Fears of a credit bubble in Brazil are increasing. A report by the rating agency Experian Latin America says the level of loans overdue by 90 days in the financial system has risen to 6.1% and it expects it to reach 8% by the end of the year.
Credit has reached 45% of GDP. Surveys suggest that the proportion of household income that goes to servicing debt is about 20%. And with interest rates still rising – the central bank’s Selic rate was raised to 12.25% in June – it is little wonder that investors are worried. According to the MSCI Brazil Large Financials Index, concerns about Brazilian credit have led to a 10% fall in the shares of Brazil’s largest banks since April 26, the beginning of the earnings season.
Fear can be a good thing. In mid-May Brazil’s senate approved the formation of a positive credit registry – previously banks could only see records of those that had defaulted. This new database will enable banks to take a more sophisticated approach to extending credit to the estimated 30 million people who have joined the ranks of the country’s middle classes in recent years. This will undoubtedly help banks manage their rising delinquency rates. Fear has also led to finance minister Guido Mantega talking about further government measures to curb credit growth and take some heat out of a very warm economy.
However, there does not yet seem to be real cause for fear. Yes, the level of consumer debt is high and the proportion of household income spent on interest payments is high. But in Brazil they always have been. Brazil is perhaps the only sophisticated financial system to be born and develop in an economy continually experiencing bouts of hyperinflation, debt crises and moratoriums. Brazilian banks are used to managing high inflation, interest rates and non-performing loans.
Even in exceptionally good times, this situation has been maintained. Between September 1994 and the beginning of 1997 NPLs rose from 5% to 15% – a big jump – but not such a failure of management when seen in the context of a rise in interest rates from 20% to 65%.
Bank margins
Meanwhile, Brazilian banks’ margins have always been high. In 1981 Brazilian banks held the first, third and sixth positions in a ranking of the world’s most profitable banks. In 1983 a study found that the top 10 Brazilian banks had maintained an average profit rate of 21.4% for the previous 18 years. In 1999 the average cost of credit was 83% when the basic interest rate was 21%, a spread of 62 percentage points. Analysis found that this spread comprised: 22% administration expenses, 13% taxes, 29% profits and 35% to cover NPLs. High margins persist today. Data from Austin Ratings, a Brazilian rating agency, show that the gross margin for the banking industry was 31.5% in 2006, 33.7% in 2007, 21.4% in 2008, 29.5% in 2009 and 31.8% in 2010. A consequence (as well as perhaps one of the causes) of these margins is an inbuilt cushion against non-repayment.
Roberto Setúbal, head of Itaú Unibanco, interviewed for this issue of Euromoney (see Banker of the Year: Setúbal stays grounded as Itaú flies, Euromoney July 2011), notes rising NPLs phlegmatically. He says: “Brazilian consumer debt and the service of consumer debt is high compared with many countries, especially those countries at the same level of development as Brazil. It’s high but it’s not increasing. So we believe this is much more a characteristic of our economy and financial system than anything else.”
Moody’s Investor Service is also unfazed. It has raised the rating on Brazilian government bonds to Baa2 from Baa3 because “Brazil’s credit fundamentals validate sovereign ratings in the higher Baa range”. This might not help the government’s fight against currency appreciation, but it should help calm the fears of international investors.