Forex shake-out

Emu will accelerate the concentration of the forex market towards a few big banks. But will that harm liquidity? By Guy Whittaker.

Life under the euro

European economic and monetary union is often cited as the single most important event for the current generation of foreign exchange dealers. In fact a number of major developments are occurring simultaneously – some unconnected with Emu – each of which will have a profound impact on the forex market.

Independently of progress towards Emu, the rapid application of technology is already changing the nature of the foreign exchange market and it may be assumed that this trend will accelerate over the next few years. One example of this has been the rise of electronic broking and its impact on the traditional voice-brokerage firms. As clients increasingly embrace electronic communication and deal execution, the market-making banks will face many of the same issues. When you add the prospect of fewer currencies – post-Emu – to this development, the adjustments that will be necessary in the forex market become even more apparent.

Emu is already having a significant impact on the market. Opinions on whether or not Emu will be successful, and whether or not it will proceed on time, have ceased to be the main determinant as each market participant plans for the years ahead. The same two issues affect everyone involved in this market. The first is a practical business concern – if your bank is unable to price and settle in euros from day one, clients will move to a bank that can do this. The second involves an understanding that there will be a structural change in the business possibilities open to each market-making bank and that the competitive environment will be radically altered.

Planning systems

The practical question of acquiring the physical ability to deal in euros involves detailed process-mapping and systems-programming in the various parts of each organization whose clients may chose to use the new currency. Obvious examples for commercial banks might be cash management, electronic banking and settlements departments. In addition, front-office risk management systems need to be altered, not just to accept one more currency, but to provide the flexibility for dual-currency revaluations and risk monitoring during the transition years. This preparation is the minimum necessary to ensure that banks are equipped to stay in the forex business. The cost and effort involved in making these changes might be significant and individual institutions will visibly notice the impact on their business. However, it is unlikely that these investment decisions will lead banks to question the viability of providing foreign exchange services to their clients or will create much of an impact for the outside observer.

The first step in formulating a strategic response – the second challenge for banks – is to understand what part of the current business is at risk. For most global foreign exchange banks, as much as 20% of the turnover generated by their European-based business is likely to come from trades where both currencies might be expected to be first-wave and second-wave Emu members. This disguises the reality that this proportion varies considerably by country. Intuitively, the trade and capital flows emanating from some countries are more intra-European than others.

This is borne out by Citibank’s own internal analysis of the attendant foreign exchange flows, with some countries generating in excess of 40% of their present business from intra-European currency pairs. Pan-European banks will therefore need to be sensitive to these differences when planning their post-Emu organization. Banks that are solely dependent on local clients in these heavily affected European countries will have to give serious consideration as to whether they should continue to participate in the forex market. Consolidation around larger players is a trend that is already firmly in place and if one impact of Emu is to force today’s smaller regional participants to scale down their foreign exchange business, wider questions surrounding the tightening of market liquidity will become more acute.

A further compelling conclusion that comes from understanding the current environment is the need to centralize risk management. This conclusion is in no way special to market-making banks but is mirrored in almost all European companies. Most banks have recognized this and many have already completed the initial practical steps. Banks are now focusing on ensuring that they are still appropriately positioned to understand and meet the requirements of their clients. Among these banks two models are emerging. Many have chosen to centralize their sales and trading functions together. A few (including Citibank) have chosen to invest in the technology necessary to support local sales teams, close to their customers, with the trading managed centrally.

Rival to the dollar

The third major impact on the foreign exchange market from the introduction of the euro comes from the prospect of a new reserve currency being created to rival the dollar. Despite the trend over the past few years for cross-currency trading to increase in importance, the dollar remains the dominant traded currency. It is typically the currency in which risk is measured and managed and in which commodities and emerging market trade flows are denominated. It is also the base currency for most international investments and the reserve currency of choice for most central banks and government institutions. If the euro emerges as a hard currency, all these assumptions will be questioned and a new balance in the foreign exchange market will emerge.

Quite separately from developments in Europe, many currencies previously regarded as exotic have undergone a general liberalizing of their regulatory regimes. Faced with the prospect of fewer currencies to trade in a post-Emu world, it is not surprising that many foreign exchange banks have seen emerging markets business as the panacea. What is already evident is that this is encouraging banks to develop an activity in these infant markets. It is important that this activity soundly reflects underlying client demand and accessible liquidity.

We are still in an era of business growth but it is also an era of industry consolidation. If Emu were the only exogenous factor affecting the foreign exchange markets, the potential would exist for a major change to take place both in the structure and number of participating banks. There will be a continuation of the trend, already in place for some years, for business to gravitate to fewer, bigger, banks. The euro itself will be more important and will nominally trade in greater volumes than any individual European currency preceding it. However, the consolidation of risk management centres and the reduction in the number of participating banks will inevitably affect liquidity in non-euro currency pairs.

Success in the post-Emu foreign exchange market might require a strong presence in the growth area of emerging markets, but it will also require the ability to use the rapidly advancing technology effectively. Implications for the physical number of dealers involved in market-making can be drawn from the experiences of the voice brokers. The demands made on forex sales staff by ever more sophisticated clients covering ever more complex markets will inevitably increase dramatically.

When Emu is added to these other major developments, the foreign exchange market will emerge with a radically different profile from that which exists today.

The pace of change will accelerate over the months ahead and survival will not be guaranteed for those choosing to wait for the trends to emerge.

Guy Whittaker is head of global foreign exchange at Citibank.