Asset management: Brazil reviews its pension arrangements

Brazil is a big financial market with lots to manage and plenty of challenges. New investment rules offer broader opportunities. International investors are starting to see the potential too. Rob Dwyer reports.

IN EARLY 2010 Brazil’s Bradesco Asset Management began to solidify its strategy to attract international capital into its managed funds. Tentative soundings of the market in the previous two years had been encouraging, says company chief Denise Pavarina, so about 12 months ago the marketing efforts began in earnest.

The focus began in Japan, where Bradesco has a partnership with Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group. One year later these plans had to accommodate the speed bumps of the withdrawal of funds from emerging markets globally, the sideways performance of Brazil’s Bovespa and the increase of the IOF international tax on Brazilian fixed-income investments to 6% in October 2010. (The IOF remains at 2% for equity.) There was also the Japanese earthquake. Despite these obstacles Bradesco grew its assets from Japanese investors to $2 billion from $300 million.

In April, Pedro Bastos, chief executive of HSBC Global Asset Management Latin America, spent three weeks in India. One of the main reasons for the trip was to market the launch of two Brazilian funds. He acknowledges that there have recently been problems raising new funds but remains upbeat about the prospects for growth. “It is a volatile market in terms of assets under management because you get periods like the past six months with the migration back to the developed markets, so the flow of funds to Brazil has not been what we expected,” he says. “That temporary issue should turn positive by the second half of the year. So on a short-term basis we have seen a negative trend but the secular trend is huge: we went from zero to $9 billion from offshore clients in a matter of four-and-a-half years.”

Positive outlook

Pavarina agrees that the outlook for Brazil is positive. “The IOF slowed down the amount of new money coming into the country but we believe that Brazil is a long-term investment and so it doesn’t impact investment decisions for long-term investors. You can dilute the effect of the 6% tax if you hold your investments for three years or so.”

“We joke that in Brazil if you don’t find the right guy, you can have fun with the wrong guys – here, while you wait for good returns on equity, you can have a very nice run with fixed income”

Denise Pavarina, Bradesco Asset Management

Bradesco Asset Management company chief Denise Pavarina

 

She adds that the government’s attempts to dampen inflation have lowered the appetite for equities as monetary tightening is expected to reduce consumption and therefore corporate earnings. “Considering we have a 12% interest rate, which is going up, I think we’ve still got a very good opportunity. We joke that in Brazil if you don’t find the right guy, you can have fun with the wrong guys – here, while you wait for good returns on equity, you can have a very nice run with fixed income.” Brazil’s rising interest rates are also delaying the long-expected but as yet only partial shift away from fixed-income products by domestic institutional investors, the bread and butter of Brazil’s asset managers. Brazilian pension funds now account for about R$500 billion ($309 billion) of assets under management. With restrictions on insurance companies’ ability to invest in equities and risk-averse private and retail investors, the pension fund industry is seen by many as the big source of capital for a new wave of equity investment.

Marcelo Mello is vice-president at SulAmérica, which has just launched at new division dedicated to long-term equity fund strategies. SulAmérica has active relationships with about 100 of the country’s pension funds. Mello says that he expects pension funds to increase their allocation of investment in equities to an average of about 30% in five years, from an estimated 15% to 20% currently.

ABRAPP, the Brazilian Pension Fund Association, says the average equity allocation is 31.5% but this mean average is skewed by huge allocations by a few large funds. The median average is more representative for the industry as a whole.

“Pension funds are definitely going to increase the amount invested in equities but they are also changing the types of equity investment,” says Mello. “In the past they used to manage equity portfolios in a passive way. Now the situation is changing, they are looking to outsource these managers to active investment strategies.” Mello says alpha generation strategies are more popular, not least because an estimated 70% of equity funds have failed to generate alpha in the past six months.

Brazil’s pension fund industry is highly regulated but in 2009 regulation 3792-CMN introduced greater flexibility for investment strategies. Pension funds can now invest up to 70% of their assets in equities, although market rumours suggest this change was made solely to reflect the fact that one of the country’s largest pension funds, Banco do Brasil’s Previl, already comfortably exceeded the previous threshold of 49%.

Pension funds can now, if they satisfy certain conditions, also invest in international assets. In May SulAmérica hosted a conference in São Paulo in association with ING to discuss the possibility of international investments. “I don’t think pension funds will invest outside Brazil any time soon,” says Mello. “As well as Brazil having the world’s highest interest rates, the currency risk for pension funds will be a huge disincentive – and the cost of hedging prohibitive.”

François Racicot, principal at consultancy Mercer, is not so sure. “It’s a question of whether to hedge or not to hedge, but in terms of equity you could certainly make a case on a theoretical basis that you don’t need a hedge. The US stock market has recently outperformed the Bovespa and if you look at other periods before 2002 this was the case as well, so I think there is absolutely a case to be made for pension funds outside of Brazil.” Racicot says he expects some of the larger pension funds to look seriously at overseas investment to diversify risk and return. Foreign investment rules are, however, prescriptive: the funds that pension funds invest in must be domiciled in Brazil even if the investments are foreign, and an individual pension fund cannot own more than 25% of the fund.

Exploration of ideas

This suggests that pension funds theoretically need to find three other funds that are willing to invest in the same assets and manager, and by the same amount. However, Racicot says he expects creative fund managers to seed these funds with their own money so that pension funds can invest and satisfy the rules, then withdraw their own money from the fund as they attract more pension fund investors.

The exploration of new ideas includes a look at alternative investments. Private equity funds have attracted a huge increase in pension fund assets in recent years. Petros, the pension fund for workers of Brazil’s state-controlled oil producer, Petrobras, is alone believed to be invested in 25 private equity funds. Real estate is also becoming more popular, particularly through those funds listed on the stock exchange.

“Pension funds are starting to understand that they need to take a little more risk and diversify a little bit better if they want to be able to beat their actuarial targets in the next two to three years,” says João Scandiuzzi, strategist of BTG Pactual Asset Management. “This will definitely feed into the medium-term shift to equities – it’s already happening and it’s definitely a trend, driven by lower long-term interest rates and a desire for diversification.” BTG is Brazil’s seventh-largest asset manager, with 40% of its $47.5 billion assets managed on behalf of Brazilian institutional investor clients. About 6% of assets come from international clients.

With rising inflation, pension funds are already struggling to hit actuarial targets of returns of 6% above inflation even with CDI (the Brazilian Libor) paying about 12% on an annual basis. Long-term government bonds pay between 5.5% and 5.85% above the consumer price index. A recent Mercer study into the performance of 65 pension funds found that for the past two years the average return had been below INPC and IGP (the two most commonly used measures of inflation) plus 6%. Previously fixed-income strategies had easily made returns above the actuarial target.

If pension funds are being forced to diversify for risk and returns, the same desire for greater returns should also ensure the long-term supply of international capital. “Despite the positive headlines about Brazil in the last couple of years, when we talk to international investors it is clear the Brazil story is still under-explored and not fully understood,” says Bastos at HSBC. “Brazil is not short-term, what is going on here is a secular trend. We’re coming back from two lost decades – before 1999 Brazil grew 6% in two decades. Last year alone it grew 7.5%; GDP per capita is a lot higher than in China and India. I don’t think investors fully appreciate that – there is still a discount in our market. There is a lot of concern about inflation at the moment but in my mind it is very attractive in terms of valuations of about 10.5 times earnings on a forward basis and the corporate sector is doing great: double-digit growth, healthy balance sheets, liquidity in the system and with room for consumer purchasing power to grow.”

Indeed, such is the growth in interest from international and local investors in certain asset classes, such as private equity, that some people question whether the market is mature enough to absorb the expected supply. BTG Pactual Asset Management manages R$4.8 billion through its private equity funds and the company is said to be setting up a new fund to channel fresh money that it recently received from 10 leading international investors.

Scandiuzzi dismisses concerns about a shortage of private ­equity investment targets. “There are lots of opportunities here,” he says. “The real economy is demanding so much investment; we are seeing regional consolidation with industries and the creation of national and regional brands and companies. The financial deepening that is going on is huge. I don’t think finding opportunities for private equity will be a problem.”

Even with the inevitable bumps in the road, Brazil seems set to remain in the fast lane.