The rush to finance Latin energy

A SUPPLEMENT TO EUROMONEY/JUNE 1996 Private sector powers ahead As Latin American governments turn to private capital to finance the energy sector, opportunities for foreign investors are matched only by those in Asia. And when Brazil hits the market, all that went before will pale in comparison. Michael Marray reports The Latin American energy sector […]

A SUPPLEMENT TO EUROMONEY/JUNE 1996

Private sector powers ahead

As Latin American governments turn to private capital to finance
the energy sector, opportunities for foreign investors are matched
only by those in Asia. And when Brazil hits the market, all that
went before will pale in comparison. Michael Marray reports

The Latin American energy sector is going through a period of unprecedented change. In the oil industry, the long-standing taboo against foreign involvement has been broken – even Venezuela recently signed exploration joint ventures with the big western oil companies. And in power generation and distribution, a wave of privatizations is sweeping the region, not only bringing in players from the developed world but, at the same time, resulting in growing links between the regional power utilities.

The primary force behind all this is the recognition by Latin American governments of a pressing need to utilize private sector capital in infrastructure development. This theme was spelt out during a visit to Chile in May by German foreign minister Klaus Kinkel, accompanied by a delegation of German businessmen. During a meeting with Kinkel, Chilean president Eduardo Frei reiterated his policy of involving the private sector in the development of infrastructure and stressed the importance of freeing state resources for investment in social projects.

Similar thinking now prevails in almost all of Latin America. Programmes to eradicate poverty are getting priority in government spending plans and the state is leaving areas such as electricity generation and telecommunications.

The result is opportunities for foreign investors on a scale matched only in Asia. Developers, financiers and equipment manufacturers from North America, Europe and Asia are devoting more attention to Latin America than ever before.

Latin American countries are fortunate in that the export credit agencies (ECAs) from Europe, Japan and North America see the Latin power sector as the battlefield for exports of heavy equipment. Support for Latin power deals from institutions such as US Exim Bank and Overseas Private Investment Corporation (OPIC) is aggressive and complements support from regional development institutions such as the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB).

“Latin America has always been the strongest part of the OPIC portfolio: we are doing more business in Latin America than anywhere else in the world, with Asia in second place,” says Ruth Harkin, president and chief executive officer of OPIC, the federal agency that supports private US investment around the world by lending and providing political risk insurance. “We are specifically interested in the power sector,” she says. Latin power projects were targeted in 1993, when she was brought in to head OPIC.

“With all the privatizations, the power sector is ripe for American investment,” says Harkin. She points out that power projects in developing countries are seen by the US as the best way to improve the lives of the people living there.

So far OPIC deals include a 1,320MW Argentine hydroelectric plant for CMS Generation Corp of Michigan, a 216MW natural gas project in Bolivia for Energy Initiatives of New Jersey, a 14MW hydro facility in Costa Rica for General Electric together with the Energy Investors Funds of Massachusetts, and a 78MW hydro plant in Guatemala for Teco Power of Florida.

Although OPIC raised its finance and insurance limits in 1993 to $200 million per project, they were almost breached by Colombia’s Termobarranquilla project: OPIC provided $200 million-worth of insurance as well as $150 million in direct lending. Since then Colombia has been struck from the list of countries eligible for OPIC support as a result of a diplomatic dispute with the US. Nonetheless some deals already completed are regarded as models of successfully financing projects in Latin America.

With a total cost of around $755 million, the Termobarranquilla gas-fired power station is the biggest independent power project (IPP) so far in Latin America. Its use of a variety of ECA and commercial credit sources points the way forward for other projects. The project involves building a 750MW gas-fired combined-cycle power plant, plus refurbishing an existing 230MW thermal plant. As usual in IPP deals, the project is underpinned by a long-term power sales contract bought by state-owned Colombian electricity company Corporacion Electrica de la Costa Atlantica (Corelca). In spite of state ownership, the lending banks wanted some sort of guarantee concerning obligations under the power sales contract. The finance co-arrangers, Paribas and UBS, were able to bring in Financiera Energetica Nacional (FEN), a division of the ministry of energy, to back up the Corelca contract. Along with Corelca, the other sponsors are ABB Energy Ventures, Energy Initiatives and Lancaster Distral.

The involvement of both OPIC and US Exim were important elements in the transaction. US Exim stepped up with political risk cover for the $153 million construction loan and, once construction is completed, will replace the banks’ loans with a $162 million 12-year loan. Meanwhile OPIC is taking the construction risk, through a $150 million construction loan, and has also put up $200 million-worth of guarantees.

Bankers agree that although multi-sourcing makes deals more complex, it also points the way forward. “For the larger deals, there is no one source of funds that is deep enough,” says Ralph Scholtz, vice-president of project finance at Paribas in New York.

In the oil sector, US Exim was also a key player in one of the biggest recent projects in Colombia, in its eastern oil fields. Last December, Ecopetrol, Colombia’s state oil company, signed a 10-year, $566 million syndicated loan to help finance an 800-kilometre pipeline transporting oil from the Cusiana and Cuipiagua fields to Covenas on the Caribbean coast, from where it will be exported. The total cost of this pipeline, which will begin operations next year, is estimated at $2 billion. A syndicate comprising ABN Amro, Bank of Tokyo, Paribas, Chemical Bank (now Chase), Deutsche Bank and Société Générale is involved in the latest financing. The first $270 million tranche is a 10-year commercial loan, while the second five-year $296 million tranche carries US Exim guarantees.

These high-profile deals were completed before the US decertified Colombia. The question now being asked in the markets is whether projects can move forward without big US players such as US Exim and OPIC. Chris Teague, managing director for project finance for Latin America at Citicorp Securities in New York, comments: “We believe projects can still get done in the Colombian market. It will depend on the project: projects which have a substantial amount of local currency cash flow may, in some circumstances, require some sort of insurance support to make them viable, but we do not see a problem for projects which are export-related, such as oil and other natural resource projects.”

Scholtz comments: “The effect of the decertification has been to delay some projects with equipment to be supplied by US companies, but European and Japanese exporters are ready to step in and take advantage of opportunities in Colombia.”

Elsewhere in Latin America, Chile is a major source of power generation business, as the country attempts to keep infrastructure development in line with its high economic growth. Recently General Electric and Mitsui successfully bid for a turnkey contract for a natural gas-fired cogeneration plant supplying the Santiago Electric Company.

The deal centres on the coal-powered Renca plant on the outskirts of the city, which serves as a backup to be brought online at peak demand periods. The facility is a contributor to the smog that affects Santiago, and the building of a gas facility at Renca is viewed as a positive environmental step. The sponsors of the Renca plant, the first natural gas-fired cogeneration facility in Chile, include Chilgener, Duke Power of the US and Novacorp of Canada. Operations will start late in 1997.

More gas-powered projects are anticipated in Chile, where pipelines are under construction to bring in gas from Argentina. “In Argentina, they have a balanced generation sector, with gas, oil and hydro-electric,” notes Pablo Salcedo, head of research at ING Barings in Santiago. “But in Chile, new development is definitely going to be gas, since it is a good idea to reduce reliance upon hydro-electricity from current levels of around 80%.”

Argentina has many new power projects on the drawing board, though they tend to be relatively small-scale – generally in the $75 million to $150 million range. At the Inter-American Development Bank meeting held in Buenos Aires in March, the IDB signed a $44 million loan for the Consorcio de Lineas de Transmission, which is building a second 587-kilometre transmission line linking consumers to its hydro-electric plant in Yacyreta.

Brazil and Bolivia are cooperating in the cross-border transport of natural gas, a project worth $1.8 billion that could result in a number of gas-fired power stations in the state of Sao Paulo, the heart of Brazilian industry.

Brazil remains the country in the region with the most potential for new power projects. So far it has failed to live up to its promise. Foreign developers want to see changes in the legal framework before proceeding. “But when Brazil hits the market it will make everything else look pale,” is a typical comment from one banker.

Scholtz at Paribas views inside-the-fence deals – power plants supplying a single industrial host – as a potentially important part of the Brazilian power sector. “Brazil is moving in that direction because it has a lot of very high quality industrial companies,” he says. These will attract investors, particularly as many of them already have close relationships with foreign banks.


Taking assets to market

As state electricity utitlities come up for sale, buyers from North America, Japan and Europe are expected to lead the bidding. Within the region Chilean companies have been fastest of the blocks in the region’s privatization game

ING Barings estimates suggest that the amount of private sector financing (both for new capacity and the privatization of existing assets) in the years 1996 to 2000 will be 10 times the $5.7 billion seen from 1992 to 1995. “From Mexico in the north to Argentina in the south, more than 70% of the electricity sector is still owned by the state,” notes Pablo Salcedo, head of research at ING Barings in Santiago, “so the opportunities are huge.”

Privatizations in Brazil alone support the ING Barings forecast. At the end of last month the government sold a controlling stake in Light Servicos de Electricidade (Light), a distribution company with annual sales of 21,200 gigawatt hours (GWh), to a consortium led by Electricité de France. In 1997 another six distributors are expected to be put up for sale, totalling another 24,300 GWh. And these do not include Electropaulo, which serves Sao Paulo – by some estimates the world’s largest city. Electropaulo has annual sales of 54,700 GWh and is expected to be sold by Sao Paulo in stages between 1997 and 1999.

Buyers for these assets are expected to come from Latin America, as well as North America, Japan and Europe, with Chile leading the way among the regional bidders. Chile’s own privatization programme is almost complete. Most power generation assets were sold off in the late 1980s, at which time foreign ownership was discouraged. But more recent sell-offs have featured foreign buyers.

Earlier this year the Chilean state-owned copper mining company Codelco sold a controlling 51% stake in electricity-generating unit Central Termoelectrica Tocopilla. It was bought by Inversora Electrica Andina, a consortium formed by Powerfin of Belgium, Iberdrola Energia of Spain and Distribuidora de Gas Enagas of Chile, for $178 million. With 90% of generation assets in private hands, Chile’s focus is now on building new capacity.

One last major privatization remains in Chile: Colbun, the third-largest generator in Chile, with nearly all capacity produced from hydro-electric plants, is down to be sold before the end of the year. The winning bidder for the initial 37.5% stake will also acquire an option to take a controlling stake. Colbun is the last big electricity utility to be privatized, and the Chilean government has stipulated that the buyer must not already control more than 5% of supplies to the central grid – effectively excluding both Chilgener and Endesa. Substantial foreign interest is expected.

Other Chilean companies are looking to their regional neighbours to expand. Endesa and Enersis registered in the bidding process for the privatization of Rio de Janeiro’s electricity utility Light Servicos de Electricidade before deciding not to participate. At present only 4% of electricity sales in Brazil are made by private distributors: the privatization process is expected to be the major source of electricity assets between now and the year 2000.

Chilean companies have also been among the bidders in neighbouring Argentina, where some $2.2 billion-worth of generation assets have been sold off so far, taking the level of private participation in the electricity generation sector to 60%. Central Puerto was acquired by Chilgener and Chilquinta, while Piedra Del Aguila was bought by a consortium including Chilgener and Duke Energy of the US. Chilean companies have also featured strongly as buyers of distribution companies: in Argentina, Enersis, Chilectra and Chilgener have acquired assets. And Peruvian distribution company Edelnor was bought by a consortium including local investors, plus Endesa of Spain and Chilectra and Enersis of Chile.

Salcedo at ING Barings expects to see more Chilean involvement, since Chilean companies have strong balance sheets and access to deep domestic capital markets. “I don’t think the limit is capital; one of the challenges of these companies is management,” he says. “Chile will continue to export capital and management, but this also means taking additional risk.”

Electricity generation and distribution may form the bulk of sales in the energy sector, but there is also a high level of activity in oil and gas. Free market rules do not always apply in this sector, since most governments remain committed to maintaining a major role for the state in oil exploration, or at least keeping control of oil companies in local hands. Nonetheless there are still plenty of opportunities, particularly in joint ventures with profit-sharing exploration agreements.

The most significant development of 1996 was in Venezuela, which until its recent bout of economic troubles had a commitment to state ownership. Earlier this year foreign companies were invited to bid on contracts involving exploration and profit-sharing with state-owned oil company Petroleos de Venezuela. The contracts run for 29 years once production gets under way, and allow foreign companies to conduct exploration within 4.5 million-acre blocks, with a minimum investment of $40 million per block. The bidding process was judged a success, with a total of eight fields auctioned off. The successful bidders included Mobil, Amoco, British Petroleum, Dupont, Elf-Aquitane and Enron.

Elsewhere in Latin America, in January Colombian state-owned oil company Ecopetrol disposed of its 39% stake in Promigas; Enron purchased the Promigas shares for $100 million. Next to be sold in Colombia is Ecopetrol’s stake in Gas Natural, a gas distributor in Bogota. In Peru the government is also privatizing many state-owned companies, including some in the energy sector.