Brazil, Russia, India and China have let South Africa into their common talking club, the so-called Brics. South Africa represents Africa as a whole. Yet its mediocre growth contrasts vividly with the rise of financial markets elsewhere on the continent.
South African banks expanding north of the border expect the proportion of their revenue from the rest of Africa to grow. But not radically, partly because they think banking in South Africa can grow almost as fast as in the rest of Africa – an unlikely prospect.
South Africa’s economy has long been constrained by its inability to lift the majority out of poverty, hampered by inadequate infrastructure, especially electricity and transport. South Africa’s wealthy are now as over-indebted as western consumers. Banks are finally getting round to banking South Africa’s unbanked. But mass-market banking, which in South Africa is still mostly transactional rather than loan-oriented, might not be a game-changer for the country.
There was an interesting cartoon in a Johannesburg business daily recently. It showed a riot policeman rolling out barbed wire in front of a barrier labelled ‘Commodities boom’. It seemed to refer to the supposed damage done to South Africa’s mining sector by overblown talk of mine nationalization and the formation of a National Mining Company.
“Watch South Africa go the other way,” adds a Johannesburg banker to his recent description of pro-market reforms in the rest of Africa. There is still a lot of scaremongering about the ANC’s understandable desire to spread the nation’s wealth – mineral and otherwise. But perhaps the riot policeman in the cartoon was also alluding to how income inequality, still among the worst in the world, and the resulting social divisions might be the biggest potential problems.
The sketch also hinted at nationalistic hurt at a further phenomenon: the erosion of South Africa’s economic predominance in Africa. South Africa accounts for 30% of sub-Saharan Africa’s GDP but just 6% of its population. The rise of the rest of Africa in proportion to South Africa is therefore a good thing.
South Africa’s economy will benefit, just as the US benefits from China’s rise. South Africa’s banks and corporations are already getting vital revenue growth from the rest of Africa – the continent still needs their capital and their technical expertise. But the predominance of the Johannesburg Stock Exchange, for one, will decline.
The JSE is unlikely to attract listings from elsewhere in Africa, where other nations have ambitions for their stock exchanges too. Also (although this might change) the proportion of the assets of South African retirement funds that they are allowed to invest in non-African foreign companies listed on the JSE is lower than the proportion they can invest in JSE-listed companies from the rest of Africa. The rule is irrelevant for small firms but it has sapped liquidity in the JSE’s only big Africa listing, Nigerian energy group Oando.
Angola, Ghana, Kenya, Nigeria and Zambia, then: these are Africa’s real Brics.
Nigeria will be the continent’s leader, both in diplomacy and in financial markets. And so it should be: it is by far Africa’s most populous country. Also, even more than South Africa, Nigeria needs the national pride of continental leadership to help it overcome its ethnic and religious divisions.
However, South Africa’s lacklustre economy holds a valuable lesson for the rest of the continent: banks must invest in a sustainable boom, one that doesn’t fizzle out when a tiny elite is saturated with debt, when foreign investors tire of the pitch, or when commodity prices fall.
Lending to extravagant consumers at the top of society is one thing. Funding gleaming shopping malls with unsurfaced access roads is another. Financing private jets, and palaces surrounded by slums, is worse. But it all happens in some of Africa’s least-developed countries.
Banks that really value Africa should help themselves by helping Africa and concentrating on what Africa, like South Africa, needs first – infrastructure, especially electricity, and transport. The rest will follow.