Fund managers look to alternatives

With trading costs bearing down on them, UK fund managers are tentatively exploring the savings offered by alternative trading venues.

THE NEXT FEW months will be an exciting time for European alternative trading venues. With a March deadline looming, UK fund managers and brokers will be examining these systems more closely as they work hard to show progress in implementing recommendations on transaction costs made in the Myners Report.

Among other things, the 2001 report of Paul Myners’ review of institutional investment for the UK government enjoins fund trustees to call their fund managers to account for their choices of trading methods and venues. The choice of alternative trading venues is expanding and differentiating between them and deciding when and how to use the different strategies they offer is a challenge for managers.

The proportion of trading conducted over alternative venues in Europe is still small but it will undoubtedly grow as the Myners recommendations force investors and brokers to focus more closely on transaction costs related to market impact rather than commissions.

Liquidnet, which launched in Europe at the end of November 2002, is the newest alternative venue available for European equities trading. The company, which first launched in the US in April 2001, operates an innovative order-matching system that exclusively serves buy-side institutions. Liquidnet connects directly to the order management systems of buy-side firms and continuously scans for potential matches between clients. Users can choose to make their orders invisible to hedge funds if they wish and also to any other user whose order does not fill a minimum amount. When a potential match is found, a pop-up notice appears on the user’s screen. He or she can then either choose to accept the price, negotiate further with complete anonymity or decline to deal.

E-Crossnet, launched in 2000, is an all-electronic pan-European crossing network that works in a similar way to Posit, the oldest and best-established crossing network, with the exception that, like Liquidnet, it is a buy-side-only system. As in Posit, traders choose to send in firm orders anonymously to be crossed at the mid-point price at fixed times throughout the trading day.

Posit is part of institutional investor trading services provider ITG, which can act as an electronic agency broker on any uncompleted trades if desired. Posit takes orders electronically, but also by phone or fax, and is open to both buy-side and sell-side institutions. This sets it apart from buy-side-only Liquidnet and E-Crossnet, giving it a wider pool of users. This is both an advantage and, some in the market would argue, a disadvantage.

Deep-rooted mistrust Until recently, fund managers had no choice but to deal with brokers, which act as intermediaries. The brokers work their orders and sometimes throw in some of their own capital to help execution. This system works well enough but many fund managers see real advantages in trading directly with each other.

Brokers work on behalf of many clients, so fund managers can never be sure that their own particular interests are being prioritized. Non-agency-only brokers also have their own interests that may conflict with those of a client and the information that brokers have about their clients means that there is always the possibility this will be used against them.

Mistrust of brokers runs surprisingly deep among some of their clients, hence the attraction of dealing directly with the like-minded. “When it’s all buy-side institutions, you know you’re dealing with people who are doing transactions for the long term, not just to make a quick buck,” says the head of trading at a global asset management firm. “You have more trust in doing transactions with people of similar motives.”

The three alternative trading venues are all designed to reduce market-impact-related transaction costs to help users achieve best execution. They are competing for much of the same order flow. But their differences theoretically give them slightly different strengths that suit them to different types of orders or investor profiles.

Liquidnet is only available to buy-side institutions that have order management systems, a small but increasing proportion. The beauty of Liquidnet is that traders automatically see opportunities as they become available and that the system can be used any time throughout the day. The way it works suits it for trades in single names but means it is not that helpful for programme trading.

E-Crossnet is available to any fund manager with a Bloomberg terminal, and is suitable for single-name and programme trades for those who would prefer to trade directly with only buy-side firms when possible.

Instinet, the electronic agency broker, also runs a popular nightly crossing service.

Investors’ use of these alternatives varies according to the particular structures of their trades. For block and programme trades, investors could benefit from using the crossing networks and Liquidnet as a first point of call and only then submitting the rest of the order to brokers or executing it through direct market access systems. Indeed some investment managers, including Legal&General, say that crossing first is a core part of their strategy for both index-tracking and active management activities.

E-Crossnet claims that it is the first point of call for between 7% and 22% of monthly share volumes in the UK, though not necessarily the venue on which they are finally executed.

The alternative venues are also particularly useful for reducing the market-impact costs of trades in less liquid stocks. Some 79% of the volume of UK stocks submitted on Posit is non-FTSE 100 names.

In practice, however, fund managers still find the matching rates on the crossing networks and Liquidnet disappointing. But these will increase as more order flow is directed their way. Indeed it is hard to find a head of trading at a buy-side institution who does not intend to increase use of alternative venues. “We are using and will continue to increase our use of crossing networks,” says Gunner Burkhart, head of trading at Deutsche Asset Management. “There is significant performance uplift to be had when successful but match rates have historically been very low.”

If getting a trade done fast is a priority, dealing exclusively with other buy-side institutions becomes a luxury. Traditional brokers, committing capital, are a better bet. But for many investors the time taken to complete a trade is secondary to achieving the best price with minimum market impact. In these situations, a strategy might emerge of sending orders for crossing sequentially to E-Crossnet, then to Posit, and of continuing to use Liquidnet as and when matches arise.

At the moment buy-side traders still use the alternative trading venues only in a peripheral way. For highly liquid large-cap stocks, for example, the market impact of trades is less pronounced, and traders tend to take the attitude that it is not worth the effort of sending order flow on them to alternative trading venues.

But if buy-side firms increasingly trade directly between themselves, brokers become less important and will have to be able to demonstrate more clearly what it is they do that adds value.

Some brokers are working hard at this. Instinet has just rolled out a sophisticated new portfolio trading and execution management system called Newport. Morgan Stanley has also developed a powerful electronic trading system, TradeXL. What these systems do, apart from providing direct market access, is allow clients to see exactly how the trade is being executed in real time and to enable them to communicate or intervene.

Meanwhile, the ability of investment managers to justify trading decisions systematically and exploit alternative venues is held back by a lack of technology to analyze transaction costs and broker performance and the limited use of order management systems.

In the UK the proportion of investment managers with order management systems is less than 50%. The proportion with transaction cost analysis software is about 20%. It will take investment up-front to cut regular trading costs.

Transaction costs (basis points) and savings from crossing
Country Commission Market impact Total Savings from
    and spread   crossing (%)
France 21 60 81 88
Germany 20 75 95 89
Italy 20 54 74 86
Netherlands 20 51 71 86
Sweden 20 68 88 89
Switzerland 19 51 70 86
UK 14 78 92 89
 Source: Myners Report