Caught with their pants down?

Rating agencies have been strongly criticized for failing to spot the Asian crisis. Investment-grade bonds have been downgraded to junk status - but only after problems have appeared and without much warning. For the first time the agencies are having to justify themselves. Are they as good in Asia as they are in the US? Steven Irvine reports.

“An institution run by a bunch of bureaucrats who couldn’t run a corner candy store is not necessarily a bad credit risk,” ran one particularly good rebuff from a defensive Moody’s executive in late 1997. It was not a vintage year for the credit-rating agencies in Asia.

There is no question that a re-rating of Asian credits was in order. But both Moody’s Investors Service and Standard & Poor’s (S&P) are open to criticism over the way events overtook them.

Access intelligence that drives action

To unlock this research, enter your email to log in or enquire about access