E-cash spreads its tentacles

Asia's currencies may be worth less than they were, but in two Asian city states a new currency is on the rise - the electronic variety. As Steven Irvine reports, central bankers want to encourage e-cash but they are nervous about its implications.

Mrs Chen probably doesn’t realize the significance of her new Octopus card. She leaves it in her handbag and holds it by the turnstile. She passes through, and it deducts the fare. She catches her train and thinks nothing more about it.

However, Mrs Chen and the four million other Hong Kongers who hold Octopus cards are part of a monetary revolution. The Octopus system has created HK$4 billion ($516 million) of electronic money in an economy with about HK$100 billion of notes and coins in circulation.

Something similar is happening in Singapore. As motorists drive through the city at peak times, a charge is automatically deducted from a removable smart card installed in their cars. To enter central Singapore they need to charge the cards, which can also be used to make purchases in shops, with electronic money.

In these two city states, a critical mass of people is being drawn into the web of electronic money – or e-money as it is sometimes called. The implications of this trend have not been lost on bankers. In Hong Kong, Octopus is run by a company called Creative Star, which is a joint venture between various transport companies, notably the Mass Transit Railway (MTR) which owns 67%.

MTR is not a bank – yet. For the moment it is a state-owned operator of underground trains. But as the principal backer of Octopus it could rapidly become an issuer of electronic notes and over time displace paper-based note issuers such as HongkongBank and Bank of China.

This process is in its early stages. The Octopus card is, for the moment, somewhat restricted in its application. It is mainly used on trains and buses, but it has already begun to broaden its reach. For example, the new touchscreen telephones inside MTR stations use only Octopus. Just hold the card next to the telephone and make your call.

Inside MTR’s stations, cake shops, delicatessens and newsagents will soon take the card, and no-one is predicting it will suffer for lack of use.

Quite the contrary. Octopus is one of the most user-friendly financial inventions of recent times. The technology, developed by Sony, is effortlessly simple. Unlike conventional cards, it requires no swiping and no waiting. The user simply holds the card near a small yellow Octopus sensor for a fraction of a second and the purse is deducted. Most people leave it in their wallets or handbags and forget it’s even there.

The card is so popular in fact that since its launch last September, two-thirds of Hong Kong’s population has bought one. And feedback shows Hong Kongers want to use it more. “What’s the difference between using Octopus to pay for a telephone call in our station, and walking out of our station and using it in a telephone 10 yards away?” asks Brian Chambers, who works for MTR and also acts as general manager of Octopus’s operating company. “Some users have already asked why this is not possible. However, if we wanted to allow Octopus to be used for this purpose we would have to get the permission of the monetary authorities.”

Why? Octopus has special permission from the banking regulators to issue currency in this way – in part because the Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA) is keen to be at the forefront of encouraging this new form of money. However, its exemption only goes so far. It expires if over 15% of its transaction values come from non-core areas – that is, anything outside transport, such as making a telephone call or hiring a film in a video store.

“Our card is exempt from the banking ordinance,” says Chambers, “But as we do broaden its application it is possible we will have to change our status, and we’d be quite happy to do so.” He adds: “We are in active discussions with the monetary authorities at the moment on how we expand. Our focus is on what we have to do to get the card to a wider audience.”

This will mean more stringent reporting. In a policy intiative, the HKMA already stresses that an electronic money operator “must satisfy the monetary authority that it has adequate risk-management policies for the management of the float to ensure that there are sufficient funds for the redemption”.

Octopus’s float is around HK$4 billion. Contained in the float are the actual Hong Kong dollars backing the electronic currency Octopus has in effect created. As the float gets bigger and bigger, Octopus (for which, read MTR) will become one of the biggest liquidity providers in the Hong Kong money market, and will also earn large sums of interest on this money.

Controlling the money supply is a very profitable business and it’s usually the central bank that benefits from it. The HKMA is keen to promote the growth of e-money, and so is fairly relaxed about this erosion of its income stream – for the moment. “We might review our position when e-money is a clear substitute for money,” smiles Raymond Li, the executive director of the banking policy department.

Octopus is already throwing up some interesting philosophical debates. Foremost among them, what constitutes a bank deposit? The Octopus card can be loaded with up to HK$1,000 of non-interest-bearing Hong Kong dollars. Is this a deposit? Or is it a prepayment for goods and services – similar to a rechargeable telephone card. Is an Octopus card covered by deposit insurance, or would bankruptcy for Octopus result in six million Hong Kongers simultaneously losing their wallets? Will MTR be the first train operator in the world with a capital-adequacy requirement?

Load ’em up

Octopus already has a critical mass of users – by dint of the 2.3 million people that use the MTR every day. Over half a billion transactions have been done already, and HK$17 million of e-money goes through the system every day. The one chink in its armour is loading the card with cash.

It is here that one of its rivals, Mondex, has the edge. The competing system is operated by dominant financial institution HongkongBank so it has a lot of marketing effort behind it. But Mondex is less user-friendly than Octopus. It needs to be inserted into a reader machine, it takes a good deal longer and apart from there being no need to provide a signature, it feels a lot like a credit-card transaction. For small payments, Octopus is easier. But Mondex can be loaded with cash at HongkongBank ATMs and money can be transferred to it from the holder’s bank account. In this sense, Mondex is closest to eliminating paper from the monetary process. Your employer pays direct into your bank account. You transfer cash from the account to the Mondex card. You spend. Who needs hard cash?

Octopus cannot be used on ATMs and money has to be loaded inside MTR stations. It would dearly love to have access to Hong Kong’s ATMs so the card could be replenished in a more user-friendly fashion. “It’s not a technical issue,” says Chambers. “We could put an Octopus reader in the ATMs.”

The snag is that HongkongBank – with its subsidiary, Hang Seng Bank – runs a large proportion of the territory’s ATMs. Why would it give up its competitive advantage? For the moment, HongkongBank is laughing off the threat. One official at the bank jests that if MTR continues to try to encroach on the bank’s territory then maybe HongkongBank will build a railway line to the new airport at Chep Lap Kok, in competition with the MTR line just finished.

However, Mondex is severely handicapped in its battle. It faces an uphill struggle to gain the momentum that Octopus has achieved since its launch in September. And without critical mass, such systems as Mondex and VisaCash don’t catch on with retailers. And if you can’t use the card, no-one applies to get one. It’s a vicious circle.

HongkongBank is enlisting shops all the time. It has 6,000 retailers on board and has even given a Mondex handset to the newspaper lady outside the bank’s headquarters. But many of the places where you see a Mondex sticker are hardly ripe for building critical mass. A jeweller in Times Square for example. This makes little sense: jewellery purchases are usually made with credit or debit cards not cash.

HSBC’s head of cards, Geoff Bruce, concedes that critical mass is an issue. “It’s an evolution,” he says. “For example, supermarket point-of-sale devices are linked to their own back offices and they have their own schedules for changing them. They don’t want to junk perfectly good systems ahead of time. It’s costly.”

Mondex stresses that it is not just a Hong Kong system but a global one. London-based chief executive Michael Keegan points out that some of the biggest banks in the world create electronic money on behalf of Mondex. Institutions including Chase, Wells Fargo, NatWest and HongkongBank act as so-called originating banks. They are the creators of the electronic money and its clearer. They hold equal amounts of the electronic currency they are creating in physical currency.

Keegan is particularly proud of the new Multos operating system that will be launched later this year. It is an open platform: for £100 ($164) any software developer can program on it. “It will mean anyone can put an application on Mondex,” he says. Applications could include MasterCard credit card, airline loyalty systems or ID cards. With a flourish, Keegan opens his wallet and reveals about 20 plastic cards. “All these could go on one Mondex card,” he says. “This is right on the cusp.”

Chambers of Octopus says this not unique. The same principle applies to its card, which acts as his MTR staff identity card and security pass. But Mondex does have the edge in one way. It is international, and it is multi-currency. Keegan cites the example of MasterCard’s chief executive who has used his Mondex card at the airport in Hong Kong then caught a flight to New York where he has used the same card to buy an item in US dollars at JFK.

But this is one of the things that most worries the Hong Kong central bank. Li of the HKMA smiles at the mention of Mondex’s cross-border flexibility. “Yes, that was a trial,” he says. “We would not like an originator in the Cayman Islands to originate Hong Kong dollars, for example.”

For Hong Kong this is a particularly sensitive issue because of the currency-board system which backs every dollar in circulation with a fixed number of US dollars. An originator outside Hong Kong might undermine the integrity of the peg.

The US Federal Reserve is also concerned. In its case, it worries about handing control of the money supply to banks. That seems like turning the clock back to the days of the original bankers – goldsmiths – who issued their own notes against the gold they held. Central bankers recall just how prone these goldsmiths were to bankruptcy. What happens if the creators of electronic US dollars go bust in a derivatives transaction?

But the US authorities believe that there is too much to be gained from e-money to regulate too much just yet. There are many applications that e-money and smart cards open up. Internet purchases, for example, and set-top television purchases.

The approach of Asia’s two city states to e-money, as to much else, is markedly different. Hong Kong is happy to allow competing platforms such as Octopus, Mondex and e-park (for parking meters) to battle it out in a free market. Singapore, true to form, has taken a highly centralized approach and opted for one platform. Its traffic smart card is compatible with the big banks’ CashCard, launched in late 1996. In effect, this marries the critical mass of Octopus with the ATM benefits of Mondex. But like Mondex, the CashCard is more time-consuming than Octopus and has to be inserted into a handset.

Singapore’s coordinated model may seem more likely than Hong Kong’s to encourage its citizens to embrace e-cash. But as the HKMA’s Li puts it: “If you don’t allow competition, how do you know you’re getting the best, most innovative system?”