BTG Pactual: Premature extrapolation

Claims that BTG Pactual’s proposed link-up with Cerfin will propel the Brazilian bank into global prominence are exaggerated.

BTG Pactual’s announcement that it will merge with, or rather buy, Chile’s Celfin created much media excitement. The prominent coverage from the financial daily media can be taken as yet further evidence of the interest in, and importance of, Latin America. But is this announcement really proof that the prophesized global BTG is coming into existence?

The deal, of course, makes sense for both parties. BTG gets access to a solid Chilean asset management business and one with potential for Andean growth. The Mila project – Chile, Colombia and Peru’s integrated cross-trading platform – is still alive and Celfin is looking to expand into Colombia. And being part of the BTG group will provide Celfin with the access to Brazil that its clients will increasingly value – defending their share of wallet within the Chilean market.

BTG’s ambition for foreign expansion is not a secret. And yet the news that Celfin was in talks with BTG sparked a fresh wave of analysis that the Brazilian bank was on the verge of dominating Latin America, of breaking into the US, of adding significant retail businesses, of becoming a big global bank: a Latin American Goldman Sachs without the bad press. And with consumer banking.

Hold on: the deal is a strategic fit but the press release pertained to negotiations, and was not an announcement of a done deal. Valuing companies such as BTG Pactual ($64.5 billion of assets under management) and Celfin ($5.5 billion) is very hard. The shared strategic-fit logic might have brought the banks to an advanced stage of negotiations but there is many a slip ’twixt cup and lip, and neither side will want to give much ground on valuations should they differ to any great extent.

Even assuming the deal proceeds, and the probabilities favour that eventuality, just how transformational is it? Yes, it strengthens BTG (and Celfin) but it neither swells the Brazilian bank’s size nor hugely extends its regional penetration. Chile is a strong and important market but it is relatively small. Celfin’s activities outside its home market are small and its growth, of course, is unknowable. Mila offers some potential but the proposed integration of the Peruvian and Colombian stock exchanges has been scrapped. In short, Chile does not present unfettered access to a new pan-Andean region.

Sure, it is an important step in BTG Pactual’s international expansion. However, talk about a new international superbank is far too premature and, as such, unhelpful. Further international acquisitions might well come but each will be difficult to identify, value, negotiate and integrate. Lazy projections of global domination don’t do justice to the difficulties presented to BTG’s undoubted ambition.