Brazil: Do LatAm equity issuers need foreign bank leads?

As domestic equity markets grow, Wall Street firms will lose their dominance of new issues.

With the Bovespa down 10%, Brazil’s equity market is among the worst performers this year. In part this is for technical reasons. Bankers say that with global emerging equity funds so overweight Brazil, investors have to sell existing positions in Brazilian companies to buy new shares. Throw in the large outflows of emerging markets equities earlier this year and the impact that the sell-off of commodities has had on some of the Bovespa’s leading companies and explanation of the index’s poor performance becomes clearer.

Brazil’s difficulties, however, are proving a boon to Latin America’s other equity markets, which have been largely dormant until recently. Non-Brazilian equity deals have fared well – note the IPO of Argentine fast-food operator Arcos Dorados, which attracted over $10 billion of demand for a $1.25 billion offering. Other deals are expected in Argentina as well as in Colombia and Chile. Mexico too is reported to be particularly strong for the second half of the year. And Brazil, though probably more fitful, is still going to provide at least half the region’s supply for the foreseeable future.

But which banks will benefit from Latin American equity deals? The R$5.5 billion Brazilian steel company Gerdau follow-on transaction was managed by BTG Pactual, Bradesco and Itaú – all local firms. A Bloomberg report that looked at the absence of Wall Street firms from the mandate quoted Jean-Marc Etlin, vice-president for investment banking at Itaú, as saying: “It’s a sign of the times. Brazilian companies and entrepreneurs are learning that they don’t need a foreign bank to help them with their financing needs. Local banks have got what it takes to do even the most sophisticated deal.”

So move over Wall Street? Well, perhaps not. That Gerdau sale has attracted criticism from some who point to the 3% fall in the share price as evidence of sub-optimal execution. One bank reports that it received an allocation of 10 million shares for retail investors at the last minute, a sure sign that bookbuilding had been slow. Those with a clear interest in maintaining Wall Street’s involvement in Latin American sales say global investors still want to see a non-Latin American bank as joint lead on a deal as an endorser of its quality (let’s ignore for the moment arguments about whether Brazilian banks have the same access to US and European investors).

It’s impossible to say unequivocally who’s right. It’s undeniable that Brazil’s local banks have strong equity platforms. Itaú and BTG Pactual are leading the way for Brazil’s equity deals, and their market share is likely to grow given that domestic investors are set to become bigger buyers of shares. But there does seem, at least for now, to be a role for the international banks, especially for the larger deals.

If an international investment bank had been leading on Gerdau’s follow-on sale would the share price have dipped? We can never know, but while there is that uncertainty, it is still a brave CFO that goes exclusively local on the big deals.