next year with $2.76 billion of Eurobond issues. Thanks to the country’s revival, investors are salivating at the prospect of fresh Russian paper.

The finance ministry submitted the draft 2004 budget at the end of July. It included a provision for Eurobond issues, which look more likely to be issued thanks to a change in the way Russia handles its windfall oil revenues. Until now the ministry has been using the excess earnings to pay down foreign debt, but from next year this money will go into a fund that will be used to cushion any unexpected economic blows to the economy, such as low international oil prices.

Both foreign and Russian investors would welcome the appearance of fresh Russian sovereign bonds. Russia’s investment reputation, cut to shreds by the 1998 financial crisis, has now all but recovered.

Ratings agencies have upgraded the country repeatedly since 1998. As the economy enters its fifth straight year of solid growth, it is now just below the sought-after investment grades. Fitch rates Russia just one notch below these grades and both Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s could upgrade the country to one notch below investment grade before the end of the year, analysts say.

The last round of upgrades is being held up by the slow pace of banking reform, but most Russia-watchers are expecting an investment-grade rating to come shortly after the presidential elections next March.

Since the end of last year investors have been snapping up Russian bonds as nearly every major Russian company tapped the market for investment capital.

Growing supply

There is a growing supply of Russian corporate Eurobonds but the supply of sovereign bonds is dwindling. Russia has about $20 billion in sovereign Eurobonds outstanding, but only the longest, the Russia-30s that mature in 2030, enjoy any real liquidity on the secondary market.

“Russia is paying out about $3.5 billion a year in coupons [on sovereign Eurobonds]. The money goes out and investors would put it back in again as they are very happy with the returns,” says Al Breach, senior economist at Brunswick UBS. “But there is no new paper to buy and all they can do is bid up the existing bonds.”

Yields have fallen steadily and are currently around 8% on the longer bonds, which puts Russia on a par with such countries as Mexico that have already enjoyed investment-grade status for several years. But the finance ministry hopes that the new

enthusiasm for Russian debt will bring yields down closer to 6% to 6.5% on the 30-year bonds.

It is still not clear if the ministry will make use of the provision for Eurobond issues. The 2002 and 2003 budgets also included provisions of $2 billion and $1.25 billion respectively, but neither was taken up as the budget has been in surplus since March 2000 thanks to sustained high oil prices.

Over the last few years the finance
ministry has been able to dip into a strategic reserve fund in which excess oil revenues have been deposited. It has been using this money to meet external debt payments – in 2003 there was a $17.3 billion debt spike as payments due in 1998 were delayed by five years in the wake of the financial crisis – and even paid off some debt early. Russia’s external debt is now 36% of GDP, down from over 80% in the mid-1990s.

However, at the beginning of next year the strategic reserve will be turned into the more permanent stabilization fund. Regulations will prevent the ministry from touching this fund unless there is a nasty economic downturn – in effect the fund will used to top up the budget if international oil prices fall below about $18 a barrel.

Cut off from the pool of about $6 billion in the strategic reserve fund at the start of this year, the ministry could issue some or all of the Eurobond allocation to balance the budget; the 2004 budget assumes oil prices at a conservative $20 a barrel.

Oil revenue is key

“How much they issue depends on next year’s revenues,” says Breach at Brunswick UBS. “If oil stays over $22 then the government won’t need to borrow externally, but under $20 then it could, but will start by tapping the domestic market first.”

The finance ministry has been paying down debt, but it also wants to shift more of the debt into the form of domestic borrowing and so cut foreign exchange risks. Currently about 85% of Russia’s debt is external. The ministry says it would prefer a 50-50 split between borrowing overseas and from domestic investors within a few years’ time.

The draft budget calls for $3 billion in external borrowing and another $5 billion of domestic issues, all of which will be used to refinance the existing external debt.

The need to issue more Eurobonds has been confused by bickering over setting up the stabilization fund. The first problem is that no one is sure how much is in it.

“At the moment the strategic reserve is just a pocket in the central bank where the government keeps all this money,” says Peter Westin, economist with Aton. “No-one has said in detail how it will function and it is not even clear how much money there is in the fund.”

At the start of this year the fund had $6.2 billion but despite stronger-than-expected oil prices, according to official statements it still has roughly the same amount. Estimates vary between around $6 billion and $8 billion.

“There is a lot of confusion over how much money is in the fund. If the government had paid in all extra oil revenues it had received there should be another $5 billion to $6 billion in the fund. It is a missed opportunity and probably due to the up-coming elections,” Westin says.

After many delays the stabilization fund should be created after the March presidential elections. In an outline submitted to the government in June, the finance ministry said windfall oil revenues over $20 a barrel should be paid to the fund, which it hopes will reach $15 billion within three years.

If it can, the ministry will avoid issuing new bonds. The new budget will aim to keep a tight lid on spending to create more leeway for the tax cuts that have underpinned Russia’s strong growth. In his May state of the nation speech, president Vladimir Putin set the economy the goal of doubling GDP by 2010 – a 7.2% annual rate of growth.

Finance minister Alexei Kudrin says that spending caps will remain in place for three years. Primary budget spending (which excludes state debt servicing costs) in 2004 will be 12.3% of GDP, falling to 11.5% and 11.2% in 2005 and 2006 respectively.

“That would allow us to give a tax breather to industry so that after several years we would achieve considerable growth in GDP and new possibilities for budget financing,” says Kudrin.