The country that fostered Buddha was also one of the few in Asia that didn’t succumb to the fashion for convertibility. India was a cautious reformer and has escaped a mauling. Its economy will register not just positive but decent growth this year. Long labelled a laggard of reform, India now finds its moderate approach held up as a model for the opinion-formers in Washington as they scratch around for a new economic paradigm to replace the now-discredited pseudo-capitalism of the Asian economies.
With this in mind Euromoney decided on a re-examination of India. Taking in several cities – including the financial capital, the political capital and even a day in the spiritual capital – we met 50 of the most obviously influential people in India, and some less obviously so. Doors were opened by our travelling companion, Ajeya Singh, head of Lehman Brothers in India.
What emerges is a yearning for an economic third way somewhere between laissez-faire capitalism and the planned economy. This manifests itself in opposition to most Anglo-Saxon notions of sensible economic management rather than looking for workable alternatives. India’s elite put independence first, sound policies second. They see clearly the mistakes made in Asia and elsewhere in the emerging markets but are less willing to square up to the shortcomings in their own system. Luck, it seems, as much as judgement is at the root of India’s present success. It has avoided disaster despite its aversion to free market policies. Many of the elite’s criticisms of the free market – particularly its effect on the poor – seem strangely at odds with the reality on their own doorstep: poverty, and its passive acceptance by the country’s under-privileged majority. Steven Irvine reports
When we arrived in Delhi – at the end of October – the world was a turbulent place. Capital markets were closed to half the world, banks were haemorrhaging money and jobs and the Fed was bailing out the Rolls Royce of hedge funds (Long-Term Capital Management). In the midst of this global chaos, India too had a serious problem. There was a shortage of onions.
“The rest of the world is in meltdown and India doesn’t have enough onions,” smiles Ajeya Singh as we meet. “I know which problem I’d rather have.” Singh is 41 and a lifelong investment banker whose career spans Citibank, Merrill Lynch, Bear Stearns and, now, Lehman. He is the son of India’s most well known maharaja, a man who was India’s prime minister for a mere 11 months at the beginning of the decade but who fundamentally changed the politics of India. Vishwanath Pratap Singh’s National Front government offered “a political alternative to end the Congress [party] monopoly”. He is respected by most, hated by some, loved by others.
We go in Singh’s car to the Disinvestment (read privatization) Commission. The car is a white Hindustan Motors Birla Ambassador – one of those old British-designed vehicles that make a Volvo look like a go-cart. Singh’s car also has the advantage over its Swedish counterpart that it is bombproof.
As the son of a former prime minister he is guarded 24 hours a day by an elite force called the Special Protection Group. They wear plain clothes – or rather 1970s clothes – guard the door of his hotel room, have ruined his garden with gun positions and are allowed to take concealed weapons on planes. They spend almost as much time on their walkie-talkies as Singh spends on his mobile phone.
“I can’t go anywhere in India without these guys,” says Singh ruefully. “This dates back to the assassination of Rajiv Gandhi. My father hates it. He brought a court case trying to prevent them guarding us. He lost.”
The red light goes off outside GV Ramakrishna’s office. The green light signals that we have the go-ahead to meet the head of the Disinvestment Commission. After the appropriate five minutes spent discussing the health of Singh’s father – a recurring feature of every subsequent meeting – the wiry Ramakrishna turns his attention to the matter in hand.
“The world is moving very fast,” he says with a wave of his hand, “We were the object of ridicule till June 1997. They were called Asian tigers. We were called slow moving elephants. Here in India today the argument is over 5% or 6% growth. Our industry thinks there is a great recession. They don’t understand what a recession is: negative growth for two consecutive quarters. We have never had it for the last 20 years.”
Singh recalls that he took Lehman’s global rainmaker Theodore Roosevelt and credit analyst Stephen Taran (now at Salomon Smith Barney) to see Bimal Jalan the day before he was made central bank governor last year. “We were trying to persuade the government to do a sovereign bond. As we were in the meeting news came over about Thailand. Jalan looked over at Roosevelt and said ‘Now do you see why it is good to have controls?'”
“Total laissez faire in financial movements is not good for any country,” says Ramakrishna. “These foreign banks. Did they do due diligence before lending? Did they try and find out what purpose there was for the money? There were no checks and balances to see money was going to the right places for the right purpose. That’s why it is imprudent lending.”
The thing is, he says, institutions need to be in place for capitalism to function: a critical press, accountancy, a judicial system. “Even the Americans had their robber barons in the 19th century. Then they grew out of it and established institutions, checks and balances.”
But isn’t this export of Anglo-Saxon institutions rather imperialistic? “No,” he says. “It’s a benign form of imperialism. There is no choice.”
How should privatization be done? In this respect he’s not so keen on benign foreign ideas. “The foreign investment banks, I’m sorry to say, tell the finance ministry to use the GDR [global depositary receipts] market. What do you achieve? The company remains in the public sector with all its handicaps. They sell 10% and pocket the money for the budget. It doesn’t help the public.
“I want to link disinvestment to development. Put this money in a fund and use it for social services. Transfer one asset to another: human capital. For 1,000 crores ($236 million – a crore is Rp10 million) you can build 400,000 houses, 100,000 schools.”
For bigger companies, he proposes putting the companies into arms length trust funds, bringing in professional managers, and severing all ties to the relevant ministry in the decision making process. Once the company has been restructured then sell it a few years down the line. He has also recommended the strategic sale method for 25 out of the 35 companies he has selected for privatization.
“These companies need new capital to modernize and new management. They are languishing but will thrive again. With the strategic sale route you have 20 or 30 potential investors going round Delhi competing to invest. For 10 sales you’ll have 40 financial advisers. Think of the sentiment it will generate about the interest of the international community in investing in India.”
As we leave the Disinvestment Commission we get caught in traffic. Ramakrishna’s building is next to the passport and visa office. Cars are strewn across the road as those that can afford to travel send their boys to run in and get their visas. The Special Protection Group guys sit motionless ready for an assault. Singh calls a rival at another bank to get the gossip on the VSNL deal.
The mandate to sell $200 million of GDRs in Videsh Sanchar Nigam (VSNL), the state telephone company, has been out for six months. On October 21 the 23 interested investment banks made their presentations. Singh is not impressed with the process so far. “How can they mandate this thing when they don’t even have a chairman,” he points out to the rival. He listens to the answer. “They’ve selected a chairman. A good guy. But it’s sitting in the prime minister’s office waiting approval. Crazy. So what are you hearing?” A pause as Singh digests the info. “Yes, me too. I think they’ve got it in the bag.”
We drive to North Block, where the ministry of finance is housed in the florid mix of western neo-classical and eastern domes which its designer Sir Edwin Lutyens described as “an Englishman dressed for the climate”. We are scheduled to see Mohan Guruswamy, the adviser to the minister of finance.
We are kept waiting. A multinational and its Indian partner are with Guruswamy. Singh points to a contraption by the balcony. “This is a sonar device. It’s to stop the monkeys getting in here at night.” It doesn’t work. Sleeping on a ledge above room B136 – less than 15 metres from the minister of finance’s palatial room – is a very contented monkey.
We are taken into Guruswamy’s office and sit on a sofa while he continues talking to another visitor. We’re half an hour behind schedule. Guruswamy is very tall, very relaxed. Someone else comes in and is told to come back at 2.30.
We finally make it from the sofa to the desk. Singh asks if we can we do this over breakfast tomorrow. “You don’t have enough time now,” he points out. We agree to meet at the Belvedere club the next morning. The occupant of the sofa moves into pole position in front of the desk.
Our next meeting is with the chairman of a state-owned bank. This too is a disjointed affair because a government bureaucrat walks into the office after five minutes and points his finger at another room. The bank chairman saunters after him into an antechamber where they spend the next 15 minutes. Singh points out this is not very “usual”. If it was “official” business the bureaucrat would have summoned the chairman to the ministry.
As the bureaucrat comes out he looks a little sheepish, only subsequently discovering who Singh is. Singh’s father is well known for his efforts to defeat institutional corruption. As finance minister he started the so-called raid raj to bust tax evaders.
On one occasion he wanted to get rid of corrupt tax inspectors, but this being India he couldn’t fire them. So he created a training course for bad income-tax officials in Nagpur where they were transferred out of harm’s way.
We travel along the ring road. A cow is lying in the fast lane. Next stop Montek Ahluwalia, the secretary at the Planning Commission. He has just written a paper on India’s reforms for a new book to be edited by Harvard professor Jeffrey Sachs. His office is rather bare, except for books.
“In India we have been congratulating ourselves on our cautious approach to capital account convertibility,” the paper says. “This traditionally cautious approach was reinforced by the committee on capital account convertibility which recommended that we should not go for full capital account convertibility until certain preconditions are satisfied.”
“The emerging consensus on the financial architecture focuses on the need for greater transparency, improved prudential norms, and better supervision. This is undoubtedly important, and moving in this direction would improve the financial system. However we should not exaggerate the impact of transparency and better prudential norms. Even with an improvement in these we have to face the fact that there may be inherent instability in the international financial system.”
Ahluwalia admits that India’s present position is the result of luck and questions the current vogue for an international lender of last resort: “This is an attractive idea and on the face of it provides a solution to possible panics. In practice, however there are real difficulties. Internationally however few countries would be willing to accept continuous supervision of their banking system by a potential international lender of last resort.”
As a colleague puts it: “Would Indians be happy with an international institution that says, ‘Look, your banking system is under some stress; these banks should be shut down. If you follow this advice some people in certain Indian cities will be very upset, but the banking system will come out much healthier.’ No. As long as we don’t have a crisis, people in India would say: ‘Who do these guys think they are?’
Kedgeree culture
There is no shortage of onions at the Belvedere where, as promised, we have breakfast with Guruswamy. Singh orders kedgeree – which he describes as typical Indian peasant food – but is told that the Belvedere’s chef doesn’t know how to make it. “You see how we are losing our culture, Mohan,” he tells the man from the ministry of finance.
Dilution of culture is something Guruswamy takes seriously. He is regarded as a swadeshi intellectual. The term swadeshi means literally self reliance but has overtones of xenophobia. However Guruswamy also spent time at Harvard.
He does not oppose foreign investment, but he has misgivings about the way in which it has been attracted in the past. “The importance of foreign direct investment is highly exaggerated. Foreign capital is not even 5% of our total capital deployed every year. So the role which you [foreigners] assume for yourselves of transforming this country is not there. And when you come you should come like anyone else. You can demand speedy clearances, stable power supply, but you can’t demand special concessions just for yourself.”
What about the comparison with China and its success in attracting investment? “Most of that is overseas Chinese. Multinationals are a small fraction compared with Taiwan and the Hong Kong Chinese. So we can’t benchmark with China that way. We don’t have this huge overseas Indian population. And ours are mostly professionals.
“Indians living in India have more wealth abroad than Indians living abroad. This is the big challenge – to get this money back. Indian holdings outside India are somewhere in the order of $300 billion. The Indians are big players when they go to Zurich.”
The offshore money rankles and not just because it is unpatriotic. Says Singh: “Under the auspices of doing normal banking you have guys sitting in India doing just that kind of [Swiss] personal banking.” Personal banking – that is offering offshore private accounts – is illegal. Guruswamy says without pause: “Since I took over this office, I have been offered the services of such individuals who say: ‘You must have money now [that you are a senior politician]’.”
They assume he is receiving bribes? “Absolutely. Not a day passes when I’m not offered a bribe. In the beginning I used to get upset. Now I just laugh it off. Yesterday morning I started the day with an offer of 50 lakhs ($110,000 – a lakh is 100,000 rupees) now and 50 lakhs later for a job to be done.”
Investment bankers too will find little respect at the ministry. “With all due respect to Ajeya, I am an old-fashioned industry man. I like to see things produced and fashioned out. I can’t understand what these guys do for a living. I see them all in five-star hotels. They’re all talking a language we don’t understand, and they have managed to convince many people that their wellbeing is somehow connected to the wellbeing of economies and societies as a whole. I don’t necessarily accept that. I know they have to hustle for a living.
“I had one investment banker come to see me the other day and he said things are bad; economy is bad. When are you coming with public-sector disinvestment. So I said: ‘What happened? Did you lose your half a million bonus last year?’ So he said: ‘Yeah, yeah. I took a big hit. I got only $200,000 last year. So you must come with some privatizations.’
Guruswamy continues: “I introduced the guy to a couple of people on the committee that will decide the [VSNL] mandate. I said: ‘Meet so and so’. But I have to restrain myself. I can easily say give it to him. And it will be done. They’d come back and say ‘Mr Guruswamy, it is done’ and then it would filter out and no-one would believe that I did it for nothing. It’s very tricky. In India we’re expected to help our friends. If you don’t help your friends and kinsmen who are you going to help? Our ring of loyalties starts at the core and keeps expanding. Country comes last.”
Our next stop is the office of Arvind Pande, chairman of Steel Authority of India (Sail) no stranger to the international capital markets with several issues in circulation.
Sail has a problem common to most traditional state-owned enterprises. It has far more staff than it needs. “The problem is what to do with the people,” Pande says: “I can’t just close the plants and put people on the road.” Sail employs 180,000 staff to make 10 million tonnes of steel. A modern plant makes two million tonnes with 1,500. Pande speaks of the need to “right-size” but worries: “We have examples of steel mills where steel is the only business in the town. For miles around there is nothing.”
Tariff protection on steel has fallen from 180% to 30% in seven years. Worse, the drop in Asian demand for steel – from 26 million tonnes annually to 4 million – has caused a glut and prices have collapsed to around $220 a tonne. It costs Sail $270 a tonne to make it. Imports are flooding in. Then there’s the debt problem. Sail’s debt-to-equity ratio is 2.3 to 1 but he wants to get it back to 1 to 1.
“We had no choice but to liberalize,” says Pande. “But we have to be very clear. Today I know how to make this company efficient. I know how to do it. But then I must be able to do it in an environment where I can easily reduce manpower.” However, in India there is too much political interference with state-owned Sail to make this possible. Pande, who has worked in steel for 13 years, argues a social safety net is required.
Longer term he – like other members of India’s well-off – believes that the answer to overmanning is not economic restructuring but population control. “Population is the other issue we don’t want to talk about. Politicians don’t talk about it because they have lost elections in the past. The result is the labour force increases every year.”
India’s population is growing at 1.8% a year which means that by 2010 it will be 1.3 billion. India’s elite believes that this level of growth is damaging and unsustainable. It’s the age-old lament of the insecure rich worried by the burden of the unproductive poor. It’s expressed by even the most urbane Indians in crude terms: “We’d be a rich country if only we could keep our peckers in our trousers”
The acceptable face of Communism
We drive to a building that has a hammer and sickle at its entrance. We are taken up to the office of Sitramam Yechuri, politbureau member of the Communist Party of India. The party runs West Bengal state, and is often included in coalition governments. It is regarded as mainstream. Its most senior figure Jyoti Basu, chief minister of West Bengal, which contains Calcutta, has even gone to the US to attract foreign investment and has said “in the era of globalization and free markets, no state can remain an island. We have realized this and my government has embarked on a programme of liberalization”.
Yechuri is youngish and well dressed. He is to communism what UK prime minister Tony Blair is to socialism, except he can’t afford a spin doctor. Asked for the Marxist view of current events he says: “Hot money makes your economic indicators look comfortable. In a macro sense you are happy to plough along. But the moment this money leaves you are exposed to a crisis. The only way to repay is to sell your national assets to multinational corporations and at this stage you are selling them for a song.”
He continues in language equally at home in the mouth of right-wing populists: “This is a sort of economic recolonization. And it is taking place now. Decisions about the domestic economy are no longer sovereign. But for the West it is power without responsibility – unlike the colonial phase.”
Turning his thoughts to India, Yechuri says: “What you’ve had here is not capitalism in a classic sense. We’re having it imposed on a feudal background. That is why we don’t have capitalists with the tenacity to fight. If Coca-Cola comes and makes an offer to Charanjit Singh of Campa Cola, he buckles. He controls 80% of the market, but he doesn’t have the vision to see it can go into other dimensions of growth. An offer made by Coke is good enough for generations of his family to stay happy. It’s a feudal way of thinking.”
We have a late lunch with Deepak Nayyar a former chief economic adviser to the government of India, and currently economics professor at Jawaharlal Nehru University. He says he wrote about the Asian crisis before it happened. Economic logic, he says, dictated it was going to happen.
“As countries begin to use capital inflows to finance current-account deficits, the outcome is almost inevitable. As you finance them you need high interest rates to entice and keep investors, and you need strong exchange rates to ensure confidence. The first tends to strangle domestic investment, the second to squeeze the competitiveness of exports. Three to five years into this period your current-account deficit begins to widen as your trade deficits grow. You need larger and larger capital flows to sustain such current account deficits. There comes a time when investors begin to doubt the capacity of the government to hold the exchange rate, or the capacity of the economy to service the debt or realize the capital gain. Any crisis of confidence – it could be endogenous or exogenous – then tends to produce a run on currencies.”
Regulators under siege
Bombay is next on the itinerary. We leave for the airport around 30 minutes before the flight is due to take off. This is where Singh’s Special Protection Group becomes a business traveller’s dream.
They pre-arrange boarding passes so you don’t have to check in; they pre-check your bags so you don’t have to go through the usual rigmarole with x-rays. All of which means you can arrive at the airport minutes before take off. Singh averages an arrival time of anywhere between 11 and seven minutes. It used to be even better. He used to be able to drive his car right up to the plane. However, other SPG protectees abused the privilege. When cutting it fine they would drive their car into the path of the plane to stop it taking off without them. Singh now has to go to the terminal like everyone else and take the bus.
Next morning we meet DR Mehta, the head of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi). As we walk up the stairs to the first floor office, an exposed sewage pipe is visible. We are welcomed by Mehta from behind his seven-foot desk. He signs documents and tosses them on the floor for collection by a boy.
“We have $8.6 billion of foreign institutional money [mostly in the equity market] as of close yesterday,” he says. “They can bring in any money they like, take out any they wish. For them there is full convertibility. Very often people say the Indian market was not affected by the Asian turmoil because of its insulation. But so far as the securities market is concerned, the foreign investors have full convertibility. Earlier we had $9.2 billion.”
The real issue, he insists, is the domestic investor. “The biggest trade is when local people get their currency converted.” That is: speculators can only bring down a currency when there is capital account convertibility for locals because ultimately it is domestic capital flight that brings down the currency.
A call comes through. After a few minutes he laughs into the receiver. “Yes, I know you are quite forthright.” He puts down the telephone. “That was the head of a large foreign fund. He was complaining that he’d just gone to see the ministry of finance to complain that Sebi doesn’t have enough teeth.”
He calls his secretary and she brings in a document. It’s a list of laws that need to be changed or modified to give Sebi “teeth”. He notes: “We have large numbers of cases against us in the courts. In some of the cases our powers have been questioned.”
Our next meeting is at the Oberoi hotel with a friend of Singh’s – one of the best lawyers in India. He explains the situation Mehta has just referred to. Sebi ruled that there was a case of insider trading at Hindustan Lever.
The directors of this company then challenged the ruling at the appellate level of the ministry of finance. This overturned Sebi’s verdict and said it had acted in an arbitrary way beyond its jurisdiction. So Sebi is suing the finance ministry.
“This is not unusual,” says the lawyer. The telecoms regulator, Tria, is being sued by government telecoms operator MTNL which is challenging one of its verdicts. In India Michael Milken would still be in court querying the regulator’s right to expose him. India’s most celebrated alleged financial wrongdoer, Harshad Mehta is still in court doing just that – challenging Sebi’s allegations that he rigged the market in 1992.
In other markets there is a presumption that the regulator is a referee – necessary and with no axe to grind. In India, the regulator is just another bureaucratic department, capable of being thwarted by other bureaucratic departments and the legal system itself.
Says the lawyer: “You have to look at the judicial system here. The legal framework proceeds on the basis that even in administrative action there has to be no arbitrariness. If someone exercises discretion it opens up a window for a legal dispute. All these challenges emanate from that.” The only decision in India that can be said – by law – to contain no arbitrary elements is a verdict by the Supreme Court.
“By definition you cannot have strong regulators while you have this arbitrary clause. All regulations evolve over a period of time and require some interpretation. So they can always be challenged as arbitrary.”
Singh wants us to see corporate India. We start at one of India’s best managed companies, Larsen & Toubro. “Look around,” says Singh. “No one is lingering around in the corridors. That’s how you know it’s a good company.” We are taken into the chairman’s office. Singh is convinced Larsen & Toubro is a model for how an autonomous state-owned enterprise should be run (though it is in fact a private-sector company).
Founded by Danes who left long ago, it is the biggest engineering and construction company in the country and recently completed the world’s largest regenerator (a pressure vessel used in oil refineries). It is unique among Indian companies in that it prohibits the children of its top 100 managers from joining the business. This is to retain meritocracy and prevent cronyism.
The chairman, SD Kulkarni, is very keen on focus. “In India a number of companies are conglomerates. Much more than is normal in the West. The background to this is the days of industrial licensing. The government used to decide which industry you could get into, and say ‘you will make 100,000 and no more of these in red, not black’.
“I worked at a company that was given a licence to make a refrigerator of 100 litres, the type you find in hotels. We couldn’t make a bigger size.
“This is at an end thankfully. So today we concentrate on engineering and construction, construction equipment and cement. This is our focus. Earlier we were in shipping. We just sold the ships. We used to make computer printers. We discontinued that. We used to make footwear for export. We have closed that down. We have settled with our workers.”
When a reference is made to Arvind Pande’s problems settling with workers at Sail, he smiles. There is no comparison, he points out. His shoe company had only 200 employees.
Asked if he would find it useful to own a bank he responds: “To my mind that is one of the problems the Japanese face. All the transactions must be done on their own merits and not because I own a bank and I want this loan. If my own bank can be convinced they should take that risk, why shouldn’t I be able to persuade some other bank. That’s the wrong sort of organization to think of.”
Next we drive to the home of India’s best known entrepreneur, Subhash Chandra, the boss of satellite television station Zee-TV. His predominantly Hindi-language service has left Rupert Murdoch’s Star TV punch-drunk and now the two are in merger talks. Zee has the upper hand. We eat chillas, and talk about his company’s phenomenal growth and his highly unusual – by Indian standards – turning of the tables on a foreign entrant.
It’s a simple business history by Indian standards: “We were in agricultural commodities, and that led us in the late 1970s to do business with Food Corporation of India. We did some work for them in storage which introduced us to plastics and lamination, which is how we entered into packaging. The commodity business gave us a surplus that went into the property business. One of these properties was developed into an amusement park. That kind of introduced us to entertainment, and that is where the idea for going into satellite television came from. Now we’ve come to know what satellites can do we are going to launch one next year.”
We talk about crime in Bombay. Extortion rackets are on the increase. Middle-class people with foreign cars get a ransom note and are told to pay up or they’ll be dead the next morning.
The origin of this, he says, is, ironically, the government’s economic reforms. “Because of the liberalization of imports, the smuggling activities of the mafia gangs have gone down. Each mafia gang owner has 500 to 2,000 employees and he has to feed them every day. So they need alternative sources of income. This is one of them.”
Back in the foyer of the Oberoi, Singh spots the head of a rival investment bank wandering around looking very agitated. He suspects some VSNL gossip is to be had and goes over for a chat. He returns. “It wasn’t VSNL that was driving him mad,” he says. “He’s just brought over all his global heads to meet a client, but the client’s now reneging on the fee. Welcome to India.”
We arrive at the building of the industrial conglomerate Essar. Outside are a Bentley and Mercedes. “That one’s Shashi’s and that one’s Ravi’s.” The building is unusually eye-catching – by Bombay’s standards – and the foyer is filled with attractive women. There is so much marble it could be the EBRD. We go up in a private elevator and enter Ravi Ruia’s office which he shares with his brother, Shashi. Office is the wrong word. It is at least 20 metres long and has a single desk at either end. There is a sofa in the middle so the brothers can meet half-way for a chat.
Buy dirt, sell dirt
One floor down, Shashi’s sons Prashant and Anshuman have an identical office. They can afford it. Essar’s assets have grown from $50 million in 1983 to around $4 billion today. They have a mobile phone franchise, a steel factory, a shipping business, a power plant and an oil refinery. This building is only three years old. Unlike other Asian companies Essar doesn’t own property. “We have looked at property from a build-use perspective and not used it for wealth creation,” says Ravi. “We don’t look at it like the rest of Asia. Property has never been financed in India. There is no liquidity to finance property. So it is all self-financed.”
Indeed, one problem the banking system does not face in India is exposure to property tycoons. The Reserve Bank of India prohibited such lending several years ago – a move that now looks rather clever. India’s non-exposure to property is in stark contrast to the rest of Asia. Maybe the contrast is explained by the Chinese character for business, whose two characters literally translate as “buy dirt, sell land”. Chinese conglomerates are typically companies that made noodles and then went into property. It is not an exaggeration to say that most Chinese businesses have the goal of becoming property-centred. All the other businesses in the group – such as the noodle factory – is just to help the cashflow.
The next morning we rise early and head out to the airport. We are travelling to Gujarat state to visit Essar’s steel factory. We board a Bell long-range helicopter and get to a height from which Bombay’s shanty towns look almost picturesque.
On arrival there is a jeep full of local police waiting – Singh’s praetorian guard. We have landed in what is known as “the colony” – a living area for the factory managers complete with a school, a sports club and a shopping mall. It has the sort of orderly planning one is not accustomed to in India. In fact it looks like the set of the Truman Show.
Next to the factory is a port – which brings the iron ore in from the other side of India – and Essar’s 515 megawatt power station which both serves the factory and sells power to Gujarat state.
We view the iron ore briquette furnace. It is foreign made and has a name-plate capacity of 1.3 million tonnes. The chief engineer has already upped this to 1.7 million and he reckons 1.9 million is possible by end of the year.
The factory employs just over 1,500 people to make two million tonnes of steel. To put this in perspective, the total Indian output of steel is 24 million tonnes. World production is 750 million tonnes.
But as a result of India’s high financing costs and the falling price of steel even Essar’s state-of-the-art plant lost 106 crore ($25 million) in the first half of this year. Sail lost 617 crore ($146 million) in the same period. Luckily, the power plant is making a very good return on investment. While we were there it was pumping out 435 megawatts. At that capacity it is already making a return of 22%.
As we return to Bombay Singh tells me he is going to have to return to Delhi the next day. The fight for VSNL is hotting up and he needs to be close to the gossip.
He feels Merrill is a certainty to win the mandate. “Merrill have been throwing people at this mandate, plus they’re on very good terms with the head of the task force. He was at the steel ministry when they did the deal for Sail in 1996.”
That night we meet up with one of Singh’s friends, who is in the construction business. He mentions the rent control act, and the fact that many of India’s best apartments are being lived in at rents which date back to the 1940s.
We go for the customary paan. This is a betel leaf with sugar and spices and rose petals. We go to the best paan man in Bombay who resides behind an iron gate on a busy street. We are invited behind the gate where the old man is constructing the paans. “So is this the paan-equivalent of business class,” I joke. “No this is first class,” says Singh. The old man places a paan into Singh’s waiting mouth.
The next morning the subject of the rent control act and its related problems is picked up by Deepak Satwalekar, managing director of the Housing Development Finance Corporation. “The central government has hurt the cities because property taxes are linked to rents,” he says. “If your rents are from the 1940s your property tax is effectively frozen. In most cities around the world the property taxes account for the significant source of revenue for the local government. In India they’re insignificant.”
This has led to a reliance on the octroi “This is really an entry tax,” explains Satwalekar. “Every time you bring goods into the city you have to pay tax. So at the entry to the city you find long queues of trucks waiting to get themselves certified, pay the taxes and come in. That’s again a disincentive to trade. In Europe, economic union allows you to flow across countries. Over here you can’t even flow across states, or cities.”
Mumbai jumbo
The politician in charge of Bombay, Bal Thackeray, is next on the agenda. A rendezvous is organized with his press officer at the Lilavati Hospital from where we go to his home. The leader of the Shiv Sena party is an admirer of Hitler’s “hypnotic spell that made people follow him” and is regarded with suspicion by non-Hindu groups who consider him sectarian.
We are signed in at a checkpoint at the beginning of an otherwise normal street. Does this not make it inconvenient for others who live in the street. “No,” says the press man “they feel much safer.”
We pass through a metal detector. The interview, we are told, will be conducted without shoes. Thackeray enters in a long, flowing orange robe and a pair of dark glasses. He says he admires Margaret Thatcher’s free-market policies but has decided to give away electricity free to farmers. He favours benevolent dictatorship: “If we got a dictator then we would see what India could do.” He believes India’s democracy is “no democracy – it’s just a garb we wear to hide our sins.” He reacts angrily when asked why the name Bombay was changed to Mumbai. “Your ancestors mispronounced the name. It is Mumbai named after the goddess Mumbai devi.”
But wasn’t Bombay just an empty swamp with seven disconnected islands before the British came? This gets short-shrift: “If I come to London and change your city name how would you like it? No. These are all internal affairs. I don’t want any foreigners saying why this and why that. It’s the original name.”
Fired up, he continues: “This Pepsi generation – I don’t care a hoot for them. What is their culture? They are not Indians. My government has passed an act that any advertisement on TV if it is in an English accent and tone – the pop song – then it will be stopped. If they speak foreign English – the gargling like Americans – we will not allow it. It must have an Indian touch. When you sell a cooker, why does it need a foreign touch?
“You have to love your nation. These boys don’t have any culture. Just imitating all foreign things.”
Thackeray’s popularity is based in part on the swadeshi instinct of “India for Indians”
The final meeting Singh has set up is with an astrologer. The Indian elite take astrology seriously. “The next two years are bad for the world,” he predicts. “The position of Saturn will lead to destruction. But within Asia, India is better. The Indian moon sign is Makara and Saturn is good for that. Rahu and Ketu are positioned opposite each other which is also good for Makara. India should prosper in black metals. The Saturn period will last two and a half years.” I catch a flight back to Delhi to rejoin Singh.
He arrives at 10am wearing a brown Nehru-style suit which was made for him by the Maharaja of Jodhpur’s tailor. We go to a house which has a sign outside which reads “self reliance”. This is the residence of Virender Singh, member of parliament for the Swadeshi Jagaran Manch party. We are shown into the house, remove our shoes and sit on a mirzapur wool carpet. Our host offers us Bombay mix and bananas. The room is bare except for the carpet, a wardrobe and a painting of Shanka, a god that lives in cremation grounds.
The Swadeshi Jagaran Manch is six years old and was set up to oppose economic liberalization. Singh translates from Hindi: “They believe ours is an old nation – over 5,000 years old – and the most important thing for our country is the family. They feel that the West’s view of the family has digressed from family values that we hold close – everyone helping everyone else. Their definition of a family is not just immediate relatives but is extended to the village, the town and the world at large. They view the world at large as a family as opposed to how the West views it – as a market and that’s the crux of the difference.”
They have a publication, Swadeshi Patrika, to disseminate the message. An edition is produced from the wardrobe. Its front cover says “Multinational companies: quit India”.
Virender Singh feels India is being invaded. “That which was done by the dint of the sword, now is being done by open borders. The present economic system allows colonialism without bloodshed.”
From Bombay mix and bananas to a thali at the Sheraton with Arjun Sengupta, former parliamentarian, former planning commission boss and currently a professor at Jawahar Lal Nehru University.
We talk about the international financial system. “In fact,” says Sengupta “I am a member of an international committee for development planning. We have recommended the creation of a world financial organization, a super regulator for the world as a whole, harmonizing the national regulations and with a court of appeal. Whatever happened in east Asia was partly due to overlending and incautious lending.”
Scepticism oozes around the table. Says Singh: “The average salary of an investment banker is paid in terms of revenues generated and, when you have that kind of incentive programme, people will go to the edge and test the law. You always find that thing which is grey. It’s all right, but it’s probably not what the law intended to do.”
Sengupta does however believe in the free movement of capital: “Today I find it hard to think of controlling capital. I can only make the transaction cost higher. I cannot stop it. I am one of strongest supporters of capital liberalization in India.”
He adds: “I don’t think there is any way of stopping it. Legally you can’t send money from India abroad. I don’t believe you can stop it. A mathematician will find a derivative that will show that all money going out of India is in the form of payments for exports that will take place the day after tomorrow.
In the car Singh says: “You know what. You haven’t spoken to a former prime minister yet,” and picks up his mobile. We arrive at the home of IK Gujral later that afternoon. “This is exactly the same as the prime minister’s house,” says Singh. On Gujral’s bookshelf is a copy of The Lonely Prophet.
Gujral was a cautious liberalizer in his time as prime minister. “I was being told every time that tigers are jumping and you are losing, but we have been saved by caution.”
Was he told by the World Bank and IMF to have capital account convertibility? “Yes all the time,” says Gujral. He turns his attention to privatization, another mantra of the World Bank: “It has not been privatization. It has been loot and plunder. It took the West three centuries to create a bourgeoisie by looting the colonies. We’re trying to create a local bourgeoisie in three years by looting our own people. The market is a very cruel place for the poor.” As if India is not.
That evening we fly to Pune near Bombay to visit Rahul Bajaj, one of the most vocal men in the country. He runs Bajaj Auto, a family motorbike business and is famous for his Bombay Club (an organization which opposes foreign domination/majority ownership of Indian industry). When we enter his office he is wearing the Bajaj Auto grey shirt that his factory workers wear. He is very charming, but prone to fits of temper. His factory is located in a former snake colony, and he is the only Indian family businessman to live on site. His only means of communication with the “civilized” world is a private jet.
“No Indian company is internationally competitive,” he says, “because of the licensing and socialism of the past. And then you just want to open up the economy and bring down the import duty rates. So instead of having the opportunity to have 50 to 100 Indian multinationals by 2010 or 2020, you’d have 80% of our top 200 companies owned by foreigners. This is something I don’t find acceptable.
“People say this is nationalistic. Parochial. I say bullshit. We are called protectionist by those – I am sorry to say – who are under the influence of foreigners. They are being entertained by them or sponsored for trips by the IMF or World Bank and become armchair critics. So-called intellectuals – and my friends too. I get cheesed off.”
If Bajaj sounds uncosmopolitan, he is not. This year he was chairman of the council of the World Economic Forum in Davos. He is the first Asian and first Indian to have this honour and as he points out: “They know my views very well.”
The result of VSNL is announced the next day. Singh is shocked. It has gone to the same three lead managers who have done the earlier tranches, and to CSFB which did a rating advisory. Merrill gets nothing. “What was the point in getting us all to pitch?” he fumes. He can’t understand it.
One of the criteria for selection was item 2.4 – “number of issues pulled out (1993-98)” – which he thought was sure to cripple the previous leads. They had pulled VSNL deals in 1994 and 1995 before finally issuing the stock in March 1997. “Low fees too,” he notes, before adding: “Someone has got to reform this process.”
We head for Varanasi, India’s spiritual capital – a pick-me-up after the VSNL announcement. Hindus believe if their bodies are burned by the shores of the Ganges they will go straight to heaven. As we arrive in the city, we see bodies being carried through the streets from all corners of India, covered by shiny silks. From a boat on the Ganges we watch them as they are lit and head heavenward.
Varanasi is the closest city to Singh’s home, Manda – the principality of which his father is maharaja and of which one day he will be too. It covers 966 square miles, though the family owns little land apart from the palace. His father gave away his property in a land redistribution soon after inheriting.
The palace is nearly 500 years old and it is nearly a ruin. Singh would need a Goldman Sachs partnership to restore it to its former glory. He is racking his brains for ideas for a hotel, but hasn’t come up with a winner.
We visit his father’s birthplace. India’s former prime minister was born in a mud hut. An ancestor had killed a sage’s child while hunting and a curse was put on the family. The family would have no heirs, went the curse, if they were born in a brick building. It said nothing about mud.
We return to Delhi. Our final meeting is with the agriculture minister Sonpal Shastry. He offers us a samosa and starts chatting about his home-made chutneys. We are on the verge of being asked back to his house to taste them, when a telephone call comes through. He’ll have to go to that farmer’s rally in Bombay after all. That means no chutney for us. The conversation turns to the most pressing subject of modern Indian life. So, what is going on with the onions?
The problem with onions
“Two harvests ago there was a glut of onions,” says Shastry. “We didn’t have space to store them or the market to absorb them. So the farmers had to leave them rotting in the fields. This year’s production therefore came down as the sowing was lower. Farmers naturally reacted to the excess supply by cutting production. Then, to make it worse, during the monsoon we had freak weather conditions that haven’t occurred for 112 years. And we don’t have a buffer stock.”
The department that exports onions wasn’t talking to anyone else and happily went ahead exporting onions as normal. So a mix of bureaucratic incompetence, freak natural conditions and – most importantly – market forces caused the onion crisis.
“Market forces can never serve the cause of agriculture,” says Shastry, and digresses: “Perfect competition presupposes a free flow of resources, free flow of capital and goods, and free flow of labour. Is it ever there? Why don’t America and Europe allow free flow of Indian labour? We will accept free competition. We will accept your free flow of capital. Have capital account convertibility. But it won’t happen. You have economic power and you are the leaders. Everybody listens to you.”
There is a power cut. We keep talking in the dark. If we talk long enough, the enormous problems of India, and its onions, may have solved themselves.